UNIVERSITY OF GHANA COLLEGE OF HUMANITIES EXPLORING TECHNICAL AND VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING (TVET) AS AN OPPORTUNITY IN ADDRESSING YOUTH UNEMPLOYMENT IN AWUTU SENYA EAST MUNICIPALITY BY ESINU AKU ADZA (10938748) THIS DISSERTATION IS SUBMITTED TO THE UNIVERSITY OF GHANA, LEGON IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF MASTER OF ARTS IN DEVELOPMENT STUDIES DEGREE INSTITUTE OF STATISTICAL, SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC RESEARCH (ISSER) APRIL 2023 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh i DECLARATION I, hereby declare that apart from the references to other people’s works which have been duly acknowledged, the dissertation, “Exploring Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) as an Opportunity in Addressing Youth Unemployment in Awutu Senya East Municipality” is the result of my fieldwork activities carried out in the Institute of Statistical Social and Economic Research (ISSER), under the supervision of Dr Cynthia Addoquaye Tagoe and that this dissertation has neither in whole nor in part been presented anywhere for the award of a degree. Any error is attributed to my limitation. ………………………………. …19 / 05/ 2023…………… ESINU AKU ADZA Date (Student) ……………………………….. …19 / 05/ 2023………….. DR. CYNTHIA ADDOQUAYE TAGOE Date (Supervisor) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh ii ABSTRACT Ghana’s youth population currently stands at 36 percent of its total population, with 54 percent living in urban areas. Data from the 2021 National Population Census indicate that 19.7 percent of unemployed adults are classified as youth, with those between the ages of 15-24 years recording a much higher rate-32.8 percent (GSS, 2021). As the country works at addressing the issue of unemployment, interventions have been put in place, one of which is technical and vocational skills acquisition. A mixed method approach was used to carry out the study in the Awutu Senya East Municipality. Data was obtained from 120 unemployed youth aged 15 to 35 years as well as 15 in-depth interviews conducted with young people in the Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) sector. The study assessed knowledge, perceptions and attitudes of the youth towards TVET, opportunities and challenges of the youth in TVET and examine the extent to which the youth perceive TVET as a solution to unemployment. The results of the study show that respondents perceive TVET as the solution to youth unemployment in the municipality and that the knowledge gained regarding the types, opportunities, and challenges TVET provides influences their attitude towards accepting it. The results further indicated a general perception that having adequate funds was a significant influence on their employability within the TVET sector. The study showed that almost all the respondents expect many interventions from the government. Additionally, the respondents were willing to adopt TVET as a skill relevant for employment, although the majority preferred formal employment. The study therefore recommended more investment into capacity building and knowledge management and sharing, with emphasis on generating resources to establish their businesses after the skill acquisition and sustainable government interventions through policies, funding, and scholarship award schemes. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh iii DEDICATION I dedicate this research work to God Almighty, my parents of blessed memory and my siblings- Seyram, Sena and Etornam Adza for their unending love, resources, and motivation during this academic journey. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I wish to express my sincere gratitude to the Almighty God, who sustained my life and made this research a success. My gratitude to my supervisor, Dr. Cynthia Addoquaye Tagoe, who guided me through this work to the end. I would also like to express my heartfelt appreciation to Prof. Austin Dziwornu Ablo of the Department of Geography and Resource Development and Dr. Karim Hakib of the Department of Theatre Arts for his counsel and unflinching support. Many thanks to Prof. Steel, Prof. Simon Bawakyillenuo, and Dr. Ralph Armah for their immense support and guidance. To the Social Welfare and Community Development workers at ASEMA, I am most grateful for your support. I also thank my siblings – Seyram, Sena, Etornam Adza, Valerie Nutakor, Mr. and Mrs. Eli Gaewu, Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Mensah, Enid Amonoo, Charles Snr. Agyarko, Nana Asi Asare, Michael Teye-Bio Nadutey, Charlotte Adjetey, Emmanuella Sarpong, Prince Bowman, Kwesi Obeng, Kekeli Amedzro, and my colleagues for their support. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh v TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION ........................................................................................................................ i ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................................... ii DEDICATION .......................................................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ......................................................................................................... iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................... v LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................................... ix LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................... x LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................... xi CHAPTER ONE ........................................................................................................................ 1 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................... 1 1.0 Background of the Study ........................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Statement of the Problem ....................................................................................................... 4 1.2 Objectives of the Study .......................................................................................................... 8 1.3 Significance of the Study ........................................................................................................ 8 1.4 Organisation of the Study ....................................................................................................... 9 CHAPTER TWO...................................................................................................................... 11 LITERATURE REVIEW ......................................................................................................... 11 2.0 Introduction........................................................................................................................... 11 2.1 Definition of Youth .............................................................................................................. 11 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh vi 2.2 Concept of Unemployment ................................................................................................... 12 2.3 Youth Unemployment in Ghana ........................................................................................... 14 2.4 Global Statistics of Youth Unemployment ........................................................................... 16 2.5 Causes of Youth Unemployment .......................................................................................... 17 2.6 Government Initiated Youth Unemployment Interventions .................................................. 19 2.7 Concept of TVET ................................................................................................................. 20 2.8 Popularisation of TVET in Ghana ........................................................................................ 23 2.9 Types of TVET ..................................................................................................................... 25 2.9.1 Formal TVET ................................................................................................................... 25 2.9.2 Informal and Non-formal TVET ...................................................................................... 26 2.10 TVET Governance and Interventions in Ghana ................................................................... 29 2.11 Challenges of TVET ............................................................................................................. 33 2.12 Theoretical Framework ......................................................................................................... 34 2.13 Conceptual Framework ......................................................................................................... 37 CHAPTER THREE .................................................................................................................. 41 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................. 41 3.0 Introduction........................................................................................................................... 41 3.1 Profile of the Study Area ...................................................................................................... 41 3.1.1 Population and Geographic Information of ASEMA ....................................................... 42 3.1.2 Economic Activities ......................................................................................................... 44 3.1.3 Education and Infrastructure ............................................................................................ 45 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh vii 3.1.4 Governance....................................................................................................................... 45 3.2 Research Design ................................................................................................................... 46 3.3 Data collection methods and procedure ................................................................................ 47 3.3.1 Survey .............................................................................................................................. 47 3.3.2 Interviews ......................................................................................................................... 49 3.4 Data Processing and Analysis ............................................................................................... 51 3.5 Ethical Considerations .......................................................................................................... 51 CHAPTER FOUR .................................................................................................................... 53 DATA ANALYSIS ................................................................................................................... 53 4.0 Introduction........................................................................................................................... 53 4.1 Demographic Characteristics of the Study Participants ....................................................... 53 4.2 Knowledge, Attitude and Perception of the Youth towards TVET ....................................... 57 4.2.1 Knowledge of the Youth towards TVET .......................................................................... 58 4.2.2 Attitude of the Youth towards TVET ............................................................................... 60 4.2.3 Perception of the Youth about TVET ............................................................................... 65 4.3 Assessment of the Opportunities and Challenges of the Youth in TVET ................................. 73 4.3.1 Opportunities of the Youth in TVET................................................................................. 73 4.3.2 Challenges of the Youth in TVET ..................................................................................... 