Bioethics In Africa: A Contextually Enlightened Analysis Of Three Cases

Abstract

Across sub-Saharan Africa, bioethics is an emerging field of scholarly inquiry informed by contextual features distinct to the region. a cultural mix comprised of European influences, indigenous traditions, Christian faiths, and Muslim communities, a bioethics for the sub-Saharan region must be responsive to this milieu. This paper asks: What values and methods can best promote the practice of bioethics in Africa? We set forth a strategy that leans one way or another in response to the contextual features of a particular setting. Since our aim is to be responsive to context, we begin with a series of cases and develop values and methods in response to each case as we work through its ethical analysis. Section 1 introduces a case involving setting priorities for public funding of services that produce large benefits for a small group of people, using the example of dialysis in Ghana. Section 11 presents a situation involving determining the permissibility of a double standard of quality for healthcare devices in rich and poor nations, using the example of explanting peacemakers from deceased people in wealthy nations for use by people in low and middle-income nations. Section 111 describes a scenario where international groups clash with religious and spiritual healers over the chaining of people with severe mental illness at prayer camps and healing centres in Ghana. Section IV articulates a three-pronged strategy for engaging in bioethics brought to light by the case analyses and defends it against objections. Throughout the paper, we tag certain views as African and others as Western to indicate ethical beliefs commonly found in these regions and less commonly found elsewhere. We do not mean to imply that all Africans hold a certain ethical stance or that all Westerners do, nor do we mean to suggest that people outside these regions do not hold the views in question.