University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh UNIVERSITY OF GHANA COLLEGE OF HUMANITIES THE IMPACT OF THE BREMEN MISSION IN THE VOLTA REGION OF GHANA BY LETICIA ODURO ASANTE (10350741) THIS THESIS IS SUBMITTED TO THE UNIVERSITY OF GHANA, LEGON IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF MPHIL FOR THE STUDY OF RELIGIONS DEGREE DEPARTMENT FOR THE STUDY OF RELIGIONS JULY, 2018 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh i DECLARATION This is to certify that this thesis is the result of the research undertaken by Leticia Oduro Asante under the supervision of Rev. Dr. Abraham Nana Opare Kwakye and Dr. Rose Mary Amenga- Etego towards the award of MPhil Religions in the Department for the Study of Religions, University of Ghana. ……………………………….. ………………………… LETICIA ODURO ASANTE DATE (STUDENT) …………………………………… …………………………… DR. ABRAHAM N.O. KWAKYE DATE (SUPERVISOR) ……………………………………. ………………………… DR. ROSE MARY AMENGA-ETEGO DATE (SUPERVISOR) University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh ii DEDICATION I dedicate this work to the Triune God for His protection and guidance during the study period and to my parents, Mr. John Oduro-Asante and Mrs. Margaret Oduro-Asante. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I begin this order of acknowledgments with a profound appreciation to the Almighty God for blessing me with good health, wisdom, knowledge, understanding and an enabling academic environment to embark on this study. My sincere appreciation to the Volkswagen Foundation under the Post-doctoral grant directed by Dr. Wazi Apoh, Head of Department of Archaeology and Heritage Studies, University of Ghana, Legon for sponsoring this MPhil programme. I owe a debt of gratitude to my supervisor, Rev. Dr. Abraham Nana Opare Kwakye for his supervisory role and guidance and his timely warnings and suggestions which has made this work reach this far. My deepest and unreserved gratitude goes to the co-supervisor and my academic mentor, Dr. Rose Mary Amenga-Etego. I am forever indebted to you for the opportunity given me to undertake this project. I am profoundly grateful to Prof. Elizabeth Amoah, Rev. Dr. Ossom-Batsa and Dr. Nicoletta Gatti for their constant encouragement and for showing interest in my academic progress. I thank the Head of Department, Hajj Sulemana Mumuni and all the faculty members of the Department for the Study of Religions. I am equally grateful to the pastors, leaders, and catechists of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Ghana in all the communities for making time for me to interview them despite their busy schedules. Special thanks to all the traditional leaders especially, Togbe Appiah and Togbe Adra for permitting me to ask questions during the interview. My heartfelt gratitude goes to Togbe Akyem Foli V, Chief of Amedzofe, Rev. S.K.H. Dzandzo, Ag. Principal of E.P College of Education, Amedzofe, Mr. G.K. Attipui and Mr. Joephery Wuaku for providing me with very useful literature for the work. I am thankful to Rev. Fr. Godwin Kornu, Parish Priest of Our Lady of Assumption Catholic Church (OLA), New Achimota for his spiritual guidance and encouragement. To Mr. Michael Asamoah-Duku, your prayers, advice, encouragement and above all your financial support cannot be quantified. You painstakingly read through the whole work and offered very insightful suggestions. Daddy, may God bless you. I cannot forget my parents Mr. and Mrs. Oduro-Asante for their prayers, advice and constant encouragement in good and bad times during this study. To my siblings Andrew, Emelia, Gertrude and Enoch, I appreciate your love and support. Special gratitude goes to Mr. Ernest Fiador for assisting me throughout the field work in all the six communities. Your dedication and commitment are very much appreciated. I thank all my colleagues for their encouragement. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh iv ABSTRACT The arrival of the North German Missionary Society, also known as the Bremen Mission, in the Volta Region of Ghana was greatly significant. Their contact with the people of the Volta Region marked the birth of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Ghana, and other developments in Eweland. The study offers a missiological perspective of the influence of diverse activities of the Bremen Mission in early German missionised and colonial communities of Peki, Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho and Amedzofe in the Volta Region. The study adopted missiological and historical methods for data collection and assessment. These methods were used to recount the history of the Bremen Mission and their encounter with the communities under study. Additionally, the methods helped in examining how the missionaries communicated the Gospel message to the indigenous people in their historical and socio-cultural milieu. Interviews were conducted to gather relevant information to augment the documentary sources. For the purpose of the study, contemporary photography was used to help in the assessment of the impact of the Bremen Mission in Eweland. The study uncovered that, as part of the Bremen Mission strategy for the growth of the mission, the missionaries selected some indigenous people who were empowered through education and professional training. It also discovered that the zealous efforts of the Bremen missionaries with support from the indigenous agents, brought change to the Volta Region through Christianity, western formal education, cultural transformation, and empowerment of women, among others. It also indicated that the development and standardisation of the Ewe language contributed significantly to contemporary Ewe identity in Ghana. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh v TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION .................................................................................................................... i DEDICATION ....................................................................................................................... ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................................................... iii ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... viii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................... ix CHAPTER ONE .................................................................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 1 1.0 Background of the Study ............................................................................................. 1 1.1 Statement of the Problem ............................................................................................. 4 1.2 Aim and Objectives of the Study ................................................................................. 5 1.3 Research Questions ...................................................................................................... 6 1.4 Methodology and Methods of Data Collection ............................................................ 6 1.5 Literature Review......................................................................................................... 8 1.6 Theoretical Framework .............................................................................................. 17 1.7 Scope of the Study ..................................................................................................... 21 1.8 Structure of the Study ................................................................................................ 21 1.9 Significance of the Study ........................................................................................... 21 CHAPTER TWO ................................................................................................................. 22 THE BREMEN MISSION IN THE VOLTA REGION (1847-1917) ................................. 22 2.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 22 2.1 The Establishment of the Bremen Mission ................................................................ 23 2.2 Bremen Mission in Ghana- A Brief History .............................................................. 25 2.3 The Early Mission Stations ........................................................................................ 27 2.3.1 The Bremen Missionaries in Peki ........................................................................... 27 2.3.2 The Bremen Missionaries in Keta ........................................................................... 30 2.3.3 The Bremen Missionaries in Waya ......................................................................... 32 2.3.4 The Bremen Missionaries in Anyako ..................................................................... 34 2.3.5 The Bremen Missionaries in Ho ............................................................................. 35 2.3.6 The Bremen Missionaries in Amedzofe ................................................................. 37 2.4 Missionary Policies and Guidelines ........................................................................... 39 2.4.1 The Congregation Serving as a Witness ................................................................. 39 2.4.2 Study of Language and Culture .............................................................................. 41 2.4.3 Concern for the Whole of Life ................................................................................ 42 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh vi 2.4.4 Civil Authority and Colonial Power ....................................................................... 44 2.4.5 Preparing Congregations for Self-Government ...................................................... 46 2.5 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 48 CHAPTER THREE ............................................................................................................. 49 CHALLENGES IN THE MISSION FIELD........................................................................ 49 3.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 49 3.2 Unfavourable Weather Condition .............................................................................. 49 3.3 Language Barrier ....................................................................................................... 50 3.4 Opposition from Indigenous Priests........................................................................... 52 3.5 Resistance of the Indigenes ........................................................................................ 54 3.6 Financial Difficulties ................................................................................................. 58 3.7 Missionaries and Colonial Governments ................................................................... 59 3.8 The Ashanti War ........................................................................................................ 64 3.9 World War I ............................................................................................................... 67 3.10 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 72 CHAPTER FOUR ................................................................................................................ 75 THE IMPACT OF THE BREMEN MISSION IN EWELAND .......................................... 75 4.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 75 4.1 Education ................................................................................................................... 76 4.1.1 Western Formal Education ..................................................................................... 76 4.1.2 Seminary Education ................................................................................................ 