THE EVANGELICAL CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIPS AND THE CHARISMATIZATION OF GHANAIAN CHRISTIANITY Abamfo O. Atiemo Abstract: Contemporary Christianity in Ghana is dominated by Pentecostal/Charismatic culture. This has attracted attention in several scholarly works and analyses have been made of the historical factors that have been responsible for this development, However, an important phase in the history of the development of the faith in Ghana - the phase of the evangelical Christian fellowships - seems to have been largely ignored. This article draws attention to the significance of that phase for Ghanaian Christianiry in general and its importance as the watershed in the transition from the dominance of the old mission-instituted type of Christianity to the current dominance of the Pentecostal /Charismatic lype. Introduction The Charismatic movemeht in Ghana has attracted widespread attention in scholarly works, The various branches of the move- ment have been well studied. Dovlo,r Gifford,2 Larbi,3 Omenyoa and Asamoah-Gyadus have all ' Elom Dovlo, 'Comparative Overview of Independent Churches and Charismatic minish'ies in Ghana' Trinity Journal o/ Church and Theologt,2:2 (December, 1992), