DIAGNOSIS OF COCOA SWOLLEN SHOOT VIRUS DISEASE BY POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION (PCR). A THESIS SUBMITTED BY RITA NANA DARKOAH OSEI TO THE DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY, FACULTY OF SCIENCE, UNIVERSITY OF GHANA IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF MASTER OF PHILOSOPHY (M. PHIL.) DEGREE DECEMBER 2000 6 & R - C I 7 ' M ' t x C . | £ f ' L, 3 7 0 3 8 2 j h & iS t r ; - • Declaration I, RITA NANA DARKOAH OSEI HEREBY DECLARE THAT THE EXPERIMENTAL WORK DESCRIBED IN THIS PROJECT WAS CARRIED OUT BY ME EXCEPT FOR THE REFERENCES TO THE WORK OF OTHER RESEARCHERS WHICH HAVE BEEN DULY CITED. RITA NANA DARKOAH OSEI (CANDIDATE) (SUPERVISOR) DR Y. D. OSEI (SUPERVISOR) ii Dedication TO MY MUM MBS AFUA SAFOAA BUSIA iii Acknowledgements My sincere thanks go to my supervisors Dr. Yaa Difie Osei and Dr. Sammy Tawiah Sackey for their guidance, advice and support throughout this project. I would also like to acknowledge with gratitude the assistance given to me by Professors Neil Olszweski and Ben Lockhart of the University of Minnesota. My gratitude goes to the Ghana Cocoa Growers’ Research Association (GCGRA) and Biscuits, Chocolate and Confectionery Companies Alliance (BCCCA), who jointly funded this research through Cocoa Research Institute of Ghana (CRIG). I am sincerely grateful to the authority of CRIG, especially Dr. G. KL Owusu (Director) for making it possible for me to cany out this research at CRIG. My appreciation goes to Doctors Ollennu, Opoku-Ameyaw, Boye Frimpong, Takrama, Ackonor and Mr. Prempeh for their support. I am also grateful to all the staff of the Physiology/Biochemistry and Pathology Divisions, especially Miss Evelyn Kwame, Messrs Francis Osae-Awuku, Ben Owusu-Ant wi, Fiifi Adu-Amankwa and Sammy Affram for their tremendous help. I would also like to acknowledge all the lecturers, students and staff of the Biochemistry Department, University of Ghana especially, Prof. Gyang and my mates John, Kwamina, and Nii Kpani. I am grateful to Lynn and all working in Lab 659 (Department of Plant Biology, University of Minnesota) for their support. I am also grateful to Doctors M Wilson, K. M Bosompem and G Armah, Mr. C. Brown, Mr. Ayim, Michael, Harry and iv Anita, and all staff of Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research (NMIMR), Accra, especially members of Parasitolgy Unit Room 133, for their various contributions to this work. To all my friends, especially Lydia and Kwame (Minnesota), Francis, Kwabena, Ato, Kojo, Peace, Christabel and Evelyn, I am very grateful for your friendship and support. My utmost gratitude goes to my Mum, my sisters Mercy and Joyce, my brothers Ernest, Charles, Ishmael, Nat and Robert, my special cousin Afua, my nephews Paa Kwesi, Papa, Fiifi, Paa Kow and my niece Menee for their immense love and support. I will finally thank the Lord God Almighty for His abundant love and grace, and for making things possible for me. v Abstract Cocoa swollen shoot virus disease causes severe damage to cocoa farms leading to substantial losses in crop yield and therefore the country’s revenue from cocoa. This study set out to design new PCR primers for the detection of the virus that causes the disease. Thirty-six cocoa swollen shoot virus (CSSV) isolates, randomly selected from 5 main groups based on serological and biological properties from the CRIG museum at Tafo were used Viral DNA extracted and purified from the infected leaves were used for PCR using two sets of universal badna primers 2+T and 3+T. The multiple amplification bands produced were cut out, gel purified and hybridised against full length cloned PCR DNA of CSSV New Juaben probes to detect the amplification products of virus origin. These were then cloned, sequenced and new primers designed based on consensus sequences derived from the alignment of the CSSV sequences with sequences from other closely related badna viruses. The new pair of primers (badna primers 1+4) gave a single PCR amplification product of 600 base pairs. The thirty-six CSSV isolates from the CRIG museum were screened with the new primers to test the efficacy of these new primers. Out of the 36 isolates screened, 28 gave the expected amplification product and 8 did not give any amplification products. The new primers in comparison with the old primers can be said to be better at detecting CSSV. Table of Contents DECLARATION 11 DEDICATION 111 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS IV ABSTRACT VI TABLE OF CONTENTS V,i LIST OF FIGURES x LIST OF TABLES X1 CHAPTER ONE 1 INTRODUCTION 1 1.0 Introduction 1 CHAPTER TWO 5 2.0 Literature Review 5 2.1 Cocoa swollen shoot virus diseasse 5 2.2 Symptoms 5 2.3 Economic impact and control of CSSVD 5 2.4 The virus morphology and genetics 6 2.5 Virus extraction and purification 9 2.6 DNA extraction and purification 10 2.7 Polymerase chain reaction 11 2.7.1 Uses of PCR 15 2.8 DNA Hybridisation analysis 16 2.9 Cloning of PCR amplification products 17 2.9.1 Ligation 17 2.9.2 Transformation, cell growth and screening of recombinants 18 2.9.3 Plasmid harvesting 18 2.9.4 Caesium chloride (CsCl) - ethidium bromide purification 19 2.10 DNA sequencing 19 2.10.1 Sanger’s method 20 v i i 2.11 Design of PCR primers 22 CHAPTER THREE 23 3.0 MATERIALS AND METHODS 23 3.1 Materials 23 3.1.1 Chemical and Reagents 23 3.2 Methods 24 3.2.1 Virus isolates 24 3.2.2 Extraction and purification of virus 28 3.2.2.1 Extraction of virus 28 3 2.2.2 Sucrose cushion centrifugation 29 3.2.3 Extraction and purification of virus DNA 29 3.2.4 DNA purification for PCR 30 3.2.4.1 QIAGEN purification 30 32.4.2 2-butoxyethanol purification 31 3.2.5 Agarose gel electrophoresis 32 3.2.6 Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) 32 3.2.7 Gel-purification of PCR products and clones 35 3.2.8. Hybridisation