77 4.1.3 Vocational/Technical Education ............................................................................. 81 4.2 Religion ...................................................................................................................... 88 4.3 Culture........................................................................................................................ 97 4.3.1 Inculturation ............................................................................................................ 97 4.3.2 Rites of Birth ......................................................................................................... 102 4.3.3 Puberty Rites ......................................................................................................... 103 4.3.4 Widowhood Rite ................................................................................................... 106 4.4 Language .................................................................................................................. 109 4.5 Agriculture ............................................................................................................... 112 4.6 Healthcare Delivery ................................................................................................. 114 4.7 Architecture.............................................................................................................. 116 4.8 Negative Influence ................................................................................................... 118 4.9 Gender Dimension of the Bremen Mission in Eweland .......................................... 121 4.9.1 The Gender Dimension of the Bremen Missionaries ............................................ 122 4.9.2 The Gender Dimension of the Indigenous Agents in Eweland............................. 125 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh vii 4.9.3 The Contribution of the Indigenous Agents to the Evangelisation of Eweland ... 127 4.10 Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 134 CHAPTER FIVE ............................................................................................................... 136 SUMMARY, FINDINGS, RECOMMENDATIONS, AND CONCLUSION ................ 136 5.0 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 136 5.1 Summary .................................................................................................................. 136 5.3 Findings.................................................................................................................... 139 5.4 Recommendations .................................................................................................... 141 5.5 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 143 BIBIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................................ 144 APPENDICES ................................................................................................................... 152 Appendix A. Interview Schedule for Church Leaders ...................................................... 152 Appendix B. Interview Schedule for the Traditional Leaders ........................................... 153 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. 1: Map showing the study areas ................................................................................. 2 Figure 2. 1: The first mission house at Keta ............................................................................ 31 Figure 3. 1: The tombs of the fourteen missionaries who were buried at Anyako .................. 50 Figure 4. 1: Mawuli Secondary School.................................................................................... 85 Figure 4. 1: Bible Cass Women singing and the traditional drums being played .................. 101 Figure 4. 2: Administration block of E.P. College of Education, Amedzofe ........................ 117 Figure 4. 3: The old chapel at Ho and the new chapel at Peki ............................................... 118 Figure 4. 4: The missionaries and their wives at Keta ........................................................... 122 Figure 4. 5: The deaconesses at Keta teaching the children .................................................. 124 Figure 4. 6: The indigenous leaders with Mr. and Mrs Beveridge in 1923 ........................... 128 Figure 4. 7: The sewing machine and the cooking pot used to teach the women .................. 132 Figure 4. 8: Some ordained women Ministers of the E.P. Church ........................................ 133 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh ix LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ARS Apostle Revelation Society CEM Christ Evangelical Mission DC District Commissioner EPC EPC Evangelical Presbyterian Church GEC Global Evangelical Church LPC Lord’s Pentecostal Church NGMS North German Mission Society PECBK Presbyterian Evangelical Church of Buem Krachi UFC United Free Church WASSCE West African School Certificate Examination WBCM Women’s Bible Class Movement WCS White Cross Society, WW I World War I YMCA Young Women’s Christian Association University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 1 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.0 Background of the Study The introduction of Christianity into the African continent dates back to the first Century AD, shortly after Pentecost.1 Yet, Christianity entered the Gold Coast, now Ghana, on 20th January 1482, through Roman Catholic Portuguese explorers and traders at Elmina.2 This first attempt did not yield any significant results since economic consideration was their primary focus and not evangelism.3 Nevertheless, their return in 1880 yielded tremendous success. Christianity gained root in Ghana in the nineteenth century with the arrival of mission societies such as the Basel Missionary Society (1828), the Wesleyan Methodist Missionary Society (1835), and the North Bremen Missionary Society (1847).4 Ansre asserts: These societies were inspired by the Pietist Movement and the Christian Awakening which occurred in the 17th and 18th centuries and spread wide in Europe and USA. These movements were themselves the result of the Reformation which had taken place in the early 16th century but which had many long-lasting effects.5 The people of Eweland had contact with Christianity in the mid-nineteenth century with the arrival of the North German missionaries also known as Bremen missionaries. This society was rooted in the liberal foreign trade of Bremen. Its overarching goal was to evangelize to the people and win them for Christ.6 According to Kodzo Gavua, the Bremen Mission, among others, were inspired by the biblical verse Mathew 28: 18-20 to spread the gospel to the 1 Jonathan Hildebrandt, History of the Church in Africa (Ghana: African Christian Press, 1996), p. 5. 2 Hans W. Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana (Accra: Waterville Publishing House, 1967), p. 17, Cephas N. Omenyo, Pentecost Outside Pentecostalism: A Study of Development of Charismatic Renewal in the Mainline Churches in Ghana (Netherland: Boekencentrum Zoetermeter, 2002), p. 45. 3 S. K. Odamtten, The Missionary Factor in Ghana’s Development 1820-1880 (Accra: Waterville Publishing House, 1978), p. 23. 4Omenyo, Pentecost Outside Pentecostalism, p. 48-59. 5 Gilbert Ansre, (ed.), Evangelical Presbyterian Church: 150 Years of Evangelization and Development, 1847- 1997 (Ho: E.P Church Press, 1997), p. 18. 6Werner Ustorf, Bremen Missionaries in Togo and Ghana: 1847-1900 (Legon: Legon Theological Studies Series, 2002), p. 2. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 2 heathen, win souls for the Kingdom of God and convert the infidels to Christianity. 7 The arrival of the Bremen missionaries in 1847 marked the birth of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church and other missionary activities in Ewe land. Initially, they settled at Peki but later expanded to Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho, and Amedzofe, all located in the Volta Region of Ghana (see fig. 1.1). Figure 1. 1: A Map Showing the Study Areas Source: Author, 2018 7 Kodzo Gavua, “The Religious Factors in the Administration of German Togoland” in Wazi Apoh and Bea Lundt (eds.) Germany and Its West African Colonies: “Excavation” of German Colonialism in Post-Colonial Times (Berlin: Lit Vergleg, 2013), p. 120. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 3 The main tool that aided the missionaries in their evangelization was the establishment of schools. This initiative was not without problems, but, they fervently carried on irrespective of the difficulties encountered.8 They were zealous about spreading the Gospel to the indigenes. The presence of the missionaries had a tremendous influence on the religio-cultural practices of the people. The missionaries regarded some indigenous beliefs and practices that were associated with the dead and exorcism of witchcraft as demonic and idolatry9, and as such they dissuaded the people from these indigenous religious beliefs and practices and persuaded them to turn to the Christian God. Some accepted the Christian faith and were able to detach themselves from everything associated with the traditional religion. Gavua notes that “pastors, catechists and other functionaries of the Missions preached against the indigenous religion by associating it with evil and engaged in the seizure of converts’ portable personal deities and shrines.”10 Whilst some ardent believers of traditional religion remained adamant, quite a number of the indigenes accepted the Christian faith by the efforts of the Bremen missionaries. The Christian converts were prevented from participating in any form of indigenous music, dance, and rituals.11 Particularly, traditional drumming and women’s dancing were considered inappropriate. This was because, in the Ewe religious tradition, women had a way of shaking and wriggling their bodies while dancing which the missionaries regarded as immodest. Therefore, the participation of converts in such traditional, religious and cultural practices was sternly forbidden.12 8 Kofi Dorvlo, “The Contributions of German Missionary Evangelism and Education in German Togoland” in Wazi Apoh, Bea Lundt (eds.) Germany and Its West African Colonies: “Excavation” of German Colonialism in Post-Colonial Times (Berlin: Lit Vergleg, 2013), p. 123. (Accra: Asempa Publishers, 2008), p. 53. 10 Gavua, The Religious Factors, p. 140. 11 Gavua, The Religious Factors, p. 140. 12 Gavua, The Religious Factors, p. 140. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 4 In view of the fact that the missionaries came from a pietistic tradition, they ensured that new converts were trained in a pietistic order. The transmission of the Christian faith to the indigenous people constitutes the most important legacy the Bremen missionaries gave to the people of the Volta region. The contact with the indigenous populations among whom the Bremen missionaries lived, worked and proselytized must be of interest to us if we are to understand the changes that occurred due to their missionary activities. The study seeks to provide an understanding of the nature of the influences that ensued as a result of their interactions across time. 1.1 Statement of the Problem Quite a number of scholarly works exist on the activities of the Bremen Mission in the Volta Region. However, one can say that the activities in the early German missionised and colonial communities, and their influence on the local populace from religious perspectives have not been adequately studied. Although scholars such as Spieth,13 Debrunner,14 Meyer,15 Ustorf,16 Dorvlo17, and Gavua18 have offered historical insight into the Bremen Mission activities, their works are largely focused on education, healthcare, architecture, craftwork, and agriculture. Similarly, Apoh19, 13 Jakob Spieth, The Ewe People: A Study of the Ewe People in German Togoland (Ghana: Sub-Saharan Publishers, 1906). 