MANAGEMENT OF CHILDHOOD DIARRHOEA IN RURAL GHANA: THE CASE OF PUTE IN THE DANGME-EAST DISTRICT BY MARTIN HUSHIE A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIOLOGY IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF PHILOSOPHY AT THE UNIVERSITY OF GHANA, LEGON. OCTOBER, 1994 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh £48851 R j ^5'6rD£ H 95 1W, “fXwOVf\ University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh DEDICATION THIS STUDY IS DEDICATED TO MY PARENTS CORLEY AND KORKOR, AND MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (i) DECLARATION I, MARTIN HUSHIE HEREBY DECLARE THAT, THIS THESIS CONTAINS NO MATERIAL WHICH HAS BEEN ACCEPTED FOR THE AWARD OF OTHER DEGREE IN ANY UNIVERSITY, THAT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, THIS THESIS CONTAINS NO MATERIAL PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED OR WRITTEN BY ANOTHER PERSON, EXCEPT WHEN DUE REFERENCE HAS BEEN MADE IN THE TEXT. MARTIN HUSHIE 31/10/94 (SUPERVISOR) 31/10/94 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh ACKNOWLEDGEMENT (ii) It is a worthwhile tradition to show appreciation to all people who contribute in diverse ways to make work of this nature 'a dream come true'. I wish to thank all Lecturers of the Sociology Department, Legon, who were overtly or covertly associated with the study. A special mention must be made of my supervisor, Mr. K.A. Senah who was very much helpful in the initial formulation of the research problem; and who in spite of his numerous engagements has actively involved himself at all stages of the study. I wish to record my gratitude for his insightful comments and invaluable dynamism. I am also particularly grateful to Dr. L.O. Gyekye of the Institute of Statistical, Social & Economic Research (ISSER), University of Ghana Legon, who was my primary source of inspiration. The enthusiastic interest of my friends has also been a perpetual source of encouragement. Special recognition is given to Mr. James Kofi Appiah-Benhin who took time off his packed schedule to do the computer analysis of field data as well as typing of the first draft. I also feel particularly privileged to have been associated with Delasi Amable, Edzodzinam Tsikata, Kojo Arhinful and Richard Afari, all of the 1991 Postgraduate Sociology Class. Other indefatigable friends are Lawrence Y. Appiah-Baiden, Godfried Addo, A.A. Apeadu and Mr. A. Addo-Kwafo. To all of them, I am most grateful. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (iii) The help and moral support given by Kofi Hushie, Essie and Soyoo- Dede, is also very much appreciated. That this study could have been conducted at all is owed to the active participation and co-operation of the people of Pute. In particular, I wish to express my thankfulness to Mr. Sarbah - the Assemblyman, as well as the Chief and his elders. The willingness of mothers to co-operate even whilst attending to their children in most cases is highly commended. My indebtedness is also owed to Pearl Adiki Puplampu - my special field assistant, Ruby Tetteh and Vera Agormeda who conducted most of the interviews. Ms. Sylvia Osei, Mr. Jones Kpelie and Ms. Elizabeth Dadson, did a good job editing this work. To them I am deeply indebted. The last but most important acknowledgement goes to the Imperceptible Force behind all of this "LE DIEU TOUT - PUISSANT". Whilst acknowledging these diverse helps, I wish to state that I must be held responsible for any shortcomings found in this study. M.H. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (iv) ABSTRACT The main thrust of this study is to investigate how childhood diarrhoea is managed at Pute - a rural community in Ghana. The study aims at eliciting local perceptions of childhood diarrhoea, including cause(s), consequences, and appropriate treatment, so as to unearth some of the social and cultural factors that may influence health-seeking behaviour in diarrhoeal episodes. To understand fully folk concepts of diarrhoea and its treatment, it was necessary to describe the social and institutional setting within which illness episodes are managed in order to lay the basis for interpreting findings from the study. To this end, the social structure of Pute was outlined. Pute is a small Dangme-speaking rural community, located some 118 kilometers from central Accra. It is predominantly a fishing community in which descent and kinship groupings form the basis of social, economic, religious and political organisations. Contact with Western society has set in motion a process of change which is gradually promoting a breakdown of traditional cosmology. In order to obtain in-depth information on folk nosologies of childhood diarrhoea and its treatment, three major methodological approaches were used. These are interviewing, focus group discussions and observation. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh The conceptual framework that was used for organising field data on ethnomedical models of diarrhoeal illness is a cultural construction that establishes a web of relationship among social factors, illness experience, help-seeking and outcome. The study has shown that folk classificatory systems for diarrhoea based mainly on physical notions of etiology determined to a very large extent therapeutic choices and hence help-seeking patterns. In particular, it has been shown that, the interpretations of specific diarrhoeal illness episodes, and specific health-seeking actions of mothers were not merely shaped by signs and symptoms, and that a wide range of factors enter into the establishment of illness identification and health-care decision-making. These include classification of a diarrhoeal ailment, perceived seriousness, availability of regimens and efficacy of treatment, all of which were found to be deeply rooted in ethnomedical models of diarrhoeal illness and its treatment. As a consequence, it has been found that, the widespread use of pharmaceuticals, especially antibiotics in the treatment of childhood diarrhoea should be considered a product of the local socio-cultural system in which illness episodes occur. To this end, it is being suggested that, programme planners for the control of diarrhoeal diseases need to take cognisance of popular health culture and home care behaviour in rural