analysis 35 3.2.8.1 Southern DNA transfer 35 3.2.8.2 Dot blots 36 3.2.8.3 Synthesis of DNA probes 36 3.2.8 4 Hybridisation reaction 37 3.2.8.5 Washing and enzyme reaction 37 3.2.8.6 Removal of colour and probe 38 3.2.9 Cloning 39 3.2.9.1 Ligation reaction 39 3.2.9.2 Preparation of competent cells 40 3.2.93 Transformation 41 3.2.9.4 Cell culture and screening 41 3.2.10 Isolation of plasmids 42 3.2.11 Restriction digests 42 v i i i 3.2.12 Large scale plasmid isolation 3.2.13 Caesium chloride purification 3.2.14 DNA sequencing 3.2.14.1 Sequencing gel 3.2.14.2 Primer radio-labelling 3.2.14.3 Sequencing gel electrophoresis 3.2.15 Primer design 3.2.16 PCR annealing temperature optimisation and primer testing CHAPTER FOUR 4.0 RESULTS 4.1 Selection and grouping of isolates 4.2 Extraction and purification of virus and virus DNA 4.3 Polymerase chain reaction analysis 4.4 Gel purification of PCR amplification products 4.5 Hybridisation analysis of PCR products 4.6 Cloning of PCR DNA 4.7 Primer design 4.8 Results of annealing temperature optimisation 4.9 Testing of primers 1+4 4.10 Dot blot hybridisation analysis of viral DNA with 1+4 PCR DNA probes 4.11 CSSV sequences from clones from new primers 1+4 CHAPTER FIVE 5.0 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION REFERENCES 43 43 44 44 44 45 46 46 47 47 47 47 48 51 51 54 57 59 59 65 68 70 70 76 ix List of Figures Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the PCR process 12 Figure 2 Map of Ghana showing the regional distribution of the 27 selected isolates Figure 3 The CSSV Genome 34 Figure 4 PCR amplification products with primers 2+T and 3+T 49 Figure 5 Gel-purified PCR amplification bands using primers 52 badna 3+T and 2+T Figure 6 Hybridised membrane of gel-purified PCR products 53 Figure 7 Screening of PCR clones by restriction digestion of 56 plasmids Figure 8 Alignment of conserved region of CSSV sequence with 58 that of the other badna viruses Figure 9 Optimisation of PCR annealing temperature for primers 60 1+4 using CSSV 1A DNA Figure 10 PCR with DNA from isolates from CRIG museum 61 using primers 1+4 Figure 11 CSSV sequences from new primers 69 x Table 1 Selection of isolates 25 Table 2: Analysis of CSSV CRIG museum isolates by PCR using 50 universal badna primers 2+T and 3+T. Table 3 Summary of results of experiment to identify virus-coded 55 PCR amplification products. Table 4 Analysis of CSSV CRIG museum isolates by PCR using new 63 badna primers 1+4. Table 5 Dot blot hybridisation analysis of virus DNA from CSSV 66 isolates with probes using 1+4 PCR products List of Tables xi CHAPTER ONE 1.0 INTRODUCTION Cocoa production in Ghana has over the years faced many challenges, but perhaps the most enduring has been cocoa swollen shoot disease. Initially, this was thought to be an agronomic problem, as the disease manifested itself by severe systemic leaf mosaic symptoms. Its name, swollen shoot disease, refers to the swelling of the stem during cancerous proliferation of phloem cells, which process contributes to the apical death of the plant. Swollen shoot disease was first reported in the Eastern region of the then Gold Coast in 1936 (Dale, 1962). Swollen shoot disease control strategies were based on a zero tolerance philosophy and involved cutting down of infected trees and those in contact with them. Alternative control measures such as the use of barrier crops to restrict the spread of the disease, use of resistant/tolerant cocoa varieties, and cross-protection using serologically closely related mild isolates of the Cocoa Swollen Shoot Virus (CSSV) are still being investigated (Hughes et al., 1995). Also, breeding programmes are pursued to develop resistant breeds, and cultural methods are used to control cocoa swollen shoot disease. For example, the Cocoa Services Division (CSD) in Ghana has a sustained program to advise fanners on methods of limiting the spread of the disease before new farms are cultivated. However, cutting down of infected trees remains the only effective method of controlling the disease in Ghana. Studies into cocoa swollen shoot disease at the Cocoa Research Institute of Ghana have focused on the biochemical, biophysical, genomic and biological characterization of the disease causal agent. Methods have thus been developed for the extraction and l purification of the virus isolates and these in turn have facilitated the development of a host of diagnostic tools for their detection and identification in plant tissue extracts. More recently, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and immunocapture PCR (ICPCR) have been used for the detection of CSSV using three sets of primers (Sackey, 1995; Sackey et a l, 1995; Hoffman et al., 1997). The first set of primers, based on nucleotide sequences derived from the severe CSSV 1 A, gave single DNA products, but these were specific for CSSV 1A and closely related isolates and therefore could not detect many isolates that fell outside the 1A group (Sackey and Hull, 1991). The other two pairs of primers were designed by Lockhart and Olszewski (1993) based on the nucleotide sequence of three conserved bacilliform DNA virus (badna virus) genomic regions, the tRNAmct binding site, reverse transcriptase and ribonuclease H genes. The nucleotide sequences used were those from the badnaviruses (commelina yellow mottle virus (CoYMV), sugar cane bacilliform virus (SCBV), Kalanchoe top spotting virus (KTSV) and rice tungro bacilliform virus (RTBV). These, however, were degenerate and most CSSV isolates gave many amplification products, most of which were found to be artefacts (Sackey etal., 1995). Breeding programs in producing countries rely on new introductions from the South American origin of the Theobroma species, as well as exchanges of improved materials from member countries of the Cocoa