14 Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana. 15 Birgit Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation of Pietist Protestantism: The Case of the Peki Ewe in Southeastern Ghana 1847-1992(Amsterdam: Doctoral Dissertation, 1995). 16 Ustorf, Bremen Missionaries in Togo and Ghana. 17 Dovlo, “The Contribution of German Missionary.” 18 Gavua, “The Religious Factors.” 19Wazi Apoh, The Akpinis and the Echoes of German and British Colonial Overrule: An Archaeological Investigation of Kpando, Ghana (An Unpublished PhD Dissertation, Binghamton University, 2008). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 5 Ladzekpo,20 Dogbey21, and Mensah22 have examined the tangible and intangible archaeological remains of the German colonial activities, which included some of the Bremen missionary works in the colonial communities. It is against this background that this study examines the religious perspective of the influence of diverse activities of the Bremen Mission in the early German missionised and colonial communities of Peki, Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho and Amedzofe in the Volta Region. These six early communities of the Bremen Mission, Peki to Amedzofe, are fundamental for the understanding of the pioneering phase of the Mission’s activities. Amedzofe became a pivotal point for the Bremen missionaries because of its altitude which provided low temperature and a mosquito-free environment which was conducive for their health.23 The warm reception of the people together with the favourable climatic condition made it possible for them to be firmly established such that it is still an important religious space of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, an offshoot of the Bremen Mission. 1.2 Aim and Objectives of the Study The aim of this study is to examine the impact of the activities of the Bremen missionaries at Peki, Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho, and Amedzofe in the Volta Region. The underlying objectives are: 1. To identify the tools employed by the Bremen missionaries in their activities. 2. To find out the roles of the local agents in the Bremen missionary agenda. 3. To examine the legacy of the Bremen Mission in the selected communities. 20 Joseph Y.E.H. Ladzekpo, The Bremen Mission Heritage in Amedzofe (An Unpublished MA Thesis, University of Ghana, Legon. 2013). 21Vincent S. Dogbey, Historical Archaeology of German Colonial Heritage at Ziavi, in the Ho Municipality, Volta Region Ghana (An Unpublished MPhil Thesis, University of Ghana, Legon, 2015). 22 Moses K. Mensah, Bremen Missionary Interactions with the Peki: An Archaeological Perspective (An Unpublished MPhil Thesis, University of Ghana, Legon, 2017). 23 Ladzekpo, The Bremen Mission Heritage in Amedzofe, University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 6 1.3 Research Questions The research seeks answers to the following questions: 1. What were the various tools used by the Bremen missionaries in their activities? 2. What were the roles of the local agents in the Bremen Mission agenda? 3. Are there any legacies of the Bremen Mission? 1.4 Methodology and Methods of Data Collection This is a qualitative study that makes use of both the missiological and historical approaches to research. Missiological Research Methodology is the systematic, dynamic and integrative manner of conducting research in the missiological study.24 E.D Steter argues that fundamentally missiological research is guided by specific questions aimed at seeking to understand the culture and society in which the church is situated.25 Grunland and Meyers share a similar view that the value of integrating the methodology of Social Sciences with the missiological study is that of understanding the culture of a group of people in order to better proclaim Christ to and amongst them so that they become Disciples of Christ.26 This methodology is carried out by formally specified procedures designed to gather, measure and interpret data. The purpose is to equip the church to minister in ways that are not only spiritually meaningful but also in ways that are situational and structurally beneficial for society at large.27 According to E.H. Carr, history is “a continuous process of interacting between the historian and his facts, an unending dialogue between the present and the past.”28 He points out that the study of history is a study of causes and that the historian continuously asked the question 24 Enoch Wan, Rethinking Missiological Research Methodology: Exploring a New Direction (Published in Global Missiology, Research Methodology Oct. 2003 www.globalmissiology.net), Assessed, 2nd October, 2017. 25 E.D. Stetzer, What is Missiologist?: The Theology, Tools and Team of a Missiologist (http://www.christianitytoday.com/edstetzer/2013/june/what-is-missiologist.html June 10, 2013), Accessed, 2nd October, 2017. 26 Grunlan and Mayers (1988: 21-22), cited in Wan, Rethinking Missiological Research Methodology, p. 4. 27 Stetzer, What is Missiologist? 28 E. H. Carr, What is History?, 2nd ed. (Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1987), p. 30. http://www.globalmissiology.net/ http://www.christianitytoday.com/edstetzer/2013/june/what-is-missiologist.html University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 7 ‘Why’? People who read or write about past events must desire to know why they happened. The historical method examines past events or combination of events to arrive at an account of what happened in the past.29 The missiological and historical approaches employed enabled a detailed description of the background to the emergence of the Bremen Mission and the histories of the communities under study. Additionally, it helped in examining how the missionaries communicated the Gospel message to the local people in their historical and socio-cultural milieu. The two approaches made use of both primary and secondary sources of data. The sources for the primary data included interviews. In each of the communities, both traditional and church leaders were interviewed in order to solicit information concerning the influence of the Bremen missionary activities in the communities. Both structured and unstructured forms of interviews were adopted by the researcher.30 Under the structured type of interview, a list of questions was formulated in order to help provide answers to the subject under investigation.31 However, the unstructured form of interview was used where the researcher deemed it appropriate. This helped the researcher to ask “probing questions which call for explanation and further clarifications on unclear issues” from the archival documents.32 It also enabled the researcher to ask follow-up questions from the respondent’s answers. Additionally, places of historical significance were visited to gather relevant information for the purpose of the study and contemporary photography was also used. 29 Historical Research: Answers to review Questions, www.scribd.com/document/11330516/Ch15-Answers (Assessed 7th September, 2017). 30 Tom K.B. Kumekpor, Research Methods and Techniques of Social Research (Accra: SonLife Services, 2002), p. 188, Emmanuel Asante, Research and Writing: A Brief Guide (Accra: African Christian Press, 2000), p. 46. 31 Kumekpor, Research Methods and Techniques, p. 188. 32 Asante, Research and Writing, p. 47. http://www.scribd.com/document/11330516/Ch15-Answers University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 8 The secondary sources of data comprised the review of some published and unpublished materials such as journal articles, archival records, books, newspapers, Ph.D./MA/MPhil theses, internet sources and other materials that are related to the work. 1.5 Literature Review In this section, the study engages in a discussion with scholars in the field of mission and historical studies. Two categories of literature were reviewed. The first category is scholarly works that focus on mission. The second category of literature looks at the historical background of the Bremen Mission activities in the Volta Basin. Scholarly works reviewed under Mission include; Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission by David J. Bosch, Contemporary Missiology: An Introduction by J. Verkuyl translated and edited by Dale Cooper and Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission edited by Andrew Walls and Cathy Ross. This review broadens our knowledge of the meaning of mission and why people embark on mission. It brings out an understanding of the various motives that inspire people to participate in mission. Equally, it reveals that mission is not only about proclaiming the gospel but also responding to the needs of society or humankind. Bosch in his book Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission33 discusses mission in two parts – biblical foundations of mission and historical paradigms of mission. The biblical foundations of mission, on one hand, address the New Testament models of mission whereas the historical paradigms of mission, on the other hand, look at the paradigm changes 33David J. Bosch, Transforming Mission: Paradigm Shifts in Theology of Mission (Maryknoll: Orbis Books, 1996). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 9 in missiology with emphasis on the six epochs suggested by Hans Kung.34 Among the themes he dealt with are missio Dei and mission as evangelism. In the introduction, Bosch gave the traditional understanding of mission and how the word “mission” had been used differently in various ways. The term “mission” presupposes a sender, a person or persons sent by the sender, those to whom one is sent and with an assignment. Thus the one who sends has an authority to do so.35 The traditional understanding of mission has been revised in the course of the twentieth century. Bosch asserts that mission had been understood in a variety of ways during this period. For example, it is interpreted in soteriological terms as the saving of individuals from eternal damnation. Culturally, as introducing people from the East and the South to the blessings and privileges of the Christian West. Equally, in ecclesiastical terms, mission was understood as the expansion of the church or a specific denomination.36 Karl Barth at Brandenburg Missionary Conference in 1932 mentioned that mission was an activity of God himself.37 It was at the Willingen Conference of the IMC in 1952 that the idea of missio Dei was fleshed out. Mission was understood to be derived from the very nature of God.38 This idea was put in the context of the doctrine of the Trinity and not Ecclesiology or soteriology. From here, mission was then understood as the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit sending the church into the world. The church thus becomes an instrument to carry out God’s mission to the entire world. Since God is the fountain of love, participating in missionary activities means that one is taking part in the movement of God’s love towards humanity.39 The missionary activities of the church cannot be claimed as identical to the missio Dei. Instead, 34 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 181. 35 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 1. 36 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 389. 37 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 389. 38 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 390. 39 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 390. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 10 they can only be authentic in so far as they reflect participation in the mission of God. They must be deeply rooted in what God himself initiated. Bosch defined Evangelism as “the proclamation of salvation in Christ to those who do not believe in him, calling them to repentance and conversion, announcing forgiveness of sin and inviting them to become living members of Christ’s earthly community and to begin the life of service to others in the power of the Holy Spirit”.40 It is also the act of spreading the gospel. To attain a holistic mission, evangelism and the provision of social services must go hand in hand. The church’s mission to the world is not only to proclaim the gospel but also to serve, love, preach, liberate, heal and protect humanity. Consistent with the foregoing discussion of Bosch’s work, the Bremen missionaries came to proclaim the Gospel and established the Christian faith among the Ewe people. They also embarked on some social services that helped to address the needs of the people. In spite of all the deaths that were recorded, coupled with the various challenges they encountered, the mission was sustained and was fruitful. Accordingly, the missionaries were only participating in the divine task of God but did not own the mission. Verkuyl41 identifies pure and impure motives as the two main motives for engaging in mission. He mentions that pure motives should be the deepest motivations for communicating the Christian faith throughout the world. The first motive is that of obedience. It is a motive which comes from a duty towards the will of God (1 Cor.1:17, 9:16; Gal. 2:7). In accordance with this motive, Zahn, the Bremen Mission Inspector, refused to extend the missionary work on Eweland to the Togoland when told to do so by the German colonial government. One of the 40 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p Bosch 11. 41 J. Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology: An Introduction, Translated and edited by Dale Cooper (Grand Rapids, Michigan: William B. Eerdman’s Publishing Company, 1978). University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 11 reasons for his refusal was that it was not the will of God to send teachers to Togoland.42 The second is the motive of love, mercy, and pity. It is a motive that has strongly received biblical accents. The motive of doxology is an expression of praise to God’s name. The missionary responds in this regard in praise of God’s name. For example, when Lorenz Wolf arrived at Peki, on the first day, he disregarded his tiredness and preached to the people on Psalm 22:23. Based on this scripture he showed the people the plan of God’s salvation.43 The fourth is the Eschatological motive which is the motive of God’s kingdom. It was an important motive for the pioneer missionaries.44 This motive inspires Christians to yearn for the kingdom so as to bring those outside the faith to experience the kingdom of God. The motive of haste, which is the fifth motivation, is closely related to the eschatological motive. Here the pioneer missionaries had a strong drive to get the message out quickly in their missionary journey. So burning was their zeal that despite the many deaths of their colleagues, the surviving Bremen missionaries remained unfazed in their determination to preach the gospel in Eweland. The final motive is Personal motive. Paul makes a statement in 1Corinthians 9:23 that “I do all for the sake of the Gospel, that I may share in the blessings”. This motive is very significant in the missionary task. In his conclusion, Verkuyl recommends that pure motive should be the basis for an authentic mission for the proclamation of the word of God to the whole world. The impure motives identified by Verkuyl include Imperialist Motives, Cultural Motives, Commercial Motives and the Motive of Ecclesiastical Colonialism.45 In this context, he described imperialism to mean the attempt by one state to use another state or people as a means to achieve its own goal. According to Bosch, colonialism and mission were interdependent; 42 Eugene Grau, ‘Missionary Policies as Seen in the Work of Missions With the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Ghana’, in C.G. Baeta (ed), Christianity in Tropical Africa (London: Oxford University Press 1968), p. 69. 43 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 149. 44 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiolosy, p. 167. 45 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiolosy, p. 168. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 12 thus the right to have colonies come with the duty to Christianise the colonised.46 Cultural motive refers to the intention or the attempt to introduce one’s culture to another. The mission work was closely connected with the transfer of missionary’s culture. During this period, mission was regarded as transmitting the values of Western culture. Commercial motives, in the words of Verkuyl, became an accessory motive and a point in the “propaganda” for mission.47 Further, promotional literature written by missionaries made an appeal to the commercial interest of its readers.48 This illustrates a statement made earlier by S.K. Odamtten that economic consideration was the primary focus of the early missionaries who came to the Gold Coast.49 Verkuyl pointed out that, it is very important for one to inspect the ties between mission and commerce; certainly, the historical record shows that these missions were closely linked with commerce or motivated by commercial intentions.50 Ecclesiastical colonialism motive, on the other hand, deals with the imposition of the model of the Mother Church on the Native Churches.51 Stated differently, it is the urge to export one’s own confession and church order to other territories.52 The above discussions clearly indicate that there have always been pure and impure motives that influence missionary tasks in the field of mission. In contrast to Verkuyl’s assertion, the records available do not indicate that the Bremen Missionaries ever showed any tendencies that commercial motives were part of their motivation to bring the gospel to the Ewe land. This was made clear in Wolf’s declaration upon arrival at Peki that: “I am not going to buy slaves nor do I have in mind to rob people of their 46 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 227. 47 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology, p. 172. 48 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology, p. 173. 49 Odamtten, The Missionary Factor, p. 23. 50 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology, p. 173. 51 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology, p. 173. 52 Bosch, Transforming Mission, p. 5. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 13 land”.53 However, the only occasions when they sold some of their estates to the local people were when they were in financial crisis and they did so in order to pay their workers.54 In another instance, financial challenges led the Bremen missionaries to grudgingly accept to sell goods for Siedel in the Blengo area as a condition for receiving credit.55 In all the cases, survival was the reason rather than commercial intentions. Also, the motive of ecclesiastical colonialism was minimal as the Bremen missionaries sought to establish an indigenous church with its own liturgy and polity, and which was to be self- supporting and self- governing. This was achieved in the Ewe Presbyterian Church which later became the Evangelical Presbyterian church. These motives serve as the benchmark to identify the authentic motive of the Bremen Mission in their missionary journey. In the edited volume Mission in the Twenty-first Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission,56 Walls and Ross identified the characteristics of mission in the Church as the proclamation of the Good News with its associated teaching, baptising and nurturing of new believers, loving service in response to human need, transforming unjust structures of society and safeguarding the integrity of creation.57 In her introduction, Ross acknowledged that the five marks presented do not embrace everything that should be said about mission. However, they outline the parameters of a holistic concept of mission and offer a starting point for on- going reflection.58 The marks of mission as propounded by different authors and edited by Walls and Ross in this book are useful for this study by serving as a theoretical frame of reference. It is used as a basis for evaluating the impact of the Bremen Mission on the communities of their operations. 53 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 84. 54 Ustorf, Bremen Mission in Togo and Ghana, p. 118. 55 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 60. 56 Andrew Walls and Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008). 57 Walls and Ross (eds.) Mission in the Twenty-first Century, p. xiv. 58 Walls and Ross (eds.) Mission in the Twenty-first Century, p. xiv. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 14 Various reviews of the historical background of the Bremen Mission activities in the Volta Region include; John K. Agbeti, West African Church History-Christian Mission and Church Foundation: 1482-1919; Gilbert Ansre (ed.), The Evangelical Presbyterian Church 150 Years of Evangelization and Development 1847 – 1997; Birgit Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation of Pietist Protestantism: The Case of the Peki Ewe in South-eastern Ghana 1847-1992, and Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity among the Ewe in Ghana. Agbeti recounts the history of the North German Missionary Society (NGMS). their aim of coming to West Africa in general, and Gold Coast in particular, focusing mainly on the missionary activities at Peki and Keta in the Volta Region. He asserts that the missionaries encountered difficulties in their missionary work in these areas. These challenges included a language barrier which was further complicated by the content of the gospel message that was completely new to the people, ill-health that resulted in the death of many of the missionaries, opposition and rivalry from traditional religious priests and leaders, and financial constraints. He enumerates the achievements of the missionaries from 1853-1919. In 1855 the first seven converts were baptised. Secondly, some indigenous people were trained to become effective agents and collaborators in the missionary effort. Agbeti emphasises that without the assistance of the African agents the missionary work could not have progressed in this period. He mentions that John Wright, one of the African agents from Teshie, was a remarkable personality during the period.59 He was made a catechist and was placed in charge of a congregation in 1863. The third achievement was that between 1882 and 1912 the first eight African pastors for the Bremen Mission were ordained. Agbeti’s work is relevant to this study because it gives information about the history and achievements of the Bremen Mission and 59 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 160. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 15 also the problems the missionaries encountered in the Eweland. It also outlines the contributions of the African agents after World War 1. However, his work only covered up to 1919. This work goes beyond this period up to the present time. Ansre discusses extensively the history of the Bremen Mission activities in the Volta Region. Like Agbeti, Ansre offers information about various challenges the missionaries faced. In spite of these challenges, the church was able to thrive. Also, he describes the contributions which the Church made towards the development of the society as well as the welfare of the indigenous people. Ansre focuses his attention on the history of the beginnings, growth, and development of the missionary Church that came to be known as the Evangelical Presbyterian Church and is therefore essential to this study. Furthermore it provides accounts of the religious activities as well as other social services undertaken by the church, dealing with the church’s practical exhibition of love for God and mankind. The exhibition of such love was made visible by activities, projects and programmes carried out by the Church. Closely linked to this was the Church’s role and quest to provide both secular and theological education to the people.60 Education thus served as an indispensable tool in the growth and development of the Church as well as the country. In this way, the contributions of the Church are mentioned as a religious duty that goes, in the long run, to bring about social development. The Church’s role in bringing education to the people manifested in the establishment of schools including teacher training institutions as well as seminaries to train pastors to lead the local church. The church also tried over the years, to provide social services in its area of influence.61 Ansres’s work is essential to this study because it gives an in-depth discussion of the beginnings, growth, and development of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church (EPC). It provides accounts of the 60 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. xi. 61 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 205. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 16 religious activities as well as other social services undertaken by the church. Ansre’s work will help the researcher to present the history of the Bremen Mission activities in the Volta Region as well as the contributions of the Church to society and the welfare of the indigenous people. The present study provides updates to Ansre’s two decade old work. Meyer in her book Translating the Devil an African Appropriation of Pietist Protestantism: The Case of the Peki Ewe in South-eastern Ghana 1847-1992 gives a historical account of the Bremen Mission and that of the people of Peki. She establishes how African Christians have practically dealt with Western impositions in their own fashion. She concentrates on the local appropriation of the Christian faith in an African context. She states that African Christianity is not merely an extension of the missionary impact, but rather a product of the encounter between missionaries and Africans.62 She mentions that the Bremen missionaries came from a Pietistic tradition and thus nurtured the new converts along the pietistic way. Wolf defined the stance of Pietism to the people of Peki when they presupposed their contact with him was of economic significance: “Though Pietists considered trade a civilising strategy and thus favoured the presence of European goods in Africa, they associated the pleasures of their consumption with the ‘broad path’”.63 This indicates that the Bremen missionaries may have preached against one’s attachment to material things to the detriment of giving heed to the Gospel message. Meyer’s Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity among the Ewe in Ghana presents to us the strategies that were used in the Bremen missionaries’ attempt to make proselytes out of the traditional worshippers. They approached this through evangelisation, education, agriculture and the establishment of segregated Christian villages called Kpodzi (‘on the 62 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p.1. 63 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 59. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 17 hill’).64 These initiatives had an impact on the socio-economic life of the people. In addition, Meyer mentioned Wolf’s evangelism strategies as follows: learning the native language, starting a school, preaching the Gospel, treating the sick and dealing with representatives of political and religious leaders. Meyer’s works are important to the study because they give a detailed historical account of Peki before the arrival of the missionaries and deal with the developmental activities of the Bremen missionaries among the people of Peki. They also provide information on the E.P. Church in the Volta Region. This thesis, which examines the impact of the Bremen Mission in the Volta Region of Ghana, with focus on the first six communities will not only provide additional in-depth data but also, picking up from Meyer’s more than two decades old works, illustrate the enduring nature of their legacy. 1.6 Theoretical Framework The study employs Walls and Ross’s (eds.)’ “Five Marks of Mission”65 which, in Ross’ view, form a good working basis for a holistic approach to mission.66 The marks include: proclaiming the Good News of the Kingdom; teaching, baptising and nurturing new believers; responding to human needs by loving service; seeking to transform unjust structures of society; and striving to safeguard the integrity of creation as well as sustaining and renewing the life of the earth.67 Proclamation in Biblical times constituted a formal public announcement from royalty.68 It also refers to “the activity of the messenger conveying an important message which had been given 64 Birgit Meyer, Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity among the Ewe in Ghana (London: Edinburgh University Press, 1999), p. 8. 65 Walls and Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century). 66 Walls and Ross (eds.) Mission in the Twenty-first Century, p. xiv. 67 Walls and Ross (eds.) Mission in the Twenty-first Century, p. ix. 68 Ken Gnanakan, “To Proclaim the Good News of the Kingdom (i)” in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 3. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 18 to him either orally or in writing.69 Jesus began his earthly ministry after he had made a proclamation in Luke 4:18-19.70 This is the good news Jesus preached. The Christian community is what it is today because of the sacrificial commitment of missionaries who offered their lives for the proclamation of the gospel.71 The churches must, therefore, give what they have to the world so that others may have fellowship with them. The Bremen missionaries first began to proclaim the Good News of the kingdom to the people of Peki. In the Great Commission, Jesus commanded his disciples to go and make disciples of all nations and to teach them to obey everything he had commanded them.72 Thus, the church does not only exist to proclaim the good news but also to teach, baptise and nurture new believers.73 Egbunu points out that the medium for the lasting transformation of converts is teaching.74 He continues that, the divine priority attached to teaching makes discipleship imperative for people who respond to the gospel. Baptism, as the initiatory rite at the point of conversion, makes the new convert step out of his old life and become identified with the death and resurrection of Christ (Romans 6:3-5).75 When new converts to the Christian faith are not steadily nurtured through the study of scripture and prayer, they easily get swayed from their faith when faced with challenging circumstances. The missionaries sought to accomplish these tasks by establishing schools to teach the indigenous people and to impart knowledge and skills which 69 Gnanakan, “To Proclaim the Good News of the Kingdom (i),” p. 3. 70 The spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to bring Good News to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives and recovery of sight for the blind, to let the oppressed go free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favour (RSV). 71 Gnanakan, “To Proclaim the Good News of the Kingdom (i)’’, p. 10. 72 Ande Titre, “To Teach, Baptise, and Nurture New Believers” in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 37. 73 Emmanuel Egbunu, “To Teach, Baptise, and Nurture New Believers” in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 25. 74Egbunu, “To Teach, Baptise, and Nurture New Believers”, p. 25. 75 Egbunu, “To Teach, Baptise, and Nurture New Believers”, p. 29. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 19 helped to improve their lives. Through their teachings, new converts were baptised into the Christian faith. Furthermore, the ‘manifesto’ of Jesus76 reveals that mission is not only about proclaiming the gospel and teaching but also to respond to the needs of humankind. “To respond to human need by loving service”77 is offering services that enhance human welfare. The greatest commandment, according to Jesus is, ‘love of God and love of neighbour’ (Matthew 22:34- 40).78 This obliges the church to express love and affection to the poor, the marginalised and the less privileged in the society. The missionaries responded by setting up healthcare facilities, digging wells for potable water and offering other humanitarian acts of mercy alongside evangelism. Loving God and loving neighbour are not sequential but a single act and hence what we do to the poor in the society is a test of what we are as people of God.79 According to Steurnagel, a holistic mission must aim at responding to unjust structures of the society, focusing on the whole of creation at peace: “Transforming justice from a biblical perspective is incarnational. It touches the very heart, feelings, and wounds of those who are victims of injustice.”80 God is the God of justice and justice must manifest in the life of the poor, the oppressed, witnessing their liberation.81 The church’s mission is to work for justice in a world where the weak are often oppressed by the wealthy and powerful. For example, the Bremen missionaries considered some practices such as ritual murder, widowhood rites, and belief in witchcraft of the Ewe people to be wrong and inhuman. Victims of such practices had 76 See Luke 4:18-19. 77 Melba Maggay, “To respond to Human Needs by Loving Service” in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 46. 78Maggay, “To respond to Human Needs by Loving Service”, p. 46. 79 Maggay, “To respond to Human Needs by Loving Service”, p. 52. 80 Valdir Raul Steuernagel. ‘’To Seek to Transform Unjust Structures of Society’’, in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 62, 69. 81 Steuernagel. ‘’To Seek to Transform Unjust Structures of Society’’, p. 72. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 20 to go through various tortures at some shrines or witch-hunting grounds to prove their innocence.82 They found these practices to be against the Christian teaching and therefore strove hard to thwart such practices among the Christian converts. Humanity’s God-given mandate to safeguard the integrity of creation and to sustain and renew life on the earth83 makes it clear that it is everyone’s responsibility to be a steward of the earth. The Bremen missionaries’ cultivation of plantations on which new crops such as teak, mango, coconut, and pear were introduced can be understood in this regard.84 Still, as DeWitt puts it, “Much as we strive to be stewards of the garden, we also strive to be stewards of God’s creation”.85 Pope Francis in his Encyclical, Laudato Si, supports this understanding, critiquing the destruction that humanity is rendering to the environment and the whole of creation: We are not God. The earth was here before us and it has been given to us…. Although it is true that we Christians have at times incorrectly interpreted the Scriptures, nowadays we must forcefully reject the notion that our being created in God’s image and given dominion over the earth justifies absolute domination over other creatures. The biblical texts are to be read in their context, with an appropriate hermeneutic, recognizing that they tell us to ‘till and keep’ the garden of the world (cf. Gen 2:15). ’Tilling’ refers to cultivating, ploughing or working, while ‘keeping’ means caring, protecting, overseeing and preserving. This implies a relationship of mutual responsibility between human beings and nature. Each community can take from the bounty of the earth whatever it needs for subsistence, but it also has the duty to protect the earth and to ensure its fruitfulness for coming generations (#67).86 The five marks of mission are significant because they provide a yardstick for examining the activities of the Bremen Mission within the study area. 82 Ganusah, Christ Meet Ewe-Dome, p. 53. 