settings such as Pute, if the promotion of ORT (including ORS) as the most effective modern approach to the treatment of most childhood diarrhoeas is to become effective. (V) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (Vi) This thesis is in five main parts with sub-divisions under each chapter. Chapter one, which sets out the introduction outlines the problem, objectives, the conceptual framework, the methodological approach to the study, the usefulness of the study as well as its broad limitations. Chapter two, is devoted to a review of literature related to diarrhoeal illness management in different cultural contexts of the world. Chapter three takes a look at the social organisation of the people under study and their general world-view. Chapter four presents the main findings and interpretation of analysed field data. Chapter five is a summary of main findings, policy implications of the study as well as suggested areas for further research. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE DECLARATION ....................................... i ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................... ii ABSTRACT .......................................... iv LIST OF TABLES .................................... xi LIST OF FIGURES ................................... xiii APPENDIX ......................................... xiv CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION ................................ 1 1.0 Statement of the Problem .................... 1 1.1 Objectives of the Study ......................... 11 1.2 Conceptual Framework ............................ 13 1.3 Key Concepts ................................ 19 1.4 Methodology ................................. 20 1.4.0 Field Setting .............................. 20 1.4.1 Data Collection Techniques .................. 21 1.4.2 Sampling .............................. 24 1.4.3 Pre-Testing ........................... 26 1.4.4 Procedure for Fieldwork .............. 27 1.4.5 Data Processing and Analysis ......... 27 1.4.6 Field Problems Encountered ............ 2 8 1.5 Implications of the Study ................... 28 1.6 Study Limitations ........................... 29 1.7 Outline of Thesis ........................... 30 (vii) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (viii) CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF LITERATURE ......................... 32 2.0 Introduction ................................. 32 2.1 Summary ...................................... 49 CHAPTER THREE THE SOCIAL STRUCTURE OF PUTE ................. 51 3 . 0 Introduction .................. . 51 3.1 Geographical Location ....................... 51 3.2 Historical Links ............................ 53 3.3 Popultion Structure ......................... 54 3.4 Economic Activities ......................... 55 3.5 Kinship and Family Life ..................... 57 3.6 Political System ............................ 66 3.7 Religion .................................... 67 3.8 Medicine .................................... 73 3.9 Social Change ............................... 75 3.10 Summary ..................................... 80 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh CHAPTER FOUR MANAGEMENT OF CHILDHOOD DIARRHOEA ........... 81 4.0 Introduction ................................. 81 4.1 Socio-demographic characteristics of the Respondents 81 4.1.0 Maternal Education .................... 81 4.1.1 Religious Background .................. 82 4.1.2 Occupational Background................ 82 4.1.3 Maternal Age............................ 83 4.1.4 Parity ................................. 83 4.2 Illness Taxonomy ............................ 85 4.3 Ethnoclassification of Diarrhoea ............ 87 4.4 Perceptions and Treatment of Diarrhoea ...... 96 4.4.0 Prevalence of Diarrhoea ............... 96 4.4.1 Recognition of Diarrhoea .............. 97 4.4.2 Feeding During Diarrhoea .............. 100 4.4.3 Fluid Intake during Diarrhoea ......... 104 4.4.4 Perceived Consequences of Diarrhoea .... 107 4.4.5 Perceptions of Dehydration ............ 109 4.5 Patterns of Help-Seeking and Treatment in Diarrhoeal Episodes ....................... 110 4.6 The Quest for Therapy in Diarrhoeal Episodes ... 116 4.7 The Context of Diarrhoeal Illness Management ... 12 0 4.8 Hierarchy of Resort in Diarrhoeal Episodes ... 124 4.9 Decision-Making in the Quest for Therapy ..... 125 4.10 Oral Rehydration Therapy ...................... 131 (ix)University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 4.11.1 Knowledge and Use of ORT .............. 132 4.11.2 Correlates of ORS Use ................. 136 4.11.3 Education and Knowledge and Use of ORS. 137 4.11.4 Religion by Use of ORS................. 140 4.11.5 Parity and Use of ORS.................. 141 4.11.6 Maternal Age and Use of ORS ........... 143 4.12 Summary ................................ 145 CHAPTER FIVE (x) 5.0 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION 147 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh LIST OF TABLES 3.1 Population Distribution by Ages and Sexes.... 55 3.2 Distribution of Economically Active Population 56 3.3 School Attendance by Ages and Sexes ......... 75 4.1 Level of Maternal Education ................. 82 4.2 Religious Affiliation of Mothers ............ 82 4.3 Occupational Distribution of Mothers ........ 83 4.4 Age Distribution of Mothers ................. 83 4.5 Parity of Mothers ........................... 84 4.6 Childhood Diseases at Pute .................. 86 4.7 Folk Taxonomy of Diarrhoeal Illness ......... 88 4.8 Mothers' Definition of Diarrhoea by Number of Stools Observed...................... 99 4.9 Signs and Symptoms Associated with Diarrhoea. 100 4.10 Mothers' conception of a child being more (or less) hungry during diarrhoea .................. 102 4.11 Food Intake during diarrhoea ................ 102 4.12 Mothers' concept of whether a child is more (or less) thirsty during diarrhoea ....... 105 4.13 Fluid intake during diarrhoea ..... 106 4.14 Fluids given during a recent diarrhoeal episode 107 4.15 Perceptions of dehydration .................. 110 4.16 First line of Action ........................ 112 4.17 Type of self-medication by traditional treatments ................................. 