Producers’ Alliance (CPA). These programs therefore rely on the establishment of quarantine facilities in non-cocoa producing countries in North America and Europe, where material from different parts of the cocoa producing world are assembled and multiplied for distribution. This requires that material received is screened for the major pests and diseases including the debilitating 2 witches broom disease of South America and cocoa swollen shoot disease of West Africa. Ghana as a major cocoa producing country contributes towards this international effort at conservation of cocoa germplasm. As one of the sources of the disease, Ghana also contributes towards sustaining the program by providing access to diagnostic tools developed for the detection of the various isolates in the country. Even though the tools currently available are adequate for Ghana’s needs, they do not entirely address the requirements of the international quarantine programmes which have to screen for isolates from all of the West African sub-region. This initiative therefore aims at developing a new universal diagnostic system for the detection and identification of the badnaviruses (Bacilliform DNA viruses) responsible for the disease in cocoa. The project was therefore carried out to identify and design new universal PCR primers for the detection of CSSV. The existing primers designed by Lockhart and Olszewski (1993) and previously described do not include sequences from cocoa swollen shoot virus but those from other key badnaviruses, namely BSV, CoYMV, ScBV, KTSV and RTBV. The first three are known in Ghana, as well as Discorea alata bacilliform virus (DaBV). Therefore, it was proposed to retain the contribution of BSV, CoYMV, ScBV particularly as these bananas, plantains, and sugarcane are often found in cocoa farms, while commelina is common as a weed. The nucleotide sequences of CSSV and DaBV were to be introduced into the new set of primers. 3 The general objectives of the study were to: a. develop nucleotide sequences covering a defined segment of several CSSV isolates b. use these sequences to design oligonucleotide primers for the rapid detection of bacilliform DNA viruses, and c. test the specificity and sensitivity of the new primers. Specific objectives The specific objectives were: i. collection of CSSV infected leaves from the Cocoa Research Institute of Ghana (CRIG) museum ii. extraction and purification of virus isolates from infected leaves iii. extraction and purification of virus DNA iv. amplification of DNA by PCR using the universal badna primers 2+T and 3+T. v. identification of virus coded PCR amplification products by hybridisation of Southern blots vi. cloning of the virus coded DNA species vii. sequencing of cloned PCR DNA to develop nucleotide sequence database using representatives of virus groups determined by serological methods and other badna viruses closely related to the CSSV viii. design of new primers based on nucleotide sequence database ix. verification of the efficacy of the new primers. 4 CHAPTER TWO 2 .0 LITERATURE R EVIEW 2.1 Cocoa swollen shoot virus disease Cocoa Swollen Shoot Virus Disease (CSSVD) was first reported in Ghana in 1936 (Dale, 1962) and in 1938, Posnette (1940) suggested that the disease was caused by several isolates of cocoa swollen shoot virus (CSSV) and transmitted by several species of mealy bugs in a semi- persistent manner. 2.2 Host symptoms CSSVD is characterised by root and stem swellings, mosaic leaf chlorosis, red vein- banding of flush leaves, rounding of pods containing fewer, smaller beans in some infected trees and in some severe cases, premature death of the plant (Posnette, 1947). Various isolates show a range of combinations of these symptoms. Healthy cocoa trees that become infected may not show any symptoms for a considerable time. This latent period varies according to the type of strain of the virus, the age and condition of the tree. The virulent strains may produce severe symptoms within five months on sensitive Amelanado, but the mild strains may not express themselves for two years or more (Wood and Lass, 1985). 2.3 Economic impact and control of CSSVD Swollen shoot disease causes severe damage to cocoa farms and therefore substantial losses in crop yield and revenue. The strategies for disease control were based on a zero tolerance philosophy and involved cutting down of infected trees and those in contact with them. At the beginning of the cutting out campaign in 1956, over a million affected and contact trees were removed. By 1982, it was estimated that 185.5 million 5 trees had already been removed in the Eastern Region alone and there were still 31.2 million trees to be removed (Owusu and Thresh, 1983). According to Owusu and Thresh (1983), only 23% of all infected trees in a new outbreak were identified because many of the infected trees were not noticed or were in the latent phase of infection. It was also realised that new infections were occurring faster than the removal of the infected trees (Legg, 1982). However, cutting down of infected trees still remains the only effective method of controlling the disease in Ghana. Alternative control measures such as the use of barrier crops to restrict the spread of the disease; breeding for resistant/tolerant cocoa varieties and cross-protection using serologically closely related mild isolates are still being investigated (Hughes et al., 1995). There were also cultural methods where the Cocoa Services Division (CSD), Ghana, advised farmers before new farms were cultivated. 