83 Calvin B. DeWitt, “To Strive to Safeguard the Integrity of Creation and Sustain and Renew the Life of the Earth” in Andrew Walls & Cathy Ross, (eds.), Mission in the 21st Century: Exploring the Five Marks of Global Mission (London: Darton, Longman and Todd Ltd, 2008), p. 84. 84 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 205. 85 DeWitt, “To Strive to Safeguard the Integrity of Creation”, P. 90. 86 Kevin Cotter, Summary of Laudato Si, Pope Francis' Encyclical on the Environment, (https://focusoncampus.org/content/summary-of-laudato-si-pope-francis-encyclical-on-the-environment- eb60806a-fe2c-41fc-8723-4ffdc631f8612015), Assessed 4th September, 2017. https://focusoncampus.org/content/summary-of-laudato-si-pope-francis-encyclical-on-the-environment-eb60806a-fe2c-41fc-8723-4ffdc631f8612015 https://focusoncampus.org/content/summary-of-laudato-si-pope-francis-encyclical-on-the-environment-eb60806a-fe2c-41fc-8723-4ffdc631f8612015 University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 21 1.7 Scope of the Study The study covers the period from 1847-1917. That is, from the arrival of the Bremen missionaries to the departure of the last German missionary during World War 1, with a special focus on their activities in the early German missionized and colonial communities of Peki, Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho and Amedzofe. The work gathered information on the activities undertaken during these periods. The study discussed and assessed the influence of those activities in the communities from the beginning of the Bremen Mission contact to present. 1.8 Structure of the Study This study has five chapters. Chapter one introduces the study and provides its background, statement of problem, aim, and objectives of the research, research questions, literature review, and theoretical framework. Also discussed in the Introduction are the study’s methodology, scope, and significance. Chapter Two discusses the Bremen Mission in the Volta Region. Chapter Three examines the challenges in the mission field. In Chapter Four, the study analyses the impact of the Bremen Mission in Eweland. The final chapter provides a summary, findings, conclusion, and recommendations. 1.9 Significance of the Study The study is expected to contribute to the literature on Missions and West African Church history with specific reference to the Bremen Mission in Ghana. Again, this research reveals some contextual evidence, which serves as a contribution to studies in Christianity and African culture. Finally, the work serves as data for further research. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 22 CHAPTER TWO THE BREMEN MISSION IN THE VOLTA REGION (1847-1917) 2.0 Introduction Many Christians have responded in varying ways to the Great Commission of Jesus Christ in Mk. 16:15.87 The North German Mission Society (NGMS) in fulfillment of this divine directive established a special group in Hamburg dedicated to proclaiming the gospel to parts of the world where it had not reached. The primary focus was to go to Africa to preach the gospel for the salvation of souls. A German composer and missionary, G. Dauble, describes the perception of Germans about the people of Africa: We hear unceasing wailing across Africa: Proceed, come to our rescue. The land of Africa is endowed with riches but the people are deep in sin Shall we look on for them to destroy in sin? Never! We shall preach The word of life freely to everybody Until they all come to Christ.88 The Bremen missionary, Bernhard Schlegel, also commented on the false and wrong European conceptions about Africans that, “the Negroes are lazy, stupid, fetish-ridden and without history” by saying that: It is one of the aims of mission to destroy these wrong conceptions. It is for this very purpose that we have come to Africa, and therefore I regret no labour, no headache, and no sickness if only I can get to know this people, its language and history.89 Indeed, these were some of the reasons that compelled the Bremen missionaries to go to the West Coast of Africa to spread the Good News and to win souls for the kingdom of God, to embark on social services that would help develop and transform the indigenous people and discover the potential in them. 87 “Go into all the world and preach the Gospel to all creation” (RSV). 88 Dorvlo, “The Contribution of German Missionary”, p. 119. 89 Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana, p.141. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 23 This chapter examines the origins and formation of the NGMS. It also describes the encounter of the Bremen Mission with the people of Peki, Keta, Waya, Anyako, Ho and Amedzofe - the early mission stations. Finally, it discusses the missionary policies and strategies that sought to ensure godly living in the non-Christian setting. 2.1 The Establishment of the Bremen Mission The Bremen Mission was established in the north German town of Bremen in 1836. Similar to the Basel Mission, its beginning can be traced to the Deutsche Christentums-Gesellschaft (German Christian Society) founded in the Swiss city of Basel in 1780. It was established originally as a Bible study and discussion group and also to publish good Christian literature.90 In 1819, the Bremische Missionsverein (Bremen Mission Association) came out of this society.91 The representatives of these associations, by a written agreement, decided to form the NGMS in the north German town of Bremen.92 In June 1835, the Protestants in Germany held an open meeting in Stade during which it was agreed that all Protestant Mission Societies in Germany should be invited to form one NGMS which would send workers abroad.93 Subsequently, in April 1836, the Lutheran and Reformed Protestants in Hamburg came together to form the NGMS.94 The mission was one of the several societies established in the early part of the 19th Century with inspiration from the Pietist Movement and the Christian Awakening in the 17th and 18th Centuries.95 90 Jon Miller, Missionary Zeal and Institutional Control. Organizational Contradictions in the Basel Mission on the Gold Coast, 1828-1917 (Grand Rapids), p. 14, Abraham N.O. Kwakye, “Mission Impossible becomes Possible: West Indian Missionaries as Actors in Mission in the Gold Coast” in Interkulteurelle Theologile Zeiteschrift Furl Missionswissens Chaft, 42 Jahrhgang (2016) p. 223. 91 Burton I. Goddderd: The Encyclopaedia of Modern Christian Mission (Tholmes Nelson and Sons, Toronto, London, New Jersey, 1967), p. 490, McWilson K. Atakro, Indigenous Leadership of the Ewe Church in Ghana and Togo (1847-1945): The Case of Reverend Andreas Aku, Robert Stephen Kwami and Robert Domingo Baeta (An unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Ghana, Legon, 2008), p. 66. 92 David N.A Kpobi, Mission in Ghana: The Ecumenical Heritage (Accra: Asempa Publishers 2008), 82. 93 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 18. 94 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 18. 95 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 18. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 24 The NGMS originally began in Hamburg and later moved to Bremen since both towns were geographically located in the northern part of Germany.96 Ustorf argues that the mission’s headquarters was relocated from Hamburg to Bremen because the society did not have a mission house and so held meetings in rented places or in the private houses of its affluent members. The leadership of the NMGS comprised influential traders and pastors from the upper class of Bremen.97 Their motivation for organising and partly financing the mission emanated from their conviction that the expansion of the kingdom of God was a task for every true Christian.98 In order to train people for missionary work, a mission school was established in 1837 at Hamburg by Rev. Johan Hartwig Brauer, the first Inspector of the Society. The school began with four students but increased to ten by 1846 with the majority being farmers, artisans or traders.99 They were trained for four years. Meyer asserts that unlike the committee members of the Mission Society, the missionaries who were recruited did not belong to the upper classes but were mostly farmers, craftsmen or petty traders with only basic education. Many of them came from southern Germany, especially Wurttemberg, which was well known for the vitality of its Pietist tradition.100 The selected students were expected to be between eighteen and twenty-four years old, not married but healthy males with unimpeachable conduct who were willing to obey orders in the mission school as well as later in the mission field.101 The first batch of five missionaries was sent out by the mission to New Zealand and India which were the mission society’s original target. Later, they included West Africa. The rule that governed missionary work in Africa was a call of willingness to suffer and rejoicing in 96 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome, p. 34. 97 Birgit Meyer, Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity, p. 29. 98 Meyer, Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity among the Ewe in Ghana, p. 29. 99 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 81, Kpobi, Mission in Ghana, p. 82, Cephas N. Omenyo, Pentecost Outside Pentecostalism, p. 59. 100 Meyer, Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity, p. 29. 101 Meyer, Translating the Devil: Religion and Modernity, p. 29. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 25 death, as implied by Franz Michael Zahn, the Mission Inspector (1862-1900) when he addressed the students who had completed their studies and were ready to be sent out: We take your willingness to mean that, trusting in the grace of the Lord, you are willing to give up even your life, if it is demanded, and in the power of God to fight perhaps even more difficult fight against the temptations to bad temper, fretfulness and faintheartedness with which the climate makes missionaries familiar.102 This indicates that the willingness to embark on a mission is not borne out of coercion but a readiness to suffer and to sacrifice oneself. No wonder that despite the frequent deaths of their colleagues and other challenges on the mission field, more missionaries were willing to take up the mantle to spread the gospel to win more souls into the Christian faith. In 1847, the mission planned to embark on a mission in Gabon as a way of extending their activities to the West Coast of Africa.103 2.2 Bremen Mission in Ghana- A Brief History The first group of missionaries to come to the Gold Coast were part of the trainees at the missionary school in Hamburg.104 On 5th May 1847, the society sent four missionaries to the Gold Coast, namely, Lorenz Wolf, Jens Graff, Luer Bultmann, and Karl Flato. They were originally meant to go to Gabon. Richard Foli ascribes the transit at Cape Coast by the Bremen Missionaries to a lack of direct sea route linking Germany and Gabon.105 Upon their arrival, Wolf and Bultman went to Gabon to explore mission opportunities while the other two missionaries stayed at Cape Coast based on the advice of the veteran Wesleyan Methodist missionary, Thomas Birch Freeman. 