113 (xi) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 4.18 Type of self-medication by biomedical treatments .................................... 113 4.19 Specific pharmaceuticals used in the treatment of Diarrhoea ........................ 114 4.20 Second line of Action ............................ 115 4.21 Self-medication by biomedical treatments 116 4.22 Reasons for first action taken on recognition of diarrhoea .................................. 12 6 4.23 Reasons for second action taken "when diarrhoea did not Stop" ........................ 131 4.24 Knowledge and use of ORS by level of Maternal Education ..................................... 138 4.25 Significant correlations between socio-demographic characteristics of mothers and use of ORS . 138 4.26 Use of ORS and Religious Background .............. 140 4.27 Parity by Use of ORS ............................. 143 4.2 8 Age-group of Mothers by use of ORS ............... 144 (xii) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (xiii) LIST OF FIGURES 1 Cultural Construction of Diarrhoeal Illness: Interrelationship of Social Factors, Illness Experience, Help-seeking and Outcome....... 17 2 Cultural Context of ORT .................... 18 3 Map of the Dangme East District Showing the Location of the Study Area - Pute......... 52 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (xiv) APPENDIX A Interview Schedule ............................ 160 B Guide Questions for Focus Group Discussions .... 170 C References ..................................... 172 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh CHAPTER 1 1 INTRODUCTION 1.0 Statement of the Problem The prime concern of this study is to investigate the social and cultural contexts in which childhood diarrhoea is managed in rural Ghana. Pute, a rural community in the Dangme East District of the Greater Accra Region of Ghana has been chosen as a case-study. This study is devoted to understanding folk concepts of childhood diarrhoea, including local interpretations of cause(s), course and treatment, and how these influence health-seeking behaviour in diarrhoeal episodes. Diarrhoeal diseases pose a major worldwide health problem, and are frequently associated with poverty, malnutrition and infection, killing between 5 and 7 million people each year. It is also estimated that about one billion episodes of diarrhoea occur each year in the 3 regions of Africa, Asia and Latin America, resulting in approximately 5 million deaths of children less than 5 years of age (Snyder and Merson 1982, WHO 1990) . Diarrhoea is also known to complicate several other diseases; the severity of measles, malnutrition and malaria is heightened by associated attacks of diarrhoea. (Scrimschaw et al. 1966; Martorell et al. 1975; Rowland et al. 1977; Mata 1978; Koster et al. 1981) . Many poverty-related factors are seen to be important in the prevalence of these conditions. Inadequate and overcrowded housing increases the transmission rates of many diseases. Insanitation, lack of University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh drainage facilities and inadequate supply of potable water results in a contaminated environment, creating ideal breeding sites for insect vectors. Furthermore, various factors including inadequate nutrition and illiteracy contribute to low levels of domestic hygiene and hence the prevalence of diarrhoeal diseases. In Ghana, diarrhoeal diseases have been one of the serious public health problems. They are second only to malaria among children under five years seen at outpatient clinics. They account for 6.7 percent of total attendances. It is also estimated that 10 percent of diarrhoeal diseases are fatal and that 70 percent of these fatalities are due to acute dehydration. In addition, 10 percent of deaths in hospitalised children under five years are attributable to diarrhoea alone or in association with measles, malaria and malnutrition (MOH 1992). Britwum et al. (1986) reported a mean incidence of diarrhoeal diseases of 1.9 episodes per child per year in a rural Ghanaian community, with the highest incidence occurring in children between the ages of 7 and 12 months. According to the Ghana Demographic Health Survey (GDHS 1988), the two week diarrhoeal incidence rate in children under five years was 26 percent. In 1992 this figure was put at 30.2 percent (MOH 1992) . Afari et al. (1988) also showed an annual diarrhoeal incidence rate of 4.5 episodes per child per year. This amounts to approximately 10 million episodes of diarrhoea per year in children under five. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh The reduction of morbidity and mortality associated with childhood diseases in developed countries was achieved through comprehensive approaches. This entailed major improvements in living conditions through the provision of facilities such as pipe-borne water, safe sewerage disposal, higher standards of housing, health-care, home hygiene, improved nutrition and universal education for all segments of society. The Alma Ata Declaration of 1978 which proposed a "Health for All by the Year 2 000" through Primary Health Care (PHC) in developing countries was conceived in a similar vein. Yet such holistic approaches have often been considered unrealistic as a long-term prospect in most developing countries in view of the economic recession and shrinking health budgets that confront them. Consequently international health experts, aid agencies and governments are focusing on Selective Primary Health Care in which a few high risk groups are targeted with a few carefully selected, cost-effective interventions, though the verticality of current programmes has been the target of harsh criticisms (Gish 1982, Unger and Killingsworth 1986) . To implement this new strategy, the emphasis has been on the promotion of immunisation and Oral Rehydration Therapy (ORT) as simple projects in the attempt to improve child health. International attention to the promotion of ORT for childhood diarrhoea began with the establishment of the World Health Organisation (WHO) Programme for the Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases (CDD) in 1978, as part of global commitment to Primary Health Care University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh (PHC). The objectives of the programme are to reduce diarrhoeal mortality