2.4 Virus morphology and genetics Electron microscopy data have shown that cocoa swollen shoot virus is a bullet shaped particle of about 142x 27mn in size (Agrios, 1997). Lot et al. (1991) showed that CSSV contained a double stranded DNA genome of molecular weight 7100 base pairs. It was proposed as a member of the Bacilliform DNA (Badna) virus (Lockhart, 1990) on account of its unenveloped bacilliform particles (Brunt et al., 1964) and circular double stranded DNA genome (Lot et al., 1991). Hagen et al. (1993) also provided the complete nucleotide sequence of the CSSV Agou 1 strain from the Republic of Togo, which partially defined the badnavirus genome organisation. Classification of the physico-chemical properties of CSSV has been hampered by a number of factors. These include the absence of a local lesion host for the biological 6 purification of the components of what may be mixed infections (Paine, 1945; Posnette, 1947; Posnette and Todd, 1955), and efficient methods of purifying the virus. Other difficulties were due to the feet that some of the isolates induced only stem swellings or transient leaf symptoms, and did not provide reliable sources of infected leaf material for virus purification and analysis. Consequently in Ghana, classification of viruses has been based on criteria like the location from which they were first isolated (Posnette, 1947) host range (Tinsley and Wharton, 1958; Legg and Bonney, 1967) and transmission vector (Roivainen, 1976). In some cases, classification was based on the indigenous or alternate host plants like Adcmsonia digitata (AD) and Cola chlamydantha (CC) from which they were isolated (Attafuah and Tinsley, 1958; Legg and Bonney, 1967). Lesemann et al. (1980), used immunosorbent electron microscopy (ISEM) to detect the virus particles. This method, however, required expensive inputs. With the development of more effective methods for the purification of the CSSV from infected cocoa leaves by Adomako el al. (1983), monoclonal and polyclonal antisera against severe 1A were produced. These have been used for the detection of the virus in infected tissue extracts and to establish relationship between isolates. Adomako et al. (1983) described the use of ISEM for the rapid detection of the CSSV in virus extract. Sagemann et al. (1983), used enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and in 1985 used ELISA and immunoelectron microscopy (IEM) for the detection of the CSSV, where the serological activity of the virus was evaluated. Sackey et al. (1990), also raised polyclonal antibodies which differentiated between severe isolates, 1A and Nsaba. These methods were good for the determination of the 7 serological relationships between CSSV isolates in the laboratory. They could also be used in the field only on trees with the symptoms. The disadvantages here were that, symptomless or transient infections could not be detected and the assay produced high background values when the antisera had high antibody content. In the virobacterial agglutination (VBA) method used by Hughes and Ollennu (1993), the test successfully detected CSSV in infected sap diluted 1/2560. The test was based on the affinity of protein A to the iron (Fe) region of IgG. The advantages here were that, the method was simple with rapid results and the IgG required was easy to prepare in the laboratory. However, the method was useful only in the detection of CSSV in freshly harvested leaf samples. Further developments in the diagnosis of CSSV include DNA hybridization and amplification methods. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was first used for CSSV diagnosis by Sackey et al. (1995) and immunocapture PCR (ICPCR) by Hoffman et al. (1997). Two different sets of primers were used in these studies. Sagemann et al. (1985) differentiated the CSSV isolates into five groups, (A-E) on the basis of leaf, stem and root symptoms, as well as serological properties by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and immunosorbent electron microscopy (ISEM). When these groups were compared with those based on area of first isolation and symptoms expressed, it was found that geographical location had no apparent relationship with the serologically characterised groups Sagemann et al. (1985). 2.5 Virus Extraction and Purification The extraction and concentration of CSSV have been made difficult by the presence of large amounts of tannins and mucilage in the cocoa leaves. Purification is however achieved by the addition of pectinase, polyethylene glycol (PEG), and standard sodium citrate (SSC), alternating high speed centrifugation and low speed centrifugation to remove cellular debris and filtration through celite and sepharose. The high speed centrifugation is carried out to pellet the virus while the low speed centrifugation is carried out to clarify the virus extract (Lot et al., 1991). More effective extraction, concentration and purification of CSSV from the infected leaves to give higher yields, was facilitated by the addition of the enzyme pectinase to the extraction buffer to degrade mucilage in the cocoa leaf extracts (Adomako et al., 1974). The mucilage and particulate host plant materials were effectively removed by the pectinase and the release of the virus particles from the leaves was enhanced. Polyethylene glycol (PEG 6000) in the extraction buffer enhanced precipitation of the virus particles. Once freed from the mucilage and plant materials, filtration and concentration were possible without losing much of the virus. Further purification of the extracts was necessary to get rid of more of the host plant and other unwanted materials. Filtration of crude preparations through Celite 545 (Adomako, 1974) was also found to be very beneficial but the yield of virus was compromised by the filtration step. 9 2.6 DNA Extraction and Purification The quality of the virus DNA extracted is very crucial for PCR and depends on the source material (tissue), presence or absence of contaminants, method of extraction and purification and the precautions taken to maintain the integrity of the