76 4.4 Extent to which the Youth Perceive TVET as an Opportunity to Address Youth Unemployment ..................................................................................................................... 80 CHAPTER FIVE ...................................................................................................................... 84 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh viii SUMMARY OF FINDINGS .................................................................................................... 84 5.0 Introduction........................................................................................................................... 84 5.1 Summary of Findings ........................................................................................................... 84 5.2 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................ 88 5.3 Recommendations ................................................................................................................. 90 APPENDIX A: QUESTIONNAIRE FOR THE UNEMPLOYED YOUTH ......................... 104 APPENDIX B: KEY INFORMANT INTERVIEW GUIDE ................................................. 111 APPENDIX C: INTERVIEW GUIDE FOR EMPLOYED YOUNG PEOPLE IN TVET AND THE UNEMPLOYED YOUTH ................................................................................... 114 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh ix LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1: Population Size of Selected Settlements ................................................................. 50 Table 3.2: Sample Size in Selected Communities .................................................................... 52 Table 3.3: Sampled Interviewees .............................................................................................. 54 Table 4.1: Demographic Characteristics of the Study Participants .......................................... 57 Table 4.2: Current Occupation and Preferred Employment Option ......................................... 61 Table 4.3: TVET Skills and Reason for not Gaining the Skills ................................................ 65 Table 4.4: Attitude of the Youth towards TVET ....................................................................... 67 Table 4.5: Perception of the Youth Towards TVET.................................................................. 71 Table 4.6: Perception of the Youth Towards TVET Funding ................................................... 73 Table 4.7: Perception of the Youth Towards TVET Employment ............................................ 75 Table 4.8: TVET as an Opportunity to Addressing Unemployment ........................................ 85 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh x LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2.1: Conceptual Framework .......................................................................................... 40 Figure 3.1: Map of Awutu Senya East Municipal .................................................................... 45 Figure 4.1: Highest Form of Education .................................................................................... 59 Figure 4.2: Programme of Study .............................................................................................. 60 Figure 4.3: Causes of Youth Unemployment ........................................................................... 63 Figure 4.4: Knowledge about TVET Qualification .................................................................. 64 Figure 4.5: Government Support of TVET .............................................................................. 76 Figure 4.6: The Role of TVET in the Community ................................................................... 84 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh xi LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ASEMA Awutu Senya East Municipal Assembly ASEM Awutu Senya East Municipality COTVET Council for Technical and Vocational Education and Training CTVET Commission for Technical and Vocational Education and Training ECA Economic Commission for Africa GES Ghana Education Service GSS Ghana Statistical Service MTDP Medium-Term Development Plan NABH National Association for Beauticians and Hairdressers NVTI National Vocational Training Institute PHC Population and Housing Census ILO International Labour Organisation ISSER Institute of Statistical, Social and Economic Research KAP Knowledge, Attitude and Practice SWCD Social Welfare and Community Development TVET Technical and Vocational Education and Training UN United Nations YEA Youth Employment Agency University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.0 Background of the Study The global employment deficit of young people has unarguably become an issue of concern, and as such, governments are working tirelessly to address the situation (O’Higgins, 2017). This is being achieved by initiating integrating policies, situating issues on youth unemployment at the core of macroeconomics, and drawing on innovations to deal extensively with the situation. In the same vein, the role of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) in advancing youth employment, and by extension nation building, cannot be overemphasised as it is conventionally and internationally recognised as possessing the capacity to provide occupational skills for employment (Akyeampong, 2005). In an era defined as youthful, it is unsurprising that more than half of the world’s eight billion population is under 30 years, with about a tenth from developing countries (UNESCO, 2013). In 2015, a total of 71 million youth was unemployed based on ILO’s definition of unemployment, with a predicted rise of emerging countries of 52.9 million in 2015 to 53.5 million in 2017. A deficit of 34 million was also recorded between 2019 and 2020, with a deficit rate of 8.2 percent. There has been a fluctuating rate of documented cases of youth unemployment over the years. The percentage decline in employment among young individuals is significantly greater compared to adults (defined as individuals 25 years and above) (ILO, 2022). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 2 There is not a universally agreed-upon definition of who qualifies as a youth, hence the variety in worldwide classifications of a youth (Leavy & Smith, 2010). However, the United Nations (UN) and other member states define youth as individuals between the ages of 15 and 24 years who, according to the UN (n.d), are 1.2 billion, making up 16 percent of the global population. In Ghana and elsewhere in Africa, a person between the ages of 15 and 35 is often categorised as a youth (Youth Policy, 2014). Youth unemployment is a major problem and a significant policy concern in Africa. The aim of solving this has led to many youth intervention programmes (Fox et al., 2020; Hardy et al., 2019). The urgent policy deficit lies in the widespread prevalence of unemployment and underemployment among young individuals in Sub-Saharan Africa. The transition from education to productive employment has not been successful over the years, and a sizeable portion of the youth in the region face barriers in accessing mainstream education due to factors like financial constraints, academic performance and limited school capacity (Blattman & Ralston, 2015; Filmer & Fox, 2014). Potentially, young people play a vital role in fostering development when provided with the knowledge and opportunities needed to excel and, as such, the need to be motivated to acquire the education and skills required to contribute to a productive economy. They need access to a job market that can absorb them into the labour force, or to set up their businesses (Yangben & Seniwoliba, 2014). Unfortunately, the formal sector, categorised by more structured and secure systems expected to harness the skillset of young people, is lagging behind in meeting their job demands, hence the informal sector's empowerment to meet these rising demands. Consequently, University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 3 the technical and vocational industry has become an effective opportunity for those not getting jobs in the formal wage economy to become entrepreneurs (Adams, 2009). Ghana's informal sector is predominantly identified with people with an informal form of education. The sector has employed many young and older workers in Ghana and Sub-Saharan Africa since the 1970s (Bangasser, 2000; Fox & Gaal, 2008; Haan, 2006). Employment in the informal sector was perceived as a temporal source of work in pursuit of modern sector employment but with increasing education, the image of the sector has changed over time. Informal economy was conceptualised in the 1970s by Keith Hart to qualify the systems of economic transactions adopted by migrant workers in Ghana at the time and has since assumed diverse contextualisation (NGOs, n.d). The majority of workers in this sector is self-employed individuals. Recognising Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) employment within this sector presents an opportunity to tackle youth unemployment. Historically, TVET is said to have been emphasised in Ghana since the colonial period, when children in missionary schools were given training in trades like masonry, carpentry, and blacksmithing, amongst others (Akyeampong, 2005). Over time, two distinct types of TVET have emerged. These include the formal system, which is school-based and can be further divided into tertiary level and pre-tertiary level TVET. On the other hand, there is the informal system, which is characterised by training obtained outside the traditional education system. In the informal system, there are structured learning objectives to be achieved, specific timeframes, and support provided to learners. Yangben and Seniwoliba (2014) talk of another form. They termed this ‘the non-formal system’, which comprises TVET workshops and seminars. In recent times, private and University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 4 public institutions have utilised all these forms in rolling out TVET in Ghana. Regrettably, the TVET sector faces numerous limitations worldwide that impede its effectiveness. These limitations encompass career-related obstacles, discrepancies between acquired skills and market demands, widespread concerns regarding subpar training quality and learning environments, as well as negative public attitudes and perceptions towards vocational education and training (Dadzie et al., 2020). 