in infants and children worldwide by one-half, and to reduce morbidity and malnutrition associated with diarrhoeal illness. The Government of Ghana has since 1983 implemented a CDD programme as part of a nation-wide PHC programme. The programme emphasises five main strategies for the prevention and control of diarrhoea. These are 1. effective case management; 2. encouragement of breastfeeding, weaning practices and nutrition; 3. proper environmental sanitation; 4. provision of good drinking water and, 5. immunisation of children against measles. The focus of this programme is the promotion of ORT which has now become the mainstay of the treatment for life-threatening diarrhoeal diseases both epidemic cholera and childhood diarrhoeas. ORT is the use of appropriate fluids including Oral Rehydration Salts (ORS) as the most effective treatment for patients who are suffering from dehydration due to diarrhoea. Under the multilateral sponsorship of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), the MOH of Ghana and a local private drug University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh manufacturing firm (DANAFCO), the production and marketing of ORS packets was formally launched in April 1988 to promote home management of childhood diarrhoea through oral rehydration. Hitherto, ORS packets were being donated by UNICEF to the MOH for free distribution through its service outlets. ORS packets approved by WHO and UNICEF contain: 3.5g sodium chloride, 1.5g potassium chloride, 2.9g trisodium citrate, and 20g anhydrous glucose. Promotional strategies in Ghana include public education, commercial advertising and sales and use of mass-media. Currently the consumer price per packet is about £120 (US$0.13). The focus of this programme has been home treatment of acute diarrhoea with oral solutions of packaged rehydration salts (ORS) or household sugar and salt solution (SSS) to replace body fluids and prevent life-threatening dehydration. The introduction of CDD programme activities and other diarrhoea- related intervention programmes in many developing countries since the early 1980s has led to considerable increase in access to ORS and use of ORT at the global level (WHO/CDD 1990) . ORS is being produced in about half of the developing countries. Surveys conducted in a number of countries have indicated that on the University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh average, the hospital admission rate for diarrhoea dropped by 61 percent after the introduction of ORT and the average case fatality rate was reduced by 71 percent (Cleason and Merson 1990). Since the introduction of the CDD programme in Ghana, two impact assessments of it have taken place in 1989 and 1992 respectively. The 1992 survey revealed among others that awareness of ORS among mothers had increased from 56 percent in 1989 to 80 percent in 1992 . Access to ORS had also increased only 16 percent of mothers had to travel more than 5 kilometres to obtain ORS as compared to 25 percent in 1989. Also treatment practices had improved as 31 percent of mothers gave ORT in 1992 as compared to 19 percent in 1989 (MOH 1989, 1992) . Despite the progress made, appropriate case management of childhood diarrhoea tends to be the exception rather than the rule and as a result, CDD programmes have not been able to achieve fully their set goals and objectives. It is the view of the present study that programme planners for diarrhoeal diseases have not adequately considered the implications of indigenous health beliefs and practices surrounding diarrhoeal illness in rural communities for their programme work. During the past decade however, it has become increasingly recognised that the ultimate control of diarrhoeal diseases depends on a comprehensive understanding of local beliefs and practices that relate positively or negatively to its transmission (Elmendorf and Isely 1983, Nations 1982, de Zoysa University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1984) . Noting the importance of the mother in childhood diarrhoeal episodes WHO observed: "There is an urgent need to understand her present attitudes, perceptions and practices regarding diarrhoea as well as those of other community workers" (WHO 1982) . In most cases, the tendency has been for research funds to be allocated to more conventional areas of disease control such as epidemiology, biomedical research and health economics, while cultural factors are to a very large extent neglected. Successful community-based programmes for the control of diarrhoeal diseases depend on mothers or other caretakers knowing how to manage diarrhoea with food and fluids and recognising when children need treatment by a health worker. In the quest for therapy, families may resort to various approaches both modern and traditional health regimens. The choice of approach however depends on the ethnoclassification of diarrhoea, what is seen as its cause and the availability of health care (Paredes 1992) . To improve health, public health programmes often concentrate on strategies for convincing people to comply with professional recommendations. In the case of diarrhoea, the emphasis has been on the promotion of ORT - the discovery of which is regarded as "potentially the most important medical advance in this century" (WHO 1991). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh Although pragmatic by biomedical standards, these recommendations may seem "irrational" in the community because they are at odds with local beliefs and practices. Health professionals who understand local perceptions of diarrhoeal illness are better able to communicate with the people they serve. They can understand how puzzling biomedical explanations might sound in the community and they can explain recommendations for prevention and treatment in a manner that makes them acceptable within the context of local beliefs and practices. Moreover, certain characteristics of diarrhoea management (ie ORT and dietary practices) make cultural knowledge particularly relevant. These include:- 1. the fact that the management of diarrhoea is home- based and controlled by the child's mother or other caretakers as opposed to services located outside the household; 2. the fact that it is focused on a specific category of maladies for which local terminology and explanatory models exhibit extreme diversity; and, 3 . the fact that existing traditional therapies for digestive disorders generally and diarrhoea in particular are everywhere well developed and firmly well rooted in ethnomedical systems. Thus diarrhoea treatment lends itself to contextual analysis. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh Although various surveys provide a dramatic confirmation that diarrhoeal disease is a major health problem in Ghana (Britwum et al. 1986; Afari et al. 1988; GDHS 1988), they necessarily focus to a large extent on broad socio-demographic data and general morbidity and mortality patterns without delving into the complex complementary area of local beliefs and practices associated with childhood diarrhoea. There are a few studies touching on this area of enquiry (Adjei 1988, Abu 1988). Yet these are scattered and largely unpublished. The main task of this study is to understand folk concepts of diarrhoea and its treatment. Attempts have been made to raise culturally relevant issues that might be missed by macro surveys but might have important implications for community-based health programmes for the control of diarrhoeal diseases. Mothers' ethnomedical models of childhood diarrhoeal illness and concepts of appropriate treatment have been examined in terms of their most receptive and resistant points to modern approaches to the prevention and treatment of diarrhoea. The analysis made in this study is based on the view that, the socio-cultural environment (including political, economic and psychological aspects) is only one among a multiplicity of factors influencing illness behaviour and for that matter health-seeking behaviour. Other factors are biological and physical. Cultural University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh beliefs and attitudes have been found to be very important in shaping response to diseases (Maina-Ahlberg 1984) . Fosu (1984) observed that, ethnomedical concepts of disease causation affected therapeutic choices in Ghana. Although diarrhoea is not found among children alone, this study focuses on infant and childhood diarrhoea for two important reasons. Firstly, it is widely recognised that acute diarrhoeal diseases are a leading cause of morbidity and mortality in children under five years of age especially in developing countries. Published studies in Africa, Asia and Latin America have shown that children under one year of age may have on the average 5 episodes of diarrhoea a year while children between 1 and 2 years old may even have more episodes than their counterparts aged between 3 and 4 years. (Snyder and Merson 1982, Parker 1984, WHO 1988) . This fact has been documented in Ghana by Afari et al. (1988); Britwum et al. (1986) and the GDHS (1988) . Secondly, most of the diarrhoeal diseases which kill children can be averted through the appropriate use of ORT. The relevance of ORT in diarrhoeal diseases is best expressed in the summary of an international conference on ORT: "The experience reported at this conference unequivocally confirms that, oral rehydration therapy can reduce mortality, sometimes drastically in communities, clinics and hospitals; promote child growth and sound nutrition; lessen the morbidity burden; reduce hospitalisation attendance, duration of stay and cost; and generate auxilliary benefits such as minimising the indiscriminate use of ineffective or harmful drugs (Chen 1983)". University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1.1 Objectives of the Study In pursuing the research problem, the study focuses on the following issues: - 1 . to highlight some of the traditional health beliefs and practices associated with childhood diarrhoea at Pute; 2. to show the extent to which these beliefs and practices influence the choice of both modern and traditional health care regimens for the treatment of diarrhoea; 3. to make appropriate recommendations based on the findings of the study; Specifically the following questions are framed to guide the study:- 1. What is the folk classification of childhood diarrhoeal disease with respect to types and causes at Pute? 2. What features of a diarrhoeal ailment do mothers- consider important in the process of diagnosis? 3. What indigenous beliefs exist about food and fluid intake during diarrhoea? 4. What are the perceived consequences of childhood diarrhoea? 5. What are the perceptions of dehydration due to diarrhoea? 6. To what extent are local concepts of childhood diarrhoea related to specific health care regimens that are used in diarrhoeal episodes and hence patterns of help-seeking? 7. What are the factors underlying the decision to use or not to use specific health care regimens in the quest for therapy? 8. Do mothers at Pute know of ORS? What do they think it is used for? Have they ever used it? What are the reasons for non-use if they know or have heard of it before? University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh The following hypotheses are framed to guide the discussions in later chapters:- (1) The choice of modern scientific approaches to the treatment of childhood diarrhoea depends on folk nosologies, etiologies and consequences as well as treatment for various diarrhoeal illness categories. (2) The use or non-use of ORT (including ORS) is a function of the educational level of mothers or other caretakers of the child. Educated mothers are more likely to use ORT as a remedy for the prevention and treatment of diarrhoea than uneducated mothers. An attempt will be made to test these hypotheses by analysing the beliefs and practices of the people of Pute regarding diarrhoeal illness and its treatment. A study of this nature requires a setting that will permit an in- depth examination of behaviours during illness episodes. In this respect, Pute1, a Dangme rural community in the Greater Accra Region of Ghana was chosen for the case-study. An important characteristic feature of Pute that makes it suitable for an investigation of this nature is that it has a high incidence of diarrhoeal illness and is therefore in great need of diarrhoeal control efforts. Elsewhere in this study, other reasons have been outlined to show why this particular community was chosen. Chapter Three gives a detailed description