DNA. The plant tissues are known to contain large quantities of proteins, cell wall materials, and phenolic compounds which tend to contaminate the virus extract. The extraction buffer contains ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA), sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS), Tris-HCl and MgCfe. The EDTA inhibits the activities of naturally occurring DNase, which will degrade the virus DNA once it is released from its protective walls. The SDS is an ionic detergent that dissolves away lipid membranes to free the DNA (Roe et al., 1996). Proteinase K is also added to break down proteins. Extraction with either Tris-EDTA (TE) saturated phenol and phenol: chloroform solution removes the SDS, proteins and other related substances from the nucleic acid- buffer mixture (Newton and Graham, 1997). Addition of sodium acetate and ethanol or NaCl and isopropanol to the aqueous upper phase precipitate the virus DNA. To further purify the virus DNA, the enzyme RNase may be used to digest contaminating RNA. Other purification methods like the use of 2- butoxyethanol can be used to remove more polysaccharides and phenolic compounds. There are also spin column chromatography methods that can be used to clean up the DNA sample and to get rid of very small single stranded and double stranded molecules. 10 2.7 Polymerase Chain Reaction The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is an in-vitro process used for amplifying specific regions of the genome of DNA by a factor of 106 (Mullis et al., 1986; Mullis and Faloona, 1987). The amplification is achieved in the presence of suitable primers, deoxynucleoside tri-phosphates (dNTPs), magnesium chloride (MgCl2), the DNA template to be amplified, the enzyme Taq DNA Polymerase and the enzyme buffer. The double stranded template DNA is first heat denatured to obtain single strands. The primer anneals to the strands and the Taq polymerase uses the dNTPs to extend the strand thus, producing another complementary strand (figure 1). PCR involves the repetitive cycles of heat denaturation of the double stranded DNA to be amplified at a high temperature (92-95°C), annealing of primers to template (complementary) DNA strands at a lower temperature (37-55°C) and extension of the new strands at 72°C. According to Saiki et al. (1988), the temperature chosen for annealing of the primer is a compromise. This is because at lower temperatures (37°C), annealing is more efficient but there is a significantly increased amount of mis-priming. At higher temperatures (55°C) however, there is increased amplification specificity but the overall efficiency is decreased. 11 Target Region ■ Unamplified DlslA % Denature and anneal primers Extend primers Denature and anneal primers Extend primers Denature and anneal primers Extend primers H yc | Cycles 4-30 -3' *3' =Shgrt "target’ product | =Long product Amplification of short ’target' product Figure 1. Schematic diagram of the PCR process 12 Normally, a series of reactions are set up to determine the optimal annealing temperature. Extension of the annealed primers by the Taq DNA polymerase uses the dNTPs at an increased temperature (72°C) for 3 minutes. The cycle then restarts. The result is an exponential increase of the DNA with the generation of over a million copies of the DNA of interest in several hours. The PCR process is directed by sequence-specific oligonucleotide primers of between 20-24 nucleotides in length. The primers are designed with the knowledge of the sequence to be amplified. The primers thus locate and anneal to complementary sequence on the template DNA. The annealing step is an important parameter in optimising the specificity of a PCR. The starting material, the template DNA may be single stranded or double stranded DNA. The DNA to be amplified should be free of contaminants or non-target materials to avoid their amplification rather than the target DNA. Normally, sub-nanogram quantities of the template DNA are used for PCR. Taq DNA Polymerase, the enzyme used in PCR is a thermostable polymerase isolated from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus aquaticus (Taq). Earlier reports on PCR by Saiki et al. (1985) and Mullis et al. (1987) involved the use of Klenow fragment of E. coli polymerase I. This enzyme is heat labile, therefore, fresh enzyme had to be added at the beginning of each cycle of the PCR. The results were the generation of a heterogeneous set of products in addition to the DNA of interest. This is due to the non­ specific binding of primers and non-processivity of the enzyme under those conditions. The discovery of Taq DNA polymerase therefore solved these problems because the 13 enzyme was added only once at the beginning of the reaction (Erlich, 1989). Apart from Taq DNA polymerase, its cloned and modified version, Tth DNA polymerase from Themtus thermophihis, Pfu DNA polymerase from Pyrococcus furiosus and a few others can also be used for PCR (Newton and Graham, 1997). Taq DNA polymerase has an optimal extension rate (polymerisation rate) of 35-100 nucleotides per second at between 70-80°C (Newton and Graham, 1997). Synthesis of DNA at higher temperatures was advantageous because non-specific binding was greatly reduced (Horn, 1988). The dNTPs are the building blocks of the DNA. They are made up of the four bases of the DNA (purine, pyrimidine, thymine and adenine) that are used by the Taq DNA polymerase to synthesize the new DNA strand. High purity dNTPs are used, normally at concentrations between 200-400|iM. However, Taq DNA polymerase has a higher fidelity even at lower dNTP concentrations (10-100(j.M). An optimal concentration here depends on the concentrations of MgCl2 and the primer, the number of PCR cycles, the length of the amplified product and the stringency of the reaction (Newton and Graham, 1997). The presence of divalent cations is critical in PCR. According to Chein et al. (1976), Mg2+ ions form a soluble complex with dNTPs, which is essential for dNTP incorporation. They also stimulate the polymerase activity and increase the Tm of the double stranded DNA and primer/template interaction. The optimal concentration of magnesium ions is quite low (1.0-1.5mM) thus, the template DNA should not contain high concentrations of chelating agents like ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA). 