1.1 Statement of the Problem Ghana’s youth population currently stands at 36 percent of its total population, with 54 percent living in urban areas. Unfortunately, three-quarters of unemployed adults recorded in the 2021 National Population Census represent the youth. This is undoubtedly an alarming proof that unemployment remains problematic despite the country's economic growth. The situation worsened at the outbreak of COVID-19, placing various limitations on individuals and development in general. Lockdowns, loss of jobs, and loss of lives characterised the period. With countries still at a recovery stage, the youth employment deficit in 2020 was projected to be recovered in 2022 despite the 5.9 percent fall recorded in 2021. About 4 percent fall is expected, increasing the youth labour force worldwide (ILO, 2022; World Bank Group, 2022). Amid the ongoing global youth employment crisis, which is persistently increasing, countries are actively exploring strategies to tackle these issues more effectively, particularly as they reached their peak during the 2009 global recession (ILO, 2017). It is, therefore, no coincidence that UN Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) eight emphasises decent work for all, which is undoubtedly pertinent to young people because unemployment is high amongst this group of people and three University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 5 times higher than the adult unemployment rate (UNDP, 2019). The youth in Ghana, as elsewhere, often face unique challenges transitioning into the labour market. As the country works to address unemployment, many interventions have been put in place, one of which is technical and vocational skills acquisition. According to Amadi and Abdullah (2012), vocational skills acquisition training, when effectively rolled out, acts as an intervention tool in curbing the issue of unemployment and poverty in the society- in this case, Awutu Senya East Municipality (ASEM). In corroboration, Kennedy et al. (2013), postulated that acquiring vocational skills as a young person with employable potential contributes immensely to one’s ability to generate income, likewise the securing of livelihoods. Thus, there is an increased potential of becoming economically self-reliant as skills attained are put to work. Other benefits include high self-esteem and wider social capital. The growing body of literature suggests TVET as possessing the capacity and a sustainable alternative to addressing the country's increasing unemployment rate (Yangben & Seniwoliba, 2014). Additionally, TVET has, over the years, proven to be important in Africa due to its higher probability of providing jobs to learners, and Ghana is no exception. Ghana’s TVET system has been an essential part of its informal economy, particularly as a complementary means of skills transfer and the development of the nation's human capital required for overall national development. In emphasising the responsibilities of various stakeholders who affect the youth, provision is made for the country to provide opportunities for educational advancement and University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 6 adequate resources for sustainable youth development. In contrast, the youth is expected to willingly take advantage of the opportunities for personal socioeconomic development. There are many programmes been implemented nationwide including online digital marketing and entrepreneurship training, app development training, youth innovation for sustainable development challenge, youth livelihoods farms, and skills towards employment and productivity (Dadzie et al., 2020). This means that the government is working towards addressing the youth unemployment in the country. Against this background, there is the need to undertake a study among the youth to ascertain the reasons for the poor participation in TVET despite its capacity to curb unemployment. This study explored the knowledge, perceptions, attitudes, challenges, and opportunities associated with TVET among youth aged 15 to 35 years in Ghana using Awutu Senya East Municipality (ASEM) as a case study. This would provide insights into how the youth perceive these opportunities and identify effective approaches to address youth unemployment, with a focus on ASEM as a case study (National Youth Authority, 2022). Several studies have been conducted about the prospective contribution of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) to youth employment, drawing on testimonies in countries like Germany- one of the leading developed countries with an advanced experience in TVET juxtaposed to that of developing countries. Olelewe (2016) and Sanni (2018) researched the potential of TVET in addressing youth unemployment and the challenges of providing Vocational Education for young people in Nigeria. Rathidevi and Sudhakaran (2019) explored students' attitudes towards TVET in Chennai City, India. In Ghana, studies have assessed the TVET skill gaps in the extractive sector, its importance, and career challenges (Ansah & Kissi, 2013; University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 7 Saskatchewan Polytechnic, 2016; Yangben & Seniwoliba, 2014). Little is known about the knowledge, perception and attitude of young people towards TVET and, likewise, the extent to which they perceive it as an opportunity to address unemployment. Ghana’s 2021 TVET report showed that TVET completion rates were low, especially amongst pre-tertiary learners, due to the course duration and lack of funding. Technical institutes and national vocational institutes run courses of three to five years; many learners leave after two years, believing that their employability will not significantly improve in the remainder of the course (Atchoarena and Delluc, 2002; CTVET, 2021). It is for such reasons that this study is to be undertaken with the youth of ASEM as the target population since the area is documented to be urban, youthful and has a vibrant informal sector known to be the booster of the local economy having job creation and training potentials for the youth (Medium Term Development Plan, 2021). Out of a total population of 66,878 aged 15 years and above, 5.2 percent are unemployed, with 90 percent falling between the ages of 30 and 44. These statistics imply that a proportion of the youth are unemployed despite the dominance of the informal sector in the municipality and TVET as a potential pathway for addressing the issue. In exploring the reasons for the high rate of unemployment recorded amongst the youth in Awutu Senya East Municipality, the study sought to answer the following questions; what are the knowledge, perceptions and attitudes of the youth towards TVET? What are the opportunities and challenges of the youth in TVET? To what extent do young people perceive TVET as a solution to youth unemployment? University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 8 1.2 Objectives of the Study The study's general objective explored TVET as an opportunity to tackle unemployment amongst the youth in ASEM. Specifically, the study aims 1. To assess the knowledge, attitudes and perceptions of the youth in ASEM towards TVET 2. To assess the opportunities and challenges of the youth in TVET 3. To examine the extent to which the youth perceive TVET as a solution to unemployment amongst young people in the municipality. 1.3 Significance of the Study The emerging challenges confronting the youth create a sense of urgency that necessitates a significant level of concern among policymakers and government officials in charge of formulating, implementing, monitoring, and evaluating youth programmes as well as projects. This warrants that the right approaches are devised to address the identified challenges (Huut, 2018). The study will therefore provide reliable information to all relevant stakeholders, policymakers, and employers alike in the education and employment sectors. This will rekindle the urgency and framework surrounding job provision among the youth in Ghana. Since most youths are in the informal sector, attention is needed to encourage and provide relevant skills for economic development. As youth unemployment has become a national problem and efforts have been put in place to address the issue, findings of this study in ASEM are expected to help inform the Government of Ghana and policymakers on the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of the youth towards TVET and how they can intervene effectively. Thus, the findings will help orient resource allocation and University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 9 project design. The Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) asserts that employment is foundational to any region’s prosperity and continued improvement in the welfare of its people (ECA, 2007 cited in Amadi & Abdullah, 2012). Findings and recommendations will therefore enhance ongoing deliberations between relevant stakeholders, which is expected to impact TVET positively. Overall, the study is expected to contribute to efforts geared towards advancing knowledge about youth unemployment and TVET. Thus, drawing on the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of the youth and the lingering challenges and opportunities inherent in the sector. This aligns with Dyson’s (2008), and van Blerk’s (2019) call for more engagement with young people to learn from their experiences on the issue under study. Finally, the study seeks to add to the existing literature on youth unemployment and TVET from the perspective of the youth in Awutu Senya East Municipality. 1.4 Organisation of the Study The study is structured into five chapters. The first chapter introduces the study by highlighting, the background, problem statement, objectives and significance of the study. Chapter Two presents a review of relevant literature. Additionally, the chapter presents the theoretical and conceptual frameworks of the study. In Chapter Three, the methodology employed in data collection and analysis are explained. The chapter also provides a profile of the study district as well as the study population and the sampling techniques employed. Chapter Four then presents the results of the study and discusses the findings. Finally, Chapter Five provides a summary of University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 10 the key findings of the study, conclusion and makes recommendations for policy and future research. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 11 CHAPTER TWO LITERATURE REVIEW 2.0 Introduction This chapter reviews relevant literature on TVET as an opportunity to address youth unemployment in Ghana. Thus, various scholarly works were reviewed to give an in-depth understanding of the definition of youth, and the concept of unemployment, then narrowed down to youth unemployment, global statistics of unemployment amongst young people, causes of youth unemployment, and some government-initiated interventions. Subsequent sections covered the concept of TVET and the opportunities it has created in the global space, its popularisation in Ghana, a brief highlight on both formal and informal TVET, its governance, and some interventions in Ghana and challenges being faced by the sector. The chapter will also look at the theoretical and conceptual frameworks underlying the study. 2.1 Definition of Youth According to United Nations (UN), a youth is a person between the ages of 15 and 24 years. Countries like Ghana, Mali, and Nigeria have different age ranges for defining youth. These countries defined a youth as a person aged between 15 to 40 years, 18 to 35 years, and 15 to 35 years, respectively. In the case of Ethiopia, a youth is a person who is between 15 and 24 years old. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 12 2.2 Concept of Unemployment In defining unemployment, authors have tried to use concepts that benefit their objectives. Over time, unemployment as a familiar phenomenon has been described by the International Labour Organisation (ILO) as individuals who are of working age, actively looking for work within a relatively brief period (such as a month, week, or day), but are unable to find suitable employment opportunities (ILO, 2007). Based on the above, the World Bank estimated that about 48 percent of the youth in Ghana are unemployed (World Bank Group, 2022). Poku-Boansi and Afrane (2016) question this definition and label it as porous as it appears to suit the context of unemployment in developed countries as opposed to developing countries, Africa inclusive. They argued that the conceptualisation of the situation makes no provision for discouraged workers and those in the rural sector since majority of the labour offices are situated in the urban centres. Governments worldwide work tirelessly at tackling the canker, especially the prevalence of youth unemployment but has, over the years, proven to be a cumbersome task to complete, with most faults being accredited to governments preceding the incumbent. With much conviction, issues have been raised concerning how trivial the statistics make unemployment look in the African domain compared to the reality on the ground. Baah-Nuakoh (1993), Poku-Boansi and Afrane (2016), in concurrence stipulated that the representation of unemployment within the Ghanaian region by census is not representational, thereby causing gaps in interventions carved out by both government and private institutions in attacking the menace. For many years, concerns have been raised about the consistent understatement of the unemployment rate in Africa, which in turn justifies the pertinence of the phenomenon. Giving rise to the conclusion that the universal University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 13 conceptualisation of unemployment is ‘too narrow’ in its application in the African context (Awad, 2019). Theoretically, unemployment has been analysed in many ways. One of these ways is the neoclassical model, which posits that there is no such phenomenon as unemployment on the premise that the labour market consistently clears - presupposing that unemployment is recorded only when an individual willingly chooses to rebuff the market-clarity wage offer. That is the assumption of flexible wages and perfect information. This theory further enumerates the required generalisation of excess supply of labour and structural employment resulting from the mismatch between the demand for labour and skills in positioning job seekers as assumptions. The classical model attributes the imbalance between demands in supply of labour to the creation of unintentional unemployment, and only happens when there is market imperfection caused by the government interruptions such as minimum wage. This theory further explains that government interventions provoked surplus labour because of the excess supply over demand for labour. Despite the arguments raised in contradiction to the relative influence of minimum wage on unemployment, Nevmark and Wascher (1995) reiterate the significant effect it had on the youth and unskilled workers and, as such cannot be underestimated. Furthermore, voluntary and involuntary models have been used in explaining unemployment. Shackleton (1985) elucidated that the state in which individuals cannot get work despite their readiness to accept lower real wages or poorer conditions compared to the ideal summed up involuntary unemployment. In contrast, voluntary unemployment is dependent on the individual’s willingness to remain unemployed. Bentolila et al. (2011) added to this definition by explaining University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 14 the concept using the insider model. Here, employment is said to spring forth when wages are determined based on the considerations of current employees (insiders) with no recognition of the interests of jobseekers – outsiders. Thus, insiders remain the beneficiaries of the employment opportunities that crop up, leaving job seekers in the dark. 2.3 Youth Unemployment in Ghana The large youth population in the country represents a potential resource for growth and development when they are gainfully and productively employed. However, the size of the youth population may pose a challenge and source of civil disorders and social unrest if this untapped resource is poorly managed, negatively affecting development. Ostensibly, high-rise insecurity in some Sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries and the present-day disruption in North Africa have been connected to unemployment (AfDB et al., 2012). Not only does unemployment give rise to economic costs expressed in revenues and output losses, but it suggests a misuse of human resources and consequently sparks maximal individual deprivation. Notable of which is accrued psychological costs for the unemployed (Eguaveon, 2010). Young people are most often new candidates in the market from different educational backgrounds, with limited or no work experience and that tends to hamper their prospects of securing productive and/or formal sector jobs. The problem these people face in securing adequate remunerated and productive jobs after school tends to increase their vulnerability in society and makes them liable to social vices and source of conflicts amongst others. Most of the cases of failed government initiatives have been linked to the unprogressively and failed state of economic reforms and policies initiated by governing bodies (Dietrich & Moller, 2016; Jumpah et al., 2020). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 15 Based on this heterogeneous characteristic of the economic status, advocacy for halting the one- size-fits-all approach in addressing the situation and embracing group-specific policies and programmes is on the rise. It is also revealed that in the last two decades, the rate of employment growth has fallen substantially behind that of economic growth in Ghana. Hence the recording of an expansion of the gap between job growth and economic growth from 2017 to date. Given the foregoing, the response of the youth labour market to economic growth was weak (Baah-Boateng, 2014). Fergusson and Yeates (2022) examined the different situations of unemployment in the Global South. They discovered and advanced the debate that youth unemployment is a weighty problem, but in a disguised manner. Unemployment in Ghana has over a period remained persistent and has recently been magnified due to the COVID-19 pandemic with current rates of 12 percent youth unemployment and more than 50 percent underemployment in the country- both rates reported to be higher than the average across Sub-Saharan African countries (Fairwork, 2022). To this end, this study adopts a broader definition of youth unemployment as any young individual who is without fixed employment, presently available and seeking work, but cannot find one. This is inclusive of all those who lost their jobs voluntarily or involuntarily and persons who did look for work at the time but have arrangements for a future job. The study will also consider that young individual who is unemployed, available for work but makes no effort to seek employment- a situation described as disguised unemployment which is the case for a few young people in the region. Reasons for this has been reported to be linked to the view that job opportunities are limited, or a case of restricted labour mobility, or the individual is faced with discrimination or some form of socio-cultural and structural barriers (ILO, 2022). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 16 2.4 Global Statistics of Youth Unemployment Youth unemployment is considered an undesirable situation for young people and has become one of the greatest obstructions to governments worldwide and finding sustainable solutions to it has become more critical. There is the argument that the issue of youth unemployment needs to be approached from a global perspective especially because of the existing similarities in the challenges confronting the youth on a global spectrum. Yet, this might be impossible due to the non-uniformity in the definition of a youth (Mahama, 2016; UN, 2018). In expounding the cases of unemployment in the African region, it is worth noting that there is much deficiency in statistics due to absence of efficient and functional employment centres in most African countries. Hence the need for the collation of unemployment figures and other relevant labour-related statistics from households, labour force surveys, and population census which are not conducted regularly (Gelle et al., 2021). By referring to empirical data collected between 1999– 2012, unemployment rates were recorded to be higher in North Africa and Sub-Saharan Africa. The rates on an overall scope were much higher in sampled countries in Northern and Southern Africa as opposed to those in the West, Central in East Africa – Ghana inclusive. It was observed that a higher rate was reported among the young people than adults in all the countries represented, with Ghana, Mauritius, Algeria, and Tunisia recording 3 times more rates. At the time of the study, the world average youth unemployment rate stood at 12.6 percent estimated to be 2.8 times higher than their adult counterparts. Again, North African countries had rates thrice higher than that of Sub-Saharan Africa while that of Sub-Saharan Africa was almost twice higher than that of the adults. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 17 Nigeria as of 2016 recorded 80 million out of the 140 million Nigerians, constituting 60 percent of the total population of Nigerians being the youth with 64 million (80 percent) of them unemployed whereas 1.6 million are underemployed thereby posing a threat to the sustainability of the Nigerian economy. Youth unemployment is perceived to be mostly among secondary school leavers with less than half being able to proceed to higher education. There was also a 40 percent unemployment rate among the youth aged 20-24 and 31 percent among those aged 15-19 years in urban settlements (Olelewe, 2016). Again, it is recorded to be higher among the non-science graduates and has been explained as being because of the “overproduction of skills in these areas relative to the absorption of such skills in the economy” (Baah-Boateng, 2021 p.3). In 2017, young people between ages 15 and 35 in Ghana constituted 35 percent of the entire population-about 9.92 million, with the larger population living in the country's urban areas. Baah- Boateng (2021) detailed that those between the ages of 15 and 19 dominated this population, with those aged 25-29 years accounting for the minority of 21 percent. In contrast, those in the 30-35 age bracket dominated in 2015, whereas those who fall within 20-24 years constituted the least share, with 23.3 percent. In summary, the age bracket of 15-24 consisted of approximately 5.5 million people, making up 55.3 percent of the entire population, while those aged 25-35 accounted for 44.7 percent, showing a contrasting pattern compared to the statistics from 2015. 2.5 Causes of Youth Unemployment Being abreast with the vulnerability of young people in seasons of economic situations coupled with a constant reminder of its extremity compared to that of adults is of immense essence to the study. This is ultimately linked to the young person’s limited labour market experience, lack of University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 18 job search experience and labour market information to aid in the search. Youth unemployment is indirectly affected by the unavailability of poorly structured employment centres resulting in the consequent reliance on friends and families for job search. Despite the advancement of discussions and actions towards female empowerment, youth unemployment appears to be higher amongst females than males with reasons centred around lower levels of education, some discriminatory practices of employers and constraints in establishing own enterprises (Elder & Smith, 2010). Surprisingly, many studies conducted on youth unemployment report high rates among graduates of tertiary and secondary institutions compared to those with basic education. This is because the formal sector requests at least secondary education for potential candidates and those below this requirement are automatically not qualified and so they tend to resort to the informal sector where the flexibility of entry exists (Poku-Boansi & Afrane, 2016). Awad (2019) asserts that the informal sector operates as the way out to the no opening and qualification in the formal sector. As problematic as this sounds, the informal sector cannot be ruled out as it operates as a significant contributor to a country’s economy through unemployment absorption. So, whether the informal sector is an ideal choice or not, it is the solution to the rising status of youth unemployment and sparks the conversation geared towards the exploration and better structuring of the sector. In Ghana, the issue of youth unemployment has been extensively discussed, and several studies have identified common factors contributing to this problem. One significant cause relates to the mismatch between the education curriculum and the demands of the job market. This mismatch leaves young individuals highly susceptible to unemployment, which raises concerns about the quality of education provided. Additionally, the population growth rate of a country also plays a University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 19 role in determining the level of unemployment. Statistics indicate that in 2017, Ghana's population was estimated to be 29.6 million, an increase of about 5.1 million from 24.6 million in 2010. Among this population, it is estimated that over 38.8 percent constituted the youth segment (GSS, 2021). 