of this rural community University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1.2 Conceptual Framework A study such as this and which is aimed at investigating the socio­ cultural context of diarrhoeal illness and treatment requires a cultural construction that establishes a web of relationship among social factors, illness experience, help seeking and outcome. To this effect, Weiss' (1988) proposed conceptual framework has been adapted for use. This framework is based on concepts developed by medical anthropologists in the contextual studies of diarrhoeal illness. Weiss places these concepts under four major headings as follows: patterns of distress; explanatory models/patterns of help- seeking and specific treatments. Patterns of distress refer to the range of symptoms that the local people complain about and the ways they experience the effects of the illness. Traditional people may base their distress patterns on any one or more of the following features of the diarrhoeal illness: 1. quality of the diarrhoeal stool; 2. other signs and symptoms; 3. perceived seriousness; 4. perceived vulnerability to complications or other kinds of distress,- 5. level of anxiety; 6. disturbed interpersonal relationships; 7. spiritual obligations, concerns and supports; 8. local ideas about illness that refer to diarrhoea as a primary or incidental feature. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh In contrast, clinicians considering the signs and symptoms will diagnose a microscopic pathogen or describe tissue pathology or pathophysiology. Explanatory models characterise the meaning people attribute to illness as they try to explain it. This concept specifies perceived causes of diarrhoeal illness - particularly physical, social, supernatural, humoral and other explanations - with reference to the underlying system of beliefs in different cultural settings. Different explanatory models specify the following causes for diarrhoeal illness in many cultures: 1. foods that are fatty, not cooked adequately, heavy, etc; 2. imbalance of heat and cold that may be associated with foods, exposure to drafts or seasonal changes; 3. normal or poor quality breast milk; 4. physical factors, such as a fall or poor caretaking; 5. supernatural causes including possession of sorcery or evil eye; 6. pollution from exposure to or inauspicious contact with ritually impure persons or things; 7 - moral misbehaviour, including deeds of the sick person or a sick child's parents, especially promiscuous sex and sexual intercourse or pregnancy whilst breastfeeeding; 8. natural consequence of milestones especially teething, crawling and walking; 9. infection which may be associated with hygiene and sanitation (but which may be difficult to distinguish from ideas about pollution). 14University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh In every culture, especially traditional societies, people seek help for distress from various sources. Help providers are associated with modern or traditional medical systems, religious healers or community leaders or other local institutions. Preferences for medical help-seeking may vary according to features of the illness; socio-demographic characteristics of the individual family; the reputation, availability, and prior experiences with various sources of medical help or other factors. Specific treatments refer to the diverse group of medical help providers in the community, knowledgeable relatives and others in the social network who may recommend an equally diverse array of treatments. They fall under the following broad categories: 1. adjusting diet and fluid intake or withholding foods or fluids; 2. changing breastfeeding routines; 3. cleansing the gastrointestinal tract with enemas, purgatives and emetics; 4. local herbal remedies; 5. ritual and devotional practices to promote spiritual healing; 6. other locally sanctioned interventions (eg. abdominal massage, manipulation of the soft palate and skin over fontanel, cutting gums for teething diarrhoea etc; 7. cosmopolitan medicines, including antimotility agents, adsorbents, and antibiotics; 8. ORT (including ORS). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh As figures 1 and 2 (see overleaf) show, each of these sets of variables which together constitute the 'cultural construction of illness', represents a facet of the complex relationship between a disease and the cultural context in which it occurs. These variable sets proposed by Weiss (1988) to characterise diarrhoeal illness-related beliefs and practices patterns of distress, explanatory models, help seeking and treatment practices provide an appropriate framework for organising field data on ethnomedical models of diarrhoeal illness in the community under study, and for generating hypotheses that relate perceptions and the experience of illness to relevant public health outcomes. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 17 Social'' ?ontexM Patterns ofdistress i Humoral Spiritual Physical Pollution Milestones Infection Socioeconomic General education Health education Sanitation & hygiene Feeding & breastfeeding Health & nutrition Environment Biomedical diagnosis Incidence Course Outcome Explanatory Models Family Community leaders Local healers Hospital clinic Private physician Signs (e.g., stool quality) Symptoms Perceived seriousness Features ol dehydration Designated (oik category Fig. I. Cultural construction o f diarrheal illness: interrelationship o f social factors, illness experience, help seeking and outcome. Source : Weiss M. G. , Cultural Models of Diarrhoeal Illness : Conceptual Framework and Review. Soc. Sci, Med., Vol. 27, p p .6, 1988. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh Fig. 2. C u l t u r a l co n tex t o f O R T. Source: Weiss M .G., Cultural Models of Diarrhoeal Illness : Conseptual Framework and Review, Soc. Sci, Med., Vol. 27, No. 1 pp. 7, 1988. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1.3 Key Concepts It is appropriate that in a study of this nature the various concepts used are defined in order to do away with any ambiguity in the mind of the reader. Specifying the meanings of the concepts will also facilitate the reading and understanding of the study. These concepts are therefore defined below. 