14 Any change in the volumes of any of the components of PCR will affect the concentration of the magnesium ions available. A change in the concentration of the MgCk can have a dramatic effect on the specificity and yield of the PCR products. Generally, the insufficiency of the ions will lead to low yields whiles excess will result in the accumulation of non-specific products (Newton and Graham, 1997). There are several buffers available for PCR. Most common buffers used with Taq DNA polymerase and its modified versions come in a lOx concentration and contain lOOmM Tris-HCl, pH 8.3 at room temperature; 500mM KC1; 15mM MgClz and 0.1% (w/v) gelatin. 2.7.1 Uses of PCR PCR has been used in the diagnosis of genetic disorders (SaiM et al., 1985; Saiki et al., 1988), the analysis of allelic sequence variation (Sambrook et al., 1989), and analysis of mutation or any research that involves the rapid cloning and sequencing of homologous DNA fragments (Howe and Ward, 1989). The PCR has also been used for the analysis of individual identity in forensic samples by the amplification of highly polymorphic DNA regions (Paabo et al., 1988; Higuchi et al., 1988), and the examination of nucleotide sequences from ancient preserved specimens (Paabo, 1990). Recently, PCR has been applied to difficult problems in developmental biology. For example, PCR of cDNA has been used to study V-J region combinations in the T-cell receptor a-chain (Loh et al., 1989) and the examination of the mRNAs for growth factors in small numbers of macrophages isolated from wounds actively undergoing healing (Rappolee etal., 1988). 15 2.8 DNA Hybridisation analysis. Hybridisation involves the use of a radioactively- or fluorescently-labelled probe made up of a piece of single stranded DNA to detect and bind to its complementary base pairs to form duplexes on a solid phase. A cloned virus DNA probe was used to identify virus coded PCR products. The DNA species to be hybridised are first separated according to size by agarose gel electrophoresis and then transferred onto a solid support/phase (normally a nitrocellulose filter or nylon membrane) through capillary action by the technique known as Southern transfer (Southern, 1975). Before the transfer, the DNA is denatured in situ to separate the duplex strand by causing breakage of the hydrogen bonds linking the complementary base pairs (Sambrook et al., 1989). The separation is achieved by either heating to a temperature (Tm) between 60-80°C or by soaking the gel in high salt concentrations. The nucleic acid species are neutralized in situ to prevent the separated strands from re-annealing. The relative positions of the nucleic adds fragments are maintained during the transfer (Sambrook et al., 1989). The DNA fragments are then immobilized onto the membrane by baking in a vacuum oven or cross-iinking in an Ultra Violet (UV) cross-linker before the hybridisation can take place (Khandjian, 1986). After hybridisation, the membrane is washed. A radioactively-labelled probe bound to its complementary sequence can be detected by autoradiography. The non-radioactively labelled probe can be detected by enzyme-linked immunoassay using antibody conjugate. A subsequent colour reaction is initiated at basic pH by the addition of a phosphate and a salt. A blue colour precipitate starts to form from within a few minutes up to three days. After the reaction, the membrane is washed in water and the 16 hybridised fragments can be seen visibly as blue bands. For re-use, the colour of the membrane can be removed with dimethyl formamide (DMF) and the probe removed with N ad and SDS. 2.9 Cloning of PCR amplification products Cloning of PCR products allows generation of relatively large amounts of the amplified region to be available whenever needed without having to repeat the reaction. PCR products are used in various other studies, such as for sequencing and hybridisation, thus the need to clone the amplicon (Newton and Graham, 1997). The cloning process involves the use of ligase to ligate the amplified DNA into a suitable enzyme digested vector to form a recombinant molecule. This is followed by transformation of the recombinant molecule into a suitable bacterial cell line, growth and screening of colonies by isolation of the plasmid DNA, enzyme digest and hybridisation with cloned virus DNA probe. 2.9.1 Ligation Ligation reaction involves the use of DNA ligase to introduce the amplified DNA template into the genome of a plasmid vector to form the recombinant molecule. The DNA ligase catalyses the reaction, where there is a formation of a 3’, 5’ phosphodiester bond that links two adjacent nucleotides of the amplified DNA and the plasmid vector. There is a wide range of plasmid vectors commercially available. They can be acquired already digested or they can be developed in the laboratory for cloning. There are the pUC series, the pGEM series, the pBluescript (Mezei and Storts, 1994) series and a lot 17 more For PCR cloning, dT overhang vectors can be used due to the dA-overhang in the PCR products. There are also commercially available blunt-ended cloning vectors like pCR-Script™ from Stratagene. To use the blunt-ended vectors for PCR the products will have to be polished to remove the dA- overhang. 