2.6 Government Initiated Youth Unemployment Interventions Policies and programmes aimed at generating employment primarily prioritise skills acquisition, development, and the cultivation of entrepreneurs (Avura et al., 2016). However, before formulating and implementing these effective interventions, it was crucial to have a comprehensive understanding of the labour market composition. To address this issue, the government has implemented diverse programmes to promote employment in the region. These programmes include: Youth Employment Agency (YEA); National Vocational Training Institute (NVTI); Opportunities Industrialisation Centre Ghana (OICG); Youth Leadership and Skills Training Institute; Youth in Agriculture Programme (YIAP); National Entrepreneurship Innovation Programme (NEIP), previously Youth Enterprise Support (YES); Rural Enterprises Programme (REP); National Service Scheme (NSS); Ghana Youth Employment and Entrepreneurial Agency (GYEEDA), and Nation Builders Corps (NABCO). Jumpah et al. (2020), have argued that most of these policies and programmes have produced insignificant results over the years. This, they ascribed to the failure of such interventions to factor in some rudimentary inputs like more succinct selection criteria and sustainability, resulting in the escalating national average of unemployment rate in recent years. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 20 2.7 Concept of TVET In recent years, there has been an awakening among policy makers globally on the vital role that TVET plays in national development. This is reflected in African countries in the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers developed by its governments in partnership with World Bank (Nasir, 2012). The conceptualisation of TVET is closely linked to its vision. According to UNESCO- UNEVOC (2001), this vision is ascribable to the economic and financial crisis that hit Africa in the 1980s. The uncertainties born from this period sparked grave changes in the labour market and TVET systems inclusive leading to a hike in unemployment and the deterioration of the capability of TVET as a source of employment. Education is an investment in human capital, a basal human right and a sine qua non for the socio- economic development of any given society. Additionally, education is an efficient medium for the facilitation of individual fulfilment cum the generational transfer of values not underestimated (GSS, 2014; Ansah et al., 2013). TVET is widely considered as a sub-sector in the education sphere and the propulsive force behind economic and technological progress (Akoojee, 2012). The idea of this form of education is centred on the acquisition of practical skills and is similarly viewed in other terms that are often used interchangeably. They include vocational education, technical vocational education, and training (TVET), and vocational training. Other terms used to describe this phenomenon over time include apprenticeship training, technical education, occupational education, workplace education, career and technical education, and workforce education (Hollander & Mar, 2009; Sanni, 2018). Meanings ascribed to the phenomenon are dependent on the focus of the research and largely due to its compendious nature. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 21 Primarily, TVET has been recorded in the literature as concerned with the acquisition of knowledge and skills for the labour market. According to UNESCO and ILO (2007, p.1) TVET is “aspects of the educational process involving, in addition to general education, the study of technologies and related sciences, and the acquisition of practical skills, attitudes, understanding and knowledge relating to occupants in various sectors of economic and social life". Its thriving and effectiveness are crucial to a country’s labour market as a solution to unemployment. Kotsikis (2007), defined vocational education as acquiring specific or technical skills for employment that could be complemented with general education. This, he differentiated from vocational training which involves acquiring knowledge both in theory and practical on certain jobs. Additionally, Hollander and Mar (2009) introduced technical and vocational education as an all- inclusive term describing all fragments of the educational process comprising of the study of technologies and related sciences, the acquisition of practical skills, attitudes, comprehension, and knowledge applicable to varied occupations. This, they associated with the past division of roles with respect to TVET whereby UNESCO’s primary assignment was centred on technical and vocational education. At the same time, the International Labour Organisation (ILO) was concerned about aspects of employment training. With arguments raised about education and training possessing the same meaning and role in the world of work. The concept of training was introduced as part of UNESCO’s key objectives and has remained the case to date (Hollander & Mar, 2009). While “technical education is aimed at nurturing skills and practical development of an individual, vocational education is imbued with strict adherence to guiding principles for effective professional performance in an occupational field” (Olelewe, 2016, p. 2). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 22 In the development and recognition process of TVET, an undeniable projection is made of the fact that learning no longer takes the form of formal education alone but also in informal and non- formal settings. Technical vocational education and training (TVET) involves education and training related to a specific job or economic life (Subrahmanyam, 2020). As such, TVET was introduced as the main term by international bodies to describe this kind of activity-based learning. Its complexity and multi-dimensional orientation result in the inaccurate and limited statistics available (Alvarado, 2017). Sustainability plays a major role in TVET as it boosts the economy of a country through the provision of job opportunities alongside other benefits like the reduction in crime rates and the encouragement of innovation, creativity, and competitiveness in development. There is further facilitation of skills adjustment to suit changing market demands and sustainable development practices (Okwelle & Ayomike, 2014). TVET gained an equal but different status for most of the 20th century in North America. It was a conduit for the disadvantaged populace to better themselves in Australia. Comparably, when erstwhile colonies of some advanced nations attained independence, they primarily invested in linking skill advancement to employment then to economic development. Countries like India and Kenya perceived TVET as a national intervention for strategically attaining self-dependence through the provision of job opportunities (Alagaraja et al., 2014). Germany, Austria, and Switzerland reportedly have world-renowned dual TVET systems, whereas Canada and Finland have excellent reputations for TVET in their community college system, and a world-leading education system in which TVET plays a major role. Singapore despite its lack of natural resources has grown into a Southeast Asian powerhouse by its sustainable policies regarding public-private collaboration in TVET. Another country worth referencing is China’s outstanding growth which University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 23 is evidently connected to its prioritised focus on TVET (CTVET, 2021). In Malaysia, TVET drives the country’s economic development through the sufficient and timely supply of exceptionally skilled workers. There is also the consciousness of improving people’s perception of TVET as well as strengthening ties with industries for better output. In Africa, TVET systems vary from country to country as seen in Europe and thereby conveyed or delivered in different kinds of institutions. They comprise technical and vocational schools (public and private), polytechnics, enterprise and apprenticeships – the most patronised and affordable especially for the vulnerable offering the largest platform for the acquisition of employable skills within the informal sector and expanding the job market all over Africa. The African Union (AU) with visions of promoting an integrated, peaceful, prosperous Africa recognises the crucial role TVET plays as an avenue for empowering individuals to take charge of their lives and goes on to advocate for its inclusion in the mainstream education system (African Union, 2007). In Ghana, the informal sector has over the years contributed to about 90 percent of skills training in the country including private organisations consisting of profit and non-profit institutions, church- based institutions and NGOs (CTVET, 2021). Additionally, the private organisations are heading in the provision of TVET and have been said to pay keen attention to learners for the informal sector unlike public organisations (African Union, 2007). 2.8 Popularisation of TVET in Ghana Manpower development as linked to youth empowerment has been identified to be a necessary and basic resource for national development especially in our part of the world (Sanni, 2018). Many countries have recognised this basic yet great resource and have worked on and explored its University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 24 effectiveness. Ghana, is no exception. In years past, Ghana also realised and embarked on youth employment training. That is, specific job training as later came to be known as TVET. This is documented to have commenced during the precolonial era as apprentice training or traditional education, through its attachment to the missionary period where it was taught to locals to solve their problems, strengthened during the colonial era and then invested in during the post- independence period (Benjamin, 2017). According to Avura et al. (2016), this concept seems to be unpopular among Ghanaians and has been relegated to the traditional, small-scale practice. This neglect is not only in Ghana but worldwide. However, this seems to be coming back on the development agenda of countries. With the growing unemployment in many countries, TVET that was once neglected by the World Bank and other world donor agencies between the 1980s and 2000s (Tripney et al., 2013), is now being focused on by all as an opportunity to positively affect global poverty and bring economic as well as social stability (African Union, 2007; King and Palmer, 2010; UNDP, 2019). The establishment of TVET, though covers individuals of all ages, mostly targets the youth. In Ghana, governments, individuals and organisations contribute to TVET through the numerous youth employment interventions they create (Dadzie, et al., 2020). To solve the unemployment problem, improve productivity and economic growth, Ghana has focused on skills development for a while now. Opportunities are given to young people who drop out of school and receive little or no education at all to be self-employed (Baffour-Awuah et al., 2011). In 2018, the government designed a plan to transform TVET to boost economic development and restructure the national TVET system (Ministry of Education, 2018). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 25 2.9 Types of TVET There are different types and forms of TVET education in Ghana including the formal, informal, and non-formal. The TVET curricula are taught in both private and public institutions to provide all facets of society’s access to sustainable learning channels and resources. These institutions are charged with the mandate of producing knowledgeable, skilled, and enthused workforce for the advancement of sustainable development. Skills like negotiation, teamwork, and communication are therefore incorporated in the programmes offered (Subrahmanyam, 2020). They can either be obtained through the structured formal model, the informal practical experience, or both-the dual training as mostly referred to and practiced in countries like Germany with enviable development outcomes (OECD, 2008; Oketch, 2009; Kingombe, 2011). 