1. DIARRHOEA A brief survey of diarrhoeal diseases literature depicts varying levels of heterogeneity in the use of the term diarrhoea. (Black et al. 1982). For the purposes of this study however, WHO's recommended definition will be used. Diarrhoea is defined clinically as the excretion of three or more liquid or semi liquid stools during a 24 hour period. (WHO 1988) . Two main forms of diarrhoea are recognised by WHO: acute and persistent. Acute diarrhoea refers to episodes that last less than one week. Persistent diarrhoea on the other hand is an episode which starts acutely but which lasts at least 14 days (Dialogue on diarrhoea, No. 48 1992) . 2. TRADITIONAL MEDICINE - This term is used here to describe health care that does not fall within the allopathic 'modern1 and scientific system. Under this system, there is no conceptual separation between natural and supernatural entities, although it has as a key feature, the use of magico-religious acts and concepts. As Twumasi has noted in traditional medicine "tradition is important not in the sense of empirical experience but through its validation of the power of the unseen world" (Twumasi 1975 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh p.10). Traditional health care regimens used in the prevention and treatment of diarrhoea include local remedies such as herbs, enemas, purgatives, visiting faith healers, spiritualists (diviners or fetish priests) and traditional herbalists. 3. MODERN SCIENTIFIC OR ALLOPATHIC APPROACHES TO THE PREVENTION AND TREATMENT OF DIARRHOEA - These include the use of home medication with pharmaceuticals, seeking advice and prescribed treatment from a pharmacist/chemical seller, health worker in government or private practice and the use of ORT (including ORS). Practitioners of these approaches have as an important underpinning a naturalistic world view of the causes of diseases and ill-health in general. As a result the establishment of causalities in supernatural terms is assumed to have no place in modern therapeutic choices. 1.4 METHODOLOGY 1.4.0 FIELD SETTING. To investigate the central thesis that the choice of modern approaches to the treatment of childhood diarrhoea is a function of folk concepts of cause(s), consequences and treatment of various forms of diarrhoea, it became necessary to move into a rural area. The Dangme East District readily came to mind as the investigator was familiar with this area and besides, such familiarity has been found to enhance the quality of in-depth studies (Janzen 1978; Stone and Camp 1984; Bleek 1987) . In deciding on the particular University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh community to be studied however clinical records at the Ada Foah2 Health Post were reviewed, and Pute was found to be one of the communities in the district with a high incidence of diarrhoea, which therefore made it a suitable setting for the study. Apart from these considerations, it was also felt that the chosen community should have identifiable rural features to make it easily discernible from an urban community. In this respect, lack of pipe-borne water supply, electricity, good accessible roads, and its smallness (it has a population of less than 5000) were considered typical rural features. Furthermore, this micro-approach was adopted for two other important reasons; time and financial constraints as well as to allow for a deeper study of beliefs and practices surrounding childhood diarrhoeal illness. 1.4.1 Data Collection Techniques The data upon which this study is based were gathered mainly from mothers with children under age five residing in Pute. Aware of the limitations of using standard survey methods to elicit valid information on health beliefs among a rural community, three major complementary methods were used in this study. The primary method of data collection was interviewing using a schedule which was designed following a review of literature related to the management of childhood diarrhoea in various 2 Ada Foah is the administrative capital of the Dangme East District. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh cultural contexts of the world. The schedule consisted of both close-ended and open-ended questions. The open-ended questions made it possible to elicit free and detailed responses as well as recording of information spontaneously. Topics covered in the interview schedule include socio-demographic characteristics of respondents, beliefs, perceptions and attitudes to diarrhoea with particular reference to types, their causes and treatment options; case management of diarrhoea which also included questions related to prevalence of diarrhoea, food and fluid practices and knowledge and use of ORS/SSS. Taking into consideration the problems of recall usually encountered in household morbidity surveys, questions regarding case management were framed around a point prevalent measure (the proportion of children under age five whose mothers report that they have had diarrhoea in the 24 hours preceding the interview) and a period prevalent measure (the proportion with diarrhoea in the two weeks preceding the interview). Where the diarrhoea occurred in the remote past, the technique used to facilitate recall was to centre questioning around the "last diarrhoeal episode". Thus responses were linked to a previous experience of diarrhoea usually recent in time rather than an abstract event. A major shortcoming of data from the interview schedule is that they tend to reflect reported behaviour in the sense that there may be variations in what people say they do and what they actually do (Bentley 1987) . In order to minimise the distortion between 'reported' behaviour and 'actual' behaviour, this first approach of University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh interviewing was combined with observation and informal questioning of mothers. To this end, actual diarrhoeal episodes were followed through to recovery. Where possible, visits were made daily or every other day until the diarrhoea subsided. Conducting interviews among families in which the child was ill with diarrhoea made it possible to observe and to sympathetically comprehend interactions among mother, child and other caretakers and thereby focusing the behaviours of interest first hand. In