2.9.2 Transformation, cell growth and screening for recombinants. Transformation involves the introduction of the recombinant DNA molecule into suitable competent bacteria cells for replication and multiplication. This can be achieved either by electroporation method where the competent cells are prepared and stored in glycerol. There is also the heat shock method where the cells are stored in calcium chloride. Here, the transformation mixture is given conditions of consecutive cold, hot and cold to enhance the uptake of the recombinant DNA molecule into the bacteria cells. The transformed cells are grown on agar plates containing the appropriate antibiotic, 5- bromo-4- chloro-3- indolyl-|3- D- galactoside (X-gal) and isopropylthio-P-D- galactoside (IPTG). IPTG induces the amino-terminal fragment of P- galactosidase and is capable of intra-allelic complementation with a defective form of p- galactosidase encoded by the bacterial cells. Bacteria exposed to IPTG thus form blue colonies in the presence of X-gal (Horwitz et al., 1964). 2.9.3 Plasmid harvesting Plasmids are isolated from single bacterial cell cultures. The plasmids can be harvested either by alkaline lysis, a modification of two methods (Bimboim and Doly, 1979; Ish- Horowicz and Burke, 1981) or by the heat lysis method adopted from Holmes and 18 Quigley (1981). In both cases, the cells are exposed to detergents and then lysed by boiling or treatment with alkali to release the recombinant molecule. The boiling method is however not normally recommended because endonuclease A is not completely inactivated and the bacteria release relatively large amounts of carbohydrate in this method (Sambrook et al., 1989). 2.9.4 Caesium chloride (CsCl) - ethidium bromide purification Equilibrium centrifugation in CsCl - ethidium bromide gradients of the plasmids has for many years been the method for the purification of plasmids, especially for large-scale preparations. According to Cantor and Schimmel (1980), the ethidium bromide causes the double helix of the DNA to unwind and bind to the dye at the rate of 1 ethidium bromide molecule to 2 base pairs. This differential binding of dye gives different buoyant densities to the linear and closed circular DNA molecules in CsCl- ethidium bromide gradients. 2.10 DNA Sequencing DNA sequencing enables the determination of the base sequence in a nucleic acid. The object of DNA sequencing in this project was to develop a sequence database from which a primer could be designed. There are two main methods, the chemical reactions of Maxam and Gilbert (1977) and the enzymatic reactions of Sanger et al. (1977). Both methods produce a series of DNA molecules differing in length by a single nucleotide. These molecules can then be separated by gel electrophoresis (Maxam and Gilbert 1977; Sanger et al., 1977). 19 Sequencing can be done using both single and double stranded DNA as well as cloned DNA. DNA species subjected to PCR can also be used. There are however, considerable advantages in sequencing double stranded cloned DNA than in single stranded and uncloned DNA (Howe and Ward, 1989). In the earlier years of the introduction of sequencing, single stranded and or circular DNA were mostly used (Gronenbom and Messing, 1978; Sanger et al., 1980; Messing et al., 1981). However, sequencing of plasmid DNA has become a powerful technique being used increasingly as the methods were improved. This is because very long inserts have been found to be unstable in Ml 3 phages but stable in plasmid vectors. Short inserts were sequenced completely and easily (Hong, 1981). Double stranded DNA has also been found to be amenable to directed deletion sequencing methods, which allowed easy and accurate screening for size and deletions. 2.10.1 Sanger’s method Sanger’s method, also known as the chain termination method, was evolved from the positive/negative (+/-) sequencing technique by Sanger and Coulson in 1975. This technique first described the use of a specific primer for extension by DNA polymerase base specific chain termination and the use of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) to separate single stranded DNA differing by a single nucleotide. The technique was however inaccurate and clumsy hence, the introduction of the chain terminating dideoxynucleoside triphosphates (ddNTPs) method (Sanger et a l, 1977). The ddNTPs involved in this method lack their 3’-hydroxyl group on the deoxyribose and thus prevent the formation of phosphodiester bond with the subsequent dNTP. 2 0 These ddNTPs, which are randomly selected, when present in the reaction mixture get incorporated into the growing chain and terminate the chain. The reaction products are a mixture of oligonucleotide chains and their lengths are determined by the distance between the terminus of the primer used and the point of premature termination (Sambrook et a l 1989). Oligonucleotide populations are generated from small amounts of four different ddNTPs (ddATP, ddCTP, ddGTP and ddTTP) in four separate enzymatic reactions. The sequence reaction mixture includes the template DNA, labelled primer, the ddNTPs, dNTPs, sequencing buffer, DNA polymerase and sterile distilled water. The primer anneals to its complementary sequence on the denatured template DNA strands. The DNA polymerase then extends the chain from the 3’ end of the primer using dNTPs as precursors (Bankier and Barrell, 1983). Universal primers are normally used, where they anneal to vector sequences that flank the target DNA The primer is first either radio-labelled or fluorescently labelled. The radio-labelling can be done using either [y or a-32P] dATPs as well as [35S] dATPs (Biggin et al., 1983) with the enzyme polynucleotide kinase. The (3-particles emitted by the 32P were found to cause problems including the fact that the bands on the autoradiograph were far larger and more diffused than the bands in the DNA gel. Also, the decay of 32P caused hydrolysis of the DNA. These make reading of the sequences, especially from the top part of the autoradiograph particularly difficult resulting in very few nucleotides being read (Sambrook et al., 1989). The 35S dATP is safer to use hence, preferred. 