102 Ustorf, Bremen Missionaries in Togo and Ghana, p. 112. 103 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome of Ghana, p. 35. 104 Confidence W. Bansah, Salvation at the Crossroad: Christianity and Ewe Indigenous Religion in West Africa (Accra: SonLife Press, 2013), p. 84. 105 Bansah, Salvation at the Crossroad, p. 24. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 26 Wolf was not allowed to stay in Gabon by the French government, which was in control of the country at the time.106 It was said that: “The Government was jealous of the influence of the missionaries, and opposed them, less perhaps as Protestants than as disseminators of Anglo- Saxon influence and culture”.107 As a result, the French officials disallowed Protestant mission work in Gabon although the missionaries found the Africans friendly and were described as more effective in terms of conversions than the Catholic missions. When the Gabon mission proved unsuccessful, Wolf returned to Cape Coast. Unfortunately, Bultmann and Flato passed away at Gabon and Cape Coast respectively. Wolf and Graff left Cape Coast to Christiansborg to seek counsel from the Basel missionaries in respect of untapped mission fields to engage their attention.108 They were advised and encouraged to turn to Eweland. The old Danish coastal town of Keta would have been the most suitable area among the Ewes to begin the mission.109 However, according to Agbeti, Keta had been bombarded by the Danes due to the Anlo opposition against the attempt to halt the slave trade between the Portuguese and the people of Keta.110 While contemplating the advice of the Basel missionaries, the two missionaries came into contact with Nyangamagu, son of Tutu, Togbui Kwadzo Dei, Paramount King of Krepi,111 who was then studying at the Basel Mission school at Christiansborg. Their interaction with the prince inspired them to establish a mission station at Peki. Abraham N.O. Kwakye argues: According to Peki tradition, Nyangamagu’s stay in Christiansborg had influenced his esteem for European missions. Several decades of Danish presence in Christiansborg together with the few years of Basel mission influence had transformed Christiansborg into an active and prosperous commercial town. This had highly influenced the young Krepi prince who hoped that his father’s country would experience similar prosperity 106 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome, P. 35. 107 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome, P. 35. 108Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 81, Ansre (ed.). Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 20. 109 Abraham N.O. Kwakye, “Encountering ‘Prosperity’ Gospel in Nineteenth Century Gold Coast: Indigenous Perceptions of Western Missionary Societies” in Andreas Hauser (ed.), Pastures of Plenty: Tracing Religio- Scapes of Prosperity Gospel in Africa and Beyond (New York: Peter Lang GmbH, 2015), p. 222. 110 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 82. 111 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 82. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 27 with the mission. His studies at the Christiansborg institution also exposed him to Western education which he deemed necessary for the future development of the kingdom.112 This indicates that economic expectations and hopes for other benefits might have been the reasons why the indigenous people welcomed the missionaries. Kwakye continued that the message the prince sent to his father might have caused the people of Peki to conclude that the coming of the missionaries to their community would “mark the beginning of the transformation of their society from a simple village to a prosperous and famous commercial center like Christiansborg”.113 Therefore, after consultation with his father, Nyangamagu assured the missionaries that his father was ready and willing to receive them for mission work to be done in his kingdom. This paved the way for the arrival of the Bremen missionaries in the Volta Region. 2.3 The Early Mission Stations 2.3.1 The Bremen Missionaries in Peki On 9th November 1847, Lorenz Wolf and his entourage left Christiansborg for Peki. He arrived at Peki on Sunday 14th November 1847. According to Agbeti, Wolf was given a warm welcome by the chief and his people for which he indicated in his report home that, ‘they were too glorious for a poor missionary’.114 This might have been so because of the benefits they anticipated to get from the missionary. He began his work the same day when he preached to the people based on Ps. 22:23115, showing them in simplicity the plan of man’s salvation in Christ.116 In line with his mission, Wolf intended to gain souls for the kingdom of God.117 He interacted with the people of Peki, making them understand that the purpose of his coming was 112 Kwakye, “Encountering ‘Prosperity’ Gospel,” p. 223. 113 Kwakye, “Encountering ‘Prosperity’ Gospel,” p. 224. 114 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 83. 115 I will tell of thy name to my brethren, in the midst of the congregation I will praise thee (RSV). 116 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 84. 117 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 59. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 28 for peace, not to buy slaves or to rob people of their land.118 This assurance was necessary in view of the slave trade that was rampant at that time. To this Wolf expressed: I am not going to buy slaves nor do I have in mind to rob people of their land. I come a long way from a country where there are only white people. I wish to show you the source of happiness: the true God. I wish to proclaim him from whom come all good gifts and who sent his son into this world of ours.119 Wolf’s intention, therefore, correlates with Verkuyl’s example of pure motives – the motive of Love, Mercy, and Pity120 which define the motivation of the Bremen missionaries towards their missionary task. Thus, despite the numerous deaths and the many difficulties encountered, the missionaries persisted in communicating the gospel message to the people in love and mercy. The missionary agenda was the preaching of the good news, but the people of Peki were more interested in the socio-economic benefits they could gain than the gospel.121 In order to disabuse the minds of the people from their expected gains, Wolf made known to them Pietism’s stance that material things were the equivalent of the ‘broader path’122 that leads to destruction. Towards enhancing the missionary work, Wolf asked for a mission house to be built for him and with the assistance from the indigenes, his new home was completed on 14th January 1848.123 This house differed in size and form from the usual Peki houses.124 This was because, in his (Wolf) view, the ‘unhealthy’ weather condition of Africa had to be offset for by houses of European style.125 As a result, all the mission houses, chapels, and schools built by the missionaries in the areas they operated were of the same European architectural structure and design. Kpobi states that ‘the mission station established by Wolf with local support became 118 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 60. 119 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome of Ghana, p. 36. 120 Verkuyl, Contemporary Missiology, p. 25. 121Kwakye, “Encountering ‘Prosperity’ Gospel”, p. 224. 122 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 59. 123 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 24. 124 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 60. 125 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 60. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 29 the nucleus of transformation that would eventually extend to many other towns and villages of the Ewes.126 Indeed, most of the indigenes emulated the missionaries’ style of building and constructed their houses with the same design. Moses Mensah mentions that “it is interesting to see how early Peki wattle and daub architecture gradually gave way to building patterns similar to the stone and wood style introduced by the Bremen Mission”.127 As Wolf was alone in Peki, more missionaries were dispatched from Bremen to assist the mission work. Two missionaries, Friedrich Groth and Friedrich Hermann Quinius arrived on 3rd March 1849 to support him. In the following year, Miss Koroline Deist - Wolf’s bride - also landed at Peki.128 Consequently, Wolf was invited home as a result of ill-health and constrained financial status, without gaining a single convert, according to mission statistics.129 By 1851 Wolf together with his wife, Groth and Quinius left Peki. Wolf died upon arrival in Hamburg harbour and was buried there in April 1851.130 This notwithstanding, Wolf’s death and the departure of his colleagues did not end missionary work in the Volta Region. In 1852, Wilhelm Dauble, Johannes Menge, Quinius and his wife were sent to Peki to continue the work began by Wolf. They passionately committed themselves to the mission, but similar to their predecessors their effort did not produce any substantial results. Unfortunately, in March and April 1852 Quinius’ first son and Menge died and were buried in Peki.131 The unfavourable climate, which had a tremendous effect on their health, coupled with the threat of wars between Peki and the Ashanti-Akwamu alliance in 1852 made the work difficult 126 Kpobi, Mission in Ghana, 83. 127 Mensah, Bremen Missionary Interactions with the Peki, p. 45. 128 Ganusah, Christ Meets the Ewe-Dome of Ghana, p. 37. 129 Meyer, Translating the Devil an African Appropriation, p. 60. 130Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 86. 131 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 87. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 30 for the missionaries at Peki; they decided to transfer the mission station from Peki to the coastal areas of Keta.132 They were also convinced that the geographical location of Keta would be favourable for them as compared to Peki because they thought that it would be easier to get supplies from Accra and also be in regular touch with Germany if they were stationed in Keta.133 2.3.2 The Bremen Missionaries in Keta The Bremen missionaries Dauble and Plessing set themselves up at Keta and landed at Dzelukofe near Keta on 2nd September 1853. They then walked half an hour journey to Keta.134 Keta was an important trading port between the fourteenth and twentieth centuries. The town caught Danish interest because they felt they could establish a base devoid of interference from rival European nations there.135 Additionally, besides a factory and a warehouse, the town also had a fort which had a garrison of 30 soldiers under the command of Governor Evans.136 The Governor allowed the missionaries to stay at the fort while they looked for land to build their own house. With the support from some Africans trained at Cape Coast, they constructed their first mission station137 (see fig 2.1). 132 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 27. 133 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 88. 134 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 27. 135 Emmanuel K. Akyeampong, Between the sea and the Lagoon (Oxford: James Currey, p. 46. http://en.mwikipedia.org/wiki/keta), Assessed 16th September, 2017. 136 Dorvlo, “The Contributions of German Missionary”, p. 124. 137 Dorvlo, “The Contributions of German Missionary”, p. 124. http://en.mwikipedia.org/wiki/keta University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 31 Figure 2. 