2.9.1 Formal TVET The formal TVET programmes are school-based and can be further categorised under tertiary level and pre-tertiary level TVET. The formal type of TVET was rolled out in Technical Universities; formally known as Polytechnics. The structure of Polytechnics has been operating since the 1990s until 2016 when the Technical Universities Act, Act 922 was passed in Parliament. In 1987, during the Ghana Educational Reforms, Polytechnics were advanced from second cycle technical institutes to tertiary-level institutions due to the increasing importance attached to the development of technical and vocational education in Ghana. It is also reported to be awfully limited as fees and resources to be provided by the learner appear cumbersome compared to the informal and non- formal (Ansah et al., 2013). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 26 As at the time of this study, Ghana has ten (10) Technical Universities coupled with 88 TVET Colleges, 5 Agriculture Colleges, and other specialised providers (African Union, 2007). Overall, the country has 112 tertiary-level TVET service providers spread across the country, which specialise in different areas such as cosmetology, fashion design, woodwork, and metallurgy. It is also rolled out by the National Vocational Training Institute (NVTI), Ghana Education Service (GES), other youth training institutions and several private vocational schools. The formal system is certified training with its duration being time-bound and ranges from three and six years, depending on the country and the model. Some countries like Ghana, Senegal, and Swaziland in the quest to expose young people to pre-employment skills have integrated fundamental vocational skills into the lower or junior secondary school curriculum (African Union, 2007; Yangben & Seniwoliba, 2014). 2.9.2 Informal and Non-formal TVET The informal sector has over the years been ranked the highest in providing employment and contributing enormously to the country’s development. Employment in the informal economy has been classified as possessing poor quality due to bad working conditions, low remuneration, and above all providing minute economic security. Nonetheless, Fergusson and Yeates (2022) by virtue of their research concluded that there is a significant informal sector that absorbs the mass of the labour forces with no access to formal waged work with about 80 percent of the Ghanaian working population found in the sector. Lutta et al. (2021) averred that the sector creates a suitable training environment for skills development. Thereby resulting in similar prospects for the informal TVET sector. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 27 According to CTVET Report (2021), informal apprenticeship training is not only common in West Africa but also accounts for approximately 80 – 90 percent of all skills training in urban areas like ASEM. Consequently, the rates remain almost close to 2021’s estimation of 400,000 apprentices recorded yearly. Both informal and non-formal TVET have the advantage of shorter duration for training, occupation-specific, less expensive, and not necessarily follow the prescribed standard curriculum with emphasis on the obtainment of practical skills for employment. This traditional training is grounded in an agreement between the apprentice and a master craftsperson, and it lasts for an average of three years. Cost of training, timeframe, and the mode of assessment differ across the sector (Nasir, 2012; Schaefer-Kehnert, 2015). Despite the benefits embedded in this channel of training, there is a surging demand for highly competent labour as Ghana’s economy evolves with much emphasis on technological development. Hence, the need to transform the traditional mode of delivery to curb the current challenges including but not limited to the lack of cooperation and regularity of the training system, leading to government interventions. Informal sector workers engaging in activities like sewing, handcraft industry, furniture making, and car repair workshops signify a major factor for the provision of employment to many people especially those living in urban settlements (Osei-Boateng & Ampratwum, 2011). Ansah et al. (2013) referred to the 2004 white paper on education which advocates for an intensive evaluation and transformation in the delivery and quality of TVET yet to date, minimal attention is paid to the informal and non-formal types. This assertion is corroborated by the findings documented in the 2021 TVET report released by CVET. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 28 In response to arguments against the government concerning the neglect of the informal TVET sector, efforts have been put in place to bridge the existing gap which is unarguably a step in the right direction. As a result, the Recognition of Prior Learning (RPL) was introduced within the informal scope, and recognised certification issued. The assessment focuses on the already acquired skills, knowledge exposure, and experience gained either informally, non-formally or in some cases formally. With this certification, learners are brought at par with those in the formal sector and labour market front, the form of certification expedites transition onto the NTVETQF for all in the informal sphere. Competency Based Training (CBT) was also introduced to the sector as a means of modernising the traditional apprenticeship style. In 2012, the Cooperative Apprenticeship Project was launched and had sixteen training providers and a trade association in areas of garment, electronics, automotive, cosmetology, and welding signed on. This was the case till 2016 in collaboration with CTVET under the Phase I and II of the Ghana Skills Development Initiative. Just like the RPL, this project serves as the link between the formal and the informal sectors. Experientially, this will positively impact the quality of work, unemployment, and sustainable economic cum social development in Ghana. Tools utilised constituted occupational standards, learning material, unit specification, workplace guidelines for master craft persons, and apprentice logbook. Non-formal TVET is synonymous with training obtained outside the education system with structured learning objectives to be achieved, times and support. Community organisations and NGOs are noted to be the conveners of such and will normally not issue certificates. They come in the form of short courses, workshops, and seminars. Similarly, the informal system is University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 29 categorised by the flexibility of programmes cum practicality as priority. The majority of those in the TVET sector gained their skills through the informal system despite its characteristics of poor coordination and standardisation. Most outfits in the sector are made up of traditional apprenticeships in trades like masonry, welding and fabrication, carpentry, auto-mechanics, photography, shoe making, tailoring and dressmaking (Botchie & Ahadzie, 2004, p. 18; Adam, 2008). 2.10 TVET Governance and Interventions in Ghana Until 2000, all issues about TVET were spearheaded by NVTI. It served as the governing body for monitoring TVET and apprenticeship in the country. In 1970, the National Vocational Training Institute was established by ACT 351, the National Vocational Training Act which was approved by the then President – Edward Akufo-Addo on 12th January, 1971. This institute was tasked to create and regulate apprenticeship, and other training programmes for industrial and administrative workers as well as the trainers and instructor responsible for such purposes. Other responsibilities include the provision of vocational assistance in career advancement in industry and development of training standards in trade testing. On the international front, the body was expected to maintain cordial technical relations with international organisations engaging in activities linked with vocational training. In 1990, the National Coordinating Committee for Technical and Vocational Education and Training (NACVET) was established to prepare policies and organise all issues regarding TVET and provide pieces of advice on strategies to implement towards the achievement of a desirable economy and produce employable young people in both formal and informal sectors. There was University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 30 the role of mainstreaming the evaluation, monitoring and accreditation processes TVET system in Ghana. With all these duties in view, the NACVET successfully formulated a policy on technical vocation education as well as initiate the premier National Occupational Standards (NOS) for some designated trade areas in Ghana by a body of professionals. The Ministry of Employment and Social Welfare and the UNDP/ILO umbrella Programme for Standard Employment Creation developed the Models of Employable Skills (MES) curriculum for some 40 selected trade areas. The Umbrella programme focused on the promotion and sustainability of employment policies and programmes through comprehensive government enablement to plan and monitor employment policies, the development of micro and small business programmes. Based on the umbrella programme, NACVET introduced and emphasised “self-employment” as a key component of TVET and as such integrated entrepreneur education into the syllabus for all TVET Institutions. In comparison, the NVTI did not magnify coordination functions in its operation rather trading provider roles through its respective institutes. NACVET on the other hand made evident progress but was challenged with the unavailability of parliamentary backing, hence the need for the establishment of a council for TVET passed by an Act of Parliament. Moving on, the Commission for Technical and Vocational Education and Training (COTVET) Preparatory Technical Committee (CPTC) was introduced in June 2006 with some non-theoretical assistance from TVETs Project of Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA). This 20-member committee was seen to draft the implementation of the TVET policy, the functionalisation of the COTVET Act among others. This time, the committee called on representatives from the public and private sectors. In a nutshell, the evolution of the TVET sector from 1990 to 2012 has been one filled with shaping and re-shaping of policies, programmes, and structures towards the successful University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 31 implantation of TVET in the country and most especially, to see to the honing of skills for employment purposes. Despite the challenges identified by Saskatchewan Polytechnic (2016) as the lack of state-of-the- art infrastructure at most institutions, outmoded curriculum, inexperienced instructions, lack of cohesion between governments and other stakeholders, and low levels of female enrolment, the council has been applauded for its investment in an equitable and sustainable TVET sector. Through the Council, National TVET Qualifications Framework (NTVETQF) is currently in operation, usage of Competency-Based Training (CBT) has been intensified, and a strategic plan for the transformation of TVET (2018-2022) has been formulated and approved as well as the rebranding of TVET through projects implemented on Public Private-Partnership basis. The matters related to TVET in Ghana are tackled in relation to the commission's 5-year strategic plan. The commission is entrusted with the overarching responsibility of improving Ghana's workforce to boost productivity and employment. In 2020, the Commission for Technical and Vocational Education and Training (CTVET) was established by ACT 1023 to facilitate the evolution of the TVET sector for sustainable development. The Act in conjunction with the Pre-Tertiary Education Act (ACT 1049) paved way for the creation of CTVET and the TVET service. Pre-Tertiary level TVET in contrast to the former level is offered at various training centres nationwide with programmes taught spanning the different levels of the NTVETQF. Currently, there are thirteen