21 Two types of DNA templates could be used in Sanger’s method, either single or denatured double-stranded DNA. The quality of the template DNA and the type of DNA polymerase used are very critical for sequencing. Plasmid minipreparations are found to be always contaminated, thus, they are not recommended for sequencing. DNA purified by CsCl gradient is recommended for sequencing. Several different enzymes can be used for the chain termination method of sequencing. These include the Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I (Sanger et al., 1977), reverse transcriptase (Mierendorf and Pfeffer, 1987), modified bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerases (Tabor and Richardson, 1987) and Taq DNA polymerase. 2.11 Design of PCR primers A prime consideration when designing a primer is that it should be complex enough to reduce the likelihood of annealing to sequences other than the chosen target (Saiki, 1989). The length of the probe depends on the A+T content. The annealing temperature (Tm) for a PCR depends directly on the length and G+C composition of the primers. The higher these parameters are the higher the Tm and therefore the stringency. The possibility of 3’ overlaps in primer design should be avoided to reduce the incidence of primer dimer formation. Stretches of polypurines and/ or polypyrimidines should also be avoided. 22 CHAPTER THREE 3.0 MATERIALS AND METHODS 3.1 Materials 3.1.1 Chemical and Reagents Disodium hydrogen phosphate (NaJIPCU), sodium dihydrogen orthophosphate (NaHjPO^, bacto-tryptone, yeast extract, agar granules, chloroform, isopropanol and dimethylformamide (DMF) were obtained from Fisher Biotech (Pittsburg, USA). Sodium chloride (NaCl), polyethylene glycol (PEG), sodium citrate, sucrose, Tris base, sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS), ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA), agarose powder, sodium acetate (NaOAc), maleic acid, lauroyl sarcosine, ampicillin, glycerol, sodium hydroxide (NaOH), phenol and 2-butoxyethanol were obtained from Sigma Chemical Company (St. Louis, Missouri, USA). Blocking powder, 5-bromo-4-chloro-P-D-galactopyranoside (X-gal) and isopropyl-p-D- thiogalactopyranoside (£PTG) were obtained from Boehringer Mannheim™ (Mannheim, Germany). Sodium diethyldithiocarbamate (DIECA), magnesium chloride (MgCl2), magnesium sulphate (MgS04), glucose, p-mercaptoethanol, glacial acetic acid and hydrochloric acid were obtained from BDH Limited, UK. Ethanol was obtained from Hayman Limited (UK). 23 Mineral (paraffin) oil was obtained from Fluka Company (Sigma-Aldrich), St. Louis, Missouri, USA. The restriction and modifying enzymes used were obtained from various manufacturers and suppliers including Promega Corporation (Madison, USA), Stratagene™ (Austin, Texas, USA) and Boehringer Mannheim™. 3.2 METHODS 3.2.1 Virus Isolates Thirty-six (36) CSSV isolates from the CRIG virus museum were randomly selected from each of the 5 groups (A, B. C, D and E) in the report by Sagemann et al. (1985) and Hughes and Ollennu (1993) (Table 1). The main group A had 4 subgroups. The selection was such that all the cocoa growing regions in Ghana were represented (Figure 2). The geographical distribution of the isolates thus indicates the various locations of the isolates in the cocoa growing regions in Ghana since the isolates were named according to the locations from which they were first isolated. 24 Table 1: Selection of Isolates (Modified after Sagemann et al. (1985) and Hughes and Ollennu (1993). Isolate name and number Geographic location (Region) Type of leave symptoms ELISA reactions ISEM Decoration at antiserum dilution 1:1600 Group A Group Ai: Mild Strains 1. SS 167 Eastern vm, t + ++ + 2. SS 365B Eastern vm,t ++ ++ + 3. Worawora Volta vm, t I I l-l- + 4. Koben Ashanti m, t + ++ + Group B: Mild Strains 5. Bisa Eastern vm,t + + 6.0nyimso-Agogo Ashanti s,t +++ ++ - 7. Donkokrom Brong vm, t + - Group C: Severe Strains 8. AD 14 Eastern s,t,mo +++ +(-) 9. AD 75 Eastern s, mo +++ + 10. Mampong Eastern s, mo I 1 1 I +(-) Group D: Severe Strains 11. AD 191 Eastern s, mo + + - 12. AD 7 Eastern s, mo + + - 13. AD 135 Eastern s, mo ++ + 14. Kpeve Volta s, mo + + - Group £: Mild Strains 15. Peki Volta vm, t + - nt 16. Bobiriso Ashanti - - - nt Group A2; Severe Strains 17. Bechem Brong s,t 18. Anibil Western s , t 19. Nkawkaw Eastern s,t 20. Nkrankwanta Brong s,t 21. Tediimantia Brong s,t 22. Amafie Western s,t Group A3; Severe Strains 23 .New Juabeng-IA Eastern s,t 24. Kofi Pare - 1A Eastern s,t nt 25. Tafo Yellows Eastern s,t nt 26. Agyapoinaa Eastern s, t nt 27.Bosomtwe Ashanti s,t nt 28. Bosoratwe Ashanti Group Aji Severe Strains 29. Onyimso-Agogo 30. Sankore Ashanti Brong s,t s,t s,t nt nt nt 31. Miaso Ashanti s,t nt 32 Nsaba Central s.t nt ^ Okerikrom Brong s.t nt 34 Diinn Volta s.t nt VI Kwakoko-Juansa. Ashanti s. t nt •36 Enchi Western s. t nt 25 Key: s = severe; m = mild; vm = very mild; mo = mottled leaf symptom; — = without symptom; t = symptoms resemble those induced by strain 1 A; nt = not tested. Reactivity in ELISA indicate values obtained after 18 hours substrate incubation: ++++ = A 405nm>1.0; +++ = 0.300 to 1.0; ++ = 0.150 to 0.300; + = <0.150; - = values not distinguishable from the controls. Reference: Sagemann et al., 1985 and Hughes and Ollennu, 1993. 2 6 * TAMALE rV \ \\ \ BAR ) ( 'X/' \ \ *34 {I VR I if / • 2 0 /"'•33 * SUNYANI^ v ^ •21 ? . n / / AR •6/25^ / *3c r \ •22 •36 1 WR \ A ☆ KUMASI •27/28 •35-̂ •ii, *31,7 *19 / • 18 •3 i i ; ER P