all, the observation technique which has been found useful in the study of small-scale largely illiterate communities, provided the necessary social and cultural background for interpreting data derived from the interview schedules. As a further validity check on self-reported information, three focus group discussions of mothers randomly selected from three different age groups 15-24, 25-34 and 35 and above were conducted. Age was used as the main criterion for making the groups homogeneous. This ensured that mothers felt at ease and spoke. All participants had been previously interviewed. The investigator served as the main facilitator whilst two other members of the research team served as recorders. The questions for the focus group discussions were treated as an outline of discussion which only provided a general direction. Hence, they were not rigidly followed. To initiate a discussion on the issues of interest, the group was led to talk about general topics to build up mutual trust. It was only when this had been achieved and the discussion was running smoothly and all members were actively participating that issues related to the management of childhood diarrhoea were University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh raised. It was this part of the discussion that was recorded on a voice-activated portable tape-recorder. Sessions which were conducted in Dangme3 lasted between 60-80 minutes and they were held in a classroom at the village's primary school. Each group consisted of eight members. At the end of the group sessions, the recordings were listened to by the main facilitator and reports were written on the salient points. Furthermore, the investigator held informal interviews with some knowledgeable people like the local chief, fetish priest/priestess, herbalists, the local Assemblyman and a Chemical Seller in the village. They were all relied on to describe and to report on the culture of the people at Pute. Besides, secondary data on the anthropological studies of diarrhoeal illness (mainly from journals) in different cultural contexts were utilised where necessary. 1.4.2 Sampling In order to obtain relatively unbiased results at minimum cost, the following procedure was used in selecting mothers with children under age five for questioning. First it was important to assess the population universe of mothers in the community having children under age five. In the absence of current population data on the village, a house to house head count of these mothers was carried out together with the number of children under age five that lived Dangme is the local language of the people of Ada. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh in each house. The head count which was done in May 1993 revealed that there were approximately 291 mothers who had a total number of 383 children under age five and lived in 151 houses. There were however about 9 houses without children under age five which have therefore been excluded from the sampling universe. On the average there were about two mothers with 1.3 children in each house. In order to obtain a sample size representative of Pute community as a whole, the family was used as the sampling unit. It is defined here as a mother plus any children she had borne who are living with her in the same household. A significant proportion of households contained multiple nuclear families. Questionnaires were administered to one family in each household. The mode of interaction in this community made it unnecessary for our purpose to interview more than one family per household since the interviews were not private other family members who were around indirectly participated. In all 143 mothers from all houses having children under five were interviewed. This represents about 50 percent of mothers with children under age five residing in Pute and is therefore expected to provide a good representative sample. In selecting mothers, priority was given to those whose children were currently experiencing diarrhoea or had had the most recent episode. It was felt that household behaviour for an on-going diarrhoea will probably be reported more accurately than for past or future episodes. Furthermore, in order to obtain a representative number of diarrhoeal episodes to be followed, it was decided that half of all new episodes recorded during household interviews in a particular 25 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh day will be randomly selected for study. Out of the 47 on-going diarrhoeal episodes that were recorded over the period of the study, 23 were monitored. Given the time constraints facing the investigator, three female interviewers were recruited to help in collecting information from mothers. They were all sixth formers and Dangme-speaking. They were trained in the conduct of focus group discussions, interviewing and qualitative research techniques using role playing exercises for one week. The goal of this training was to enable interviewers to become familiar with the aims of the study and the purpose and meaning of each question. Since the interview schedule was in English, appropriate translations of the questions into Dangme were carried out to ensure that questions were asked uniformly by all. All the interviewers stayed at Pute throughout the survey. This enabled them to interview women engaged in fish- related activities and traders who left home very early and returned home very late in the evening. 1.4.3 Pre-testing The interview schedules and the guide questions for the focus group discussions were pre-tested at Ocanseykope and Totimekope - all rural communities in the Dangme East District. Pre-testing the interview schedules provided the investigator with the means for detecting and solving unforeseen problems not previously anticipated. These included rephrasing, re-wording and changing the sequence of questions. It also showed the need for new questions and the elimination of some old ones. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1.4.4 Procedure for Fieldwork 27 The investigator's first visit to Pute to begin the study was in May 1993 in which a census of mothers having children under age five was conducted. During this first visit, the chief and his elders caused a "gong gong" to be beaten at a fee of