categories of these service providers and 238 institutions under them. Programmes range from agriculture to computer-based University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 32 beauty and cosmetology art creation technology, electrical and tailoring. In all, there are 29 programmes to choose from either in a public or private pre-tertiary TVET institution. Concerning the recent report released, the Ghana Education Service institutions have the highest enrolment from 2015 to 2020. There was a recorded increase in the National Vocational Training Institute institution’s enrolment. There by resulting in a rise from 5,192 in 2015 to 11,282 in 2019. It can be deduced that the pre-tertiary TVET institutions are patronised more compared to the tertiary. In a field survey, primary data collected from 85 TVET institutions indicated that the underlying reasons and rate for learner dropouts during the 2018/2019 academic year in the pre- tertiary schools had multiplied with majority being the youth with 94.89 percentage out of 841 learners and the paramount reason being inability to pay fees. Other reasons discovered include the death of a guardian, another employment opportunity, early marriage, the proximity of the institution, and gender related issues (CTVET, 2021). As of now, accredited TVET training providers are mandated to enrol learners on the NTVETQF where eight levels of qualification are made available fashioned to suit competency-based training (CBT). The commission in collaboration with the German government and its development organisation, KfW through the Ghana TVET Voucher (GTV) reaches out to registered owners of small and medium enterprises, their workers, and apprentices to expand access to TVET in the informal sector. Number of male and female beneficiaries nationwide are 5,136 and 13,472 respectively. It is surprising to discover such a gap between the beneficiaries when in contrast, Farm Ghana International (2021) reported that most young people enrolled in TVET are men. The coordinator stated that the project had successfully seen 18,000 beneficiaries since 2017 with 73 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 33 percent being females. It is envisioned that the third phase will take off and continue to ensure that CBT will be magnified as opposed to traditional system of training (GIZ, n.d; Joy News, 2022). With efforts to promote inclusive TVET, adequate provision is being put in place to ensure Persons with Disabilities (PWDs) can participate in TVET. Other relevant pathways created and being implemented are the Workplace Experience Learning (WEL) Policy and Recognition of Prior Learning (CTVET, 2021). In summary, Ghana has over the years been collaborating and receiving support from partners in developing both the formal and informal TVET sectors as TVET poses as an important tool for government in the decrement of unemployment, and to provide workforce to the private sector as well as to attract foreign investments. Notable of these partners are GIZ, KfW, World Bank, UNESCO, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS), European Union, African Development Bank (AfDB) and Mastercard Foundation. 2.11 Challenges of TVET Notwithstanding all the projects and policies designed and implemented to boost the sector, the sector is still characterised by inadequacies that are affecting the level of skills development needed for economic growth and development (Dadzie et. al., 2020). These include inadequate number of technical institutions, inefficient and ineffective training programmes in terms of quality, lack of resources to establish a business after completing the training, a lack of appropriate and applied technology, and growing mismatch between industry requirements and training provided by the sector. Others include the extensive concern about the poor quality of training and training outlets, and existing negative perceptions, and attitudes towards TVET. COTVET has evidentially taken certain measures to solve these challenges. However, more investment is needed to achieve the University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 34 required goals in terms of popularity, resources, and effective policies (Akyeampong, 2010; Atchoarena and Delluc, 2002). In furtherance, the unresponsive characteristics of the existing curriculum stand in disagreement with the needs of the trainees and are not in sync with the demands of industry. Thus, much attention is not given to practical training and professional skills development even though they are critically needed in the current job market. Emphasis is laid on the excessive theoretical orientation of the programmes compared to workshop practical skills, which is crucial to the development of a skilled workforce to purposefully substantiate productivity (Jumpah, 2020). As per Huut's research (2018) conducted in the Northern Region of Ghana, vocational training is regarded as having lower status compared to general secondary education. However, it was found that vocational training offered a higher probability of job prospects. Nevertheless, the current reality contradicts this as the probability of finding employment becomes more uncertain when facing certain challenges. One of such challenge is the production of graduates with limited practical knowledge, contributing to the growing population of unemployed youth. Consequently, the proposed solution itself becomes a disguised problem (Ansah et al., 2013). 2.12 Theoretical Framework This study utilises the Knowledge, Attitude and Practice (KAP) theory model. This theory originated in the 1950s and was mostly used in the family planning and population research fields (Muleme et al., 2017). The KAP model, as employed in health education, is a logical model built on the premise that enhancing individual knowledge will have an impact on changing behaviour (World Health Organisation, 2008). Findings of studies that utilise this theory provide context- University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 35 specific information pertaining to what is known, believed, done, and the information needs. Here, structured, or semi-structured questionnaires are administered to participants and either quantitative or qualitative data is gathered (Jacobsen, 2021). KAP surveys, both theoretically and empirically have proven to aid in the identification of knowledge gaps, cultural beliefs, or behavioural patterns that may expedite comprehension and action as well as information that is known and attitudes that are frequently held. To some degree, information gathered using this theory can identify factors influencing behaviours that are not known to most people, reasons for their attitudes, how and why people practice such. KAP surveys can also evaluate communication procedures and sources that are key to defining effective activities and messages in youth unemployment and TVET. In addition, these surveys help in identifying the needs, problems, and barriers in programme delivery, as well as remedies for improving the quality and accessibility of services. Misconceptions and misunderstandings that may hinder the smooth rolling out of activities to be implemented alongside potential barriers to behaviour change are unearthed (World Health Organisation, 2008). Many researchers have employed this theory for diverse studies, most especially in the health sector. In 2019, a novel disease – COVID-19 originated in China and spread abroad, causing loss of lives, panic, and economic struggles. There was the need for various health practitioners to ascertain the knowledge, behaviour and attitude of people towards it. Hence, the utilisation of KAP theory. Roy et al. (2020) discovered at the time that there was moderate awareness related to transmission and symptoms of COVID-19 among the educated population in India, adequate awareness among public regarding preventive measures for COVID-19 infection, a positive University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 36 attitude of the public towards social distancing, avoiding party and travel and maintaining hygiene. More than 80 percent of people perceive that mental healthcare is needed to deal with their issues during this COVID-19 pandemic. In 2021, a similar study was undertaken by the Turkish Red Crescent Society (TRCS) as an assessment of COVID-19 in Turkey and the findings did provide information on the efforts being put in place in addressing the pandemic. It also helped the researchers to evaluate their investment in their participants. The KAP theory is not without criticism. It has been criticised on several grounds. Some of these limitations are explained hereafter. The first is the issue that creating and executing a good KAP study is reported not to be as easy as it appears. Much thought is required to go into the selection of the target population, the items in the instrument, the creation of options for answers to items in the instrument, the decision on how the instrument will be scored, and then the validation of the instrument (Jacobsen, 2021). In addressing this criticism, the instrument for this study was pre- tested prior to the rolling out of the actual survey in ensuring that the interview guide and questionnaire is good and understandable. The pilot test was conducted with respondents who were not included in the actual study. This was vital to increasing the reliability and validity of the research instrument by identifying the strengths, weaknesses, and consistency of the questions before the analysis of the actual results (Andrade et al., 2020). The awareness of young people regarding TVET is very significant to minimise youth unemployment. The study findings will expose readers and stakeholders to what the youth think and know about TVET, and whether they also perceive it as a viable response to youth unemployment as projected over time. Inclusively, this theory provides a clear perspective behind University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 37 the persistent rise in unemployment amongst young people despite the increasing campaign of TVET as the solution. It also seeks to guide the implementation of TVET interventions. Thus, the usage of this theory will generate findings that will be essential for the development of cost- effective and sustainable interventions as the success of this intervention in a resource-limited setting depends largely on the knowledge, attitude, and practice of the beneficiaries. 2.13 Conceptual Framework This conceptual framework is of essential value to this study. It helps in appreciating and examining the effectiveness of TVET in addressing youth unemployment. The major assumptions regarding the interrelationship between KAP is that, the level of knowledge about a phenomenon influences the attitudes generated towards that phenomenon and consequently the actions towards it. In relation to this study, the interrelationship between KAP are as follows: 1. Becoming an employer or employee in the TVET industry is a function of skill acquisition and utilisation (positive practices). This assumption suggests that whether someone becomes an employer or an employee in the TVET industry is primarily determined by the acquisition and utilisation of skills, which are considered positive practices. Thus, becoming an employer implies that individuals who acquire and effectively use specific skills in the TVET industry have the potential to become employers. In other words, they can start and manage their businesses or organisations within this sector, which may involve employing others. On the other hand, those who acquire and effectively utilise relevant skills may also find opportunities to become employees within the TVET industry. They can work for established businesses or institutions in roles that require the application of these skills. In order for a youth to become any of these two, the assumption emphasises the importance University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 38 of first acquiring TVET skills. This typically involves gaining practical, hands-on skills related to a particular trade or profession. It may include technical or vocational skills, such as catering, carpentry, plumbing, or IT skills. The assumption also underscores the significance of utilising acquired skills in a positive and productive manner. This suggests that it is not enough to have the skills; it is equally essential to apply them effectively in one's work or business if employment status is to be attained. In conclusion, this assumption suggests that in the TVET industry, whether an individual becomes an employer (a business owner) or an employee is largely determined by their ability to acquire specific skills relevant to the industry and then putting those skills into productive use. It highlights the pivotal role that skill development and practical application play in shaping career paths within the TVET sector. 