1: The first mission house at Keta Source: Bremen Mission Archives. The missionaries presumed that since Keta was located along the coast, it was going to have a positive influence on their health. However, to their amazement, there was little discernible difference in conditions from the inland Peki. Dauble died on 26th December 1853 after a short illness. Bructcschin arrived at Keta on 6th January 1854 to assist Plessing who was ostensibly also on his deathbed. The news of his colleague’s arrival made him recover speedily and the two continued their work with fresh hope.138 The chief of Anlo ordered his subjects not to offer any help to the missionaries, because they had not paid him a courtesy call upon their arrival, this created some difficulties for them.139 The missionaries admitted their gaffe and offered a subsequent apology which led to steady progress in the mission work. The evangelisation work did not yield much result because the local people did not accept the missionaries wholeheartedly. However, the mission witnessed some positive outcome in 1855 when the first seven converts were baptised after seven years of missionary work in Ewe land. 138 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 29. 139 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 89. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 32 Agbeti observes: The missionaries had laboured for seven years, buried seven of their members during this period and now had won seven souls for the Lord: Thus after many years of disappointments, the missionaries had the encouragement that their labour had begun to bear concrete fruits.140 There is the need to mention that Wolf’s sole objective was to win souls into the Christian faith. Although he did not witness his goal come to fruition before he passed on, he needs to be commended for the bold step taken towards the salvation of souls, most especially that of John Ababio, the only Ewe among the seven new-baptised converts who was a native of Peki, the first mission station of the Bremen Mission. In a bid to win more souls, the missionaries planned to travel inland to take the good news to the indigenous people there. However, they were prevented by the Anlo chief who claimed that the hinterland was reserved for the great Anlo deity (Trͻga) and the people living there should not be exposed to the gospel of the missionaries.141 They were later allowed to preach in those areas and they went to other places beyond the Keta Lagoon. Their work there did not yield positive results as compared to that of Keta. The missionaries continued to travel further inland and towards the north and finally entered Adaklu Waya. 2.3.3 The Bremen Missionaries in Waya The missionaries were attracted by the Adaklu Mountain in the vast Savanah Plains.142 They entered Asadame, Avenor, Mafi and other towns but the leaders of the land and the people did not accept them.143 They travelled further until on 26th January 1855, the two missionaries Wihm Brutschin and Hans J. Steinmann together with their interpreter John Wright reached Waya from Keta.144 They spelt out their mission to the chiefs and elders of the town. Upon 140 Agbeti, West African Church History, p. 90. 141 Dorvlo, “The Contributions of German Missionary,” p. 125. 142 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 34. 143 Paul Wiegrabe, Ewe Kristo Nutimya 1847-1936 (USA: St. Louis, 1936), pp. 12-13. 144 Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana, p. 128. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 33 hearing it they received the message with joy and assured them of their support.145 Due to this reception, they requested for a piece of land from the chief of the town, Togbe Komla Asbeve (Lablulu) to open a mission station. After having a brief interaction with the people they left for Keta with the intention of returning to Waya later.146 A year after, in January 1856, the missionaries returned to Waya to begin their missionary activities. They brought with them some trees to be planted at Waya. On that same day of arrival two of the trees - mango and pear - were planted. Rev. Francis Djofoxeh, the District Pastor of Adaklu-Waya, reports that: “It was quite recently that the pear tree fell due to heavy wind and the mango tree being the only surviving tree of the missionaries, also fell last year (2016).”147 He added, “I ate the last fruit from the mango tree and after a week the tree fell”.148 The missionaries began the construction of the mission house since they had already acquired the land and through the assistance of the indigenes, were able to build the mission house together with a chapel and a school.149 They began fervently with the preaching of the gospel. Two other missionaries, Christian Hornberger and Wilh Lemgo at this time joined their colleagues to continue the work. The former was a scientist who stayed at Waya and later went further inland to establish a church at Atakpame, while the latter worked as a teacher and evangelist among the people of Adaklu.150 As a result of the cordial relationship between the missionaries and the people, there was a peaceful atmosphere for the missionaries. This paved the way for them to make Waya the center for their mission work. They journeyed from Waya to Peki, Keta, Anyako and many other 145Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 34. 146 Evangelical Presbyterian Church Adaklu-Waya: 150 Years Anniversary Brochure (2006), p.7. 147 Francis K. Djofoxeh (District Pastor of Adaklu Waya), Interview, 21st November, 2017, Adaklu –Waya. 148 Djofoxeh, Interview, Adaklu –Waya. 149 Ansre, Evangelical Presbyterian Church, p. 34. 150 Evangelical Presbyterian Church Adaklu-Waya, p. 9. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 34 places for their missionary activities.151 It is recorded that by 1886 quite a number of the indigenes in Waya had joined the Christian faith.152 The work at Waya grew well which elated the missionaries. When the missionaries became convinced that Waya had been firmly established, they moved further to establish a station at Anyako. This initiative became important because it was realised that Waya needed an intermediary station on the inland side of the Keta Lagoon.153 Again, it is recorded that when the Keta Lagoon dried up, the shortest route on foot to Adaklu was through Anyako on the northern shores of the lagoon.154 Therefore, it was necessary for the missionaries to set up a station at Anyako. 2.3.4 The Bremen Missionaries in Anyako Heinrich Knecht and his team arrived at Anyako on 14th April 1857. The chief and his elders gave them a warm welcome.155 Land was acquired and with the support of the people, a house was built and used as a residence and a school. In 1858, they received assistance from Johann Mansfield, a missionary described as a master builder and built a second house. It was a two- storey building which made it unique among the structures in Waya. In 1858, the first-ever synod meeting of Keta, Waya and Anyako was held in this building.156 However, the construction of the storey building sparked some suspicion in the people against the missionaries. Their fear that the missionaries would place canons from Keta on the second floor of the strange building and wage war on the town revealed a mistrust which may have 151 Evangelical Presbyterian Church Adaklu-Waya, p. 8. 152 Evangelical Presbyterian Church Adaklu-Waya, p. 10. 153 Debrunner, A History of Christianty in Ghana, p. 128. 154 Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Anyako: A short History of Anyako E.P. Church 150 th Anniversary Celebration Brochure (2007), p. 14. 155 Wise K. Treve, Religious Conflict and Its Impacts on Society: A Case Study of Global Evangelical and Evangelical Presbyterian Churches in Anyako (An unpublished MPhil Thesis, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Ghana. 2013), p. 50. 156 Evangelical Presbyterian Church Anyako, p. 28. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 35 existed from the beginning. The indigenous people rejected the missionaries and everything they sought to introduce. Generally, missionaries who came to Africa were viewed with suspicion in their areas of operation. According to Treve, even before the missionaries could settle at Anyako there were rumours that the missionaries were buccaneers in disguise. So, if they were allowed to settle at Anyako they would raise armies to join with Danes in Keta with other neighbours in Adaklu Waya to attack Anyako. However, through the intervention of some good-hearted people at Anyako, the chiefs and his subjects finally accepted the missionaries in good faith.157 When the indigenes realised that the missionaries were not the same as slave raiders, they established such a close relationship with the missionaries that the missionaries remarked that leaving Anyako would be as difficult as having one‘s heart removed from one’s chest.158 The missionaries did not toil in vain in Anyako. After ten years of missionary activity (1857-1867), they were able to baptise fifteen converts (youths) to the Christian faith.159 Spreading out from Anyako, the missionaries decided to open another mission site at Ho. 2.3.5 The Bremen Missionaries in Ho When it became evident that Waya was not suitable as a mission station,160 the missionaries explored the surrounding areas, travelling to Agotime, Agu, Ho, and Peki in search of a more suitable site. The tribal war between Agu and Agotime ruled these two towns out and Peki was found to be too far from Waya.161 The missionaries chose a good place near Kordibe where the air was favourable but the landowners refused to sell the land to them. An indigenous priest in the town was instrumental in their rejection claiming that the gods and the missionaries could 157 Treve, Religious Conflict and Its Impacts on Society, p. 50. 158 Treve, Religious Conflict and Its Impacts on Society, p. 50. 159 Wiegrabe, Ewe Kristo Hame Nutinya, p. 20. 160 Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana, p. 128. 161 Debrunner, A History of Christianity in Ghana, p. 128. University of Ghana http://ugspace.ug.edu.gh 36 not in any way stay together.162 On 27th November 1858, the missionaries acquired a piece of land and opened a mission station at Ho. The establishment of the mission station and the development at Ho was much quicker than at other places. They went there based on these words: “the last shall be the first!”163 The chief of Keke, Morte Kofi, regularly advised his subjects to accept the gospel of the missionaries and jointhe Christian faith. Contrarily, he himself refused to be converted164 without any known reason. The missionaries regularly travelled from Ho to the other towns for evangelism accompanied by the students in the Mission school at Ho. When the missionaries visited Klefe the people assured them and said, “If the people of Ho have accepted the Gospel, they would also accept it.”165 According to Ansre, the opening of the Ho station marked the end of the pioneering stage of the Mission’s activities and the beginning of the expansion.166 Nonetheless, after the Asante war in 1874, the people of Avatime were also introduced to the Christian religion. Some indigenes of Avatime migrated to other areas in the country to escape the war. While in exile, two men from Gbadzeme encountered the Basel Missionaries at Mayera and Abokobi near Accra and were baptised.167 When they returned home after the war, they established a Christian community. This was the community that the Bremen missionaries visited during one of their travels and saw the Amedzofe hill and Mountain Gemi. This attracted them to visit Amedzofe and they subsequently considered establishing a station there. 162 Wiegrabe, Ewe Kristo Hame Nutinya, p. 20. 163 Wiegrabe, Ewe Kristo Hame Nutiny