2. Positive practices regarding TVET employment are largely the function of positive attitudes. This assumption suggests that the quality of practices and outcomes related to employment within the TVET industry is primarily influenced by individuals' positive attitudes. TVET employment, being jobs or careers within the Technical and Vocational Education and Training sector typically require specialised technical skills and knowledge. Positive practices also imply that individuals in TVET employment are engaged in productive, effective, and beneficial actions and behaviours related to TVET. This can include the acquisition and utilisation of skills, providing quality services, contributing to their workplaces, and actively participating in their roles. The assumption emphasises the importance of individuals holding positive attitudes towards their work, the industry, and their own capabilities. Positive attitudes can include optimism, enthusiasm, a strong work ethic, a willingness to learn and improve, and a general positive outlook. In explaining further, this assumption suggests that the quality of practices in TVET employment is significantly University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 39 determined by the attitudes of the individuals involved. In other words, individuals with positive attitudes are more likely to perform their job roles effectively, contribute positively to their workplaces, and have better outcomes in their careers within the TVET industry. For example, someone with a positive attitude towards TVET is more likely to be motivated to gain TVET skills, adapt to changes and challenges in the field. Conclusively, this assumption recognises the impact of individual attitudes on the success and effectiveness of employees within the TVET industry. 3. Positive attitudes regarding TVET industry are the functions of knowledge of TVET industry This assumption suggests that positive attitudes towards the TVET industry are primarily influenced by individuals' level of awareness and knowledge about the industry. Awareness or knowledge implies understanding and information about the TVET industry. It includes knowing the purposes, benefits, and opportunities within the field. This assumption suggests that individuals who have a positive attitude towards the TVET industry are likely to possess a significant level of awareness or knowledge about it. In other words, their positive feelings and opinions about the industry are associated with their understanding of what the industry entails, its role and the value it offers. For example, someone with positive attitudes about the TVET industry may have an understanding of the various careers and opportunities it provides. He or she may also have knowledge about the skills and competencies that can be gained through TVET programmes as well as the awareness of the importance of TVET in addressing workforce needs and contributing to economic development. In this context, the assumption recognises that awareness and knowledge play a crucial role in shaping individuals' knowledge, perceptions and attitudes towards the TVET industry. It suggests that informed individuals are more likely to appreciate the industry and view it positively. The conceptual framework is further illustrated in Figure 2.1 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 40 Figure 2.1: Conceptual Framework Independent Variables Source: Researcher’s Construct (2022) Youth Employment Outcome Employee Self-Employment TVET Dependent Variable Attitude Knowledge ◆ ◆ ◆ ◆ Types Opportunities Limitations Cost of training ◆ ◆ ◆ Willingness to learn Optimism/ enthusiasm General Positive Outlook Practice ◆ Training ◆ Business University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 41 CHAPTER THREE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.0 Introduction This chapter presents the methodology used in the research process which aids in comprehending and appreciating the issue being explored. The first section of the chapter provides a description of the profile of the study area, Awutu Senya East Municipality and highlights of some of the characteristics of the municipality. The composition and characteristics of the study area, especially the social orientation and economic opportunities are key to exploring TVET as an opportunity in tackling youth unemployment in the municipality. The second section focuses on the research design, the study population, the sampling techniques, sample size, the sources of data, and the analytical processes as well as the limitations of the study. 3.1 Profile of the Study Area Awutu Senya East Municipal Assembly (ASEMA) was carved out of the former Awutu Senya District on 28th June, 2012 by Legislative Instrument (L.I) 2025 and elevated to a municipal status on 15th March 2018, with Kasoa as its administrative capital. This was done to effectively facilitate government’s decentralisation initiatives and local governance system (Ghana Districts, 2006). ASEMA is one of the 261 Metropolitan, Municipal, and District Assemblies (MMDAs) in Ghana and one of the MMDAs in the Central Region. The municipal assembly aims to develop its inhabitants, with a mission to “facilitate the improvement in the quality of life of the people in close collaboration with the private sector and other development partners in the municipality through the mobilisation and the judicious use of resources and provision of Basic Socio-Economic University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 42 Development within the context of Commitment to Equity, Accountability, Transparency and Excellence” (GSS, 2014, p. 1). The municipality can boast of six zonal councils, namely, Zongo, Ofaakor, Akweley, Opeikuma, Walantu, and Kpormetey. It is also made up of fourteen electoral areas. The municipality is notably endowed with both natural and man-made resources like rocks and dams vital to the livelihood of members. 3.1.1 Population and Geographic Information of ASEMA From the 2021 census, the municipality recorded a population of 236,527 inhabitants with 51.2 percent being females and 48.8 percent males. Interestingly, “males ever born are more than females ever born but male children surviving are less than females surviving” (GSS, 2021, p. 10). Despite the large population in the municipality, most inhabitants are migrants from other parts of the country and some foreigners (from outside Ghana) who are either there for trading purposes or as permanent residents. The municipality’s population is categorised as youthful with about 56.2 percent of the population falling between the ages of 15 and 35 (Ghana Districts, 2006). With Ghana’s total population currently standing at 30,832,019, Central Region is recorded as one of the four most populated regions containing more than half of the entire population (54 percent) and one of the seven urbanised regions in the country. Awutu Senya East Municipality (ASEM) being the second most populous in the region is reportedly one of the major contributors to Ghana’s economy (GSS, 2014; 2021). Furthermore, Awutu Senya East Municipality is in the eastern part of the Central Region. It shares common boundaries with Ga South Municipal Assembly (in the Greater Accra Region) in the East, Awutu Senya District in the North and Gomoa East District in University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 43 the West and South respectively (See Figure 3.1). The municipality covers a total land area of about 108.004 sq. km, about 1.1 percent of the total land area of the Central Region (NDPC, 2017). Figure 3.1: Map of Awutu Senya East Municipal Assembly Source: (ASEMA Medium Term Development Plan 2022-2025) The indigenous people of the municipality are principally of the Guans tribe of Awutu, and they speak the Guan language or “Obutu” as referred to by the Ga-speaking community. Due to the proximity of the municipality from Accra and its vibrant economic environment, people of different tribes of Ghana such as the Gas, Akans, and Ewes, amongst others, have relocated to the municipality resulting in its cosmopolitan inclination. According to findings documented in the 2022-2025 MTDP, most of these settlers are of Akan origin and have made Akan the main Ghanaian language spoken in the municipality (MPCU, 2021). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 44 3.1.2 Economic Activities The main economic activities engaged in by residents of the municipality include commerce, (wholesale and retail), informal service sector and livestock production. The local economy includes large numbers of small and medium-scale businesses throughout the municipality, providing sources of employment for many. Nevertheless, lack of funds for business expansion poses a threat to the sustainability of the businesses thereby increasing the rate of unemployment (MPCU, 2021). Conclusively, the services and sales sectors are reported as the occupations with the highest populations, followed by the craft-related trades. The municipality takes pride in having the highest population engaged in service, sales and craft industries. Furthermore, the technical and vocational sector, particularly in the repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles, stands as the primary employer for the local populace. It is not just individuals working towards the industry's sustainability; the municipal assembly, along with its Social Welfare and Community Development officials, also plays a significant role. They achieve this by conducting periodic informal technical and vocational training programmes for local residents. To give an example, two hundred skilled craftsmen underwent training in contemporary methods for building basic homes. Additionally, other training initiatives included a food safety programme for 60 food vendors, training for 33 young individuals in tie and dye production, training for 47 young people in liquid soap manufacturing, and another 33 of the youth received instruction in batik artistry (MPCU, 2021). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 45 3.1.3 Education and Infrastructure There are 41 public basic schools, 239 private basic schools, and 8 private and one public secondary cycle schools in the municipality. There are numerous social amenities in the municipality out of which the private ones form the majority and as such employ more than 80 percent of the working population. They include 26 government and 17 private health facilities, markets, financial institutions, educational facilities, police station, hotels, lorry stations and public washrooms among others (MPCU, 2021; GSS, 2014). It is therefore obvious that depending largely on government institutions is not a possibility in ASEMA hence the emphasis being placed on the private sector. 3.1.4 Governance The Awutu Senya East Municipal Assembly is the highest governing body at the municipal level and was established by Legislative Instrument (L.I) 2025. The assembly is made up of 19 assembly members with 6 appointed and 13 elected. The municipality is headed by the Municipal Chief Executive (MCE) who is appointed by the President with approval by at least two-thirds of the assembly members (Ghana Districts, 2006). In 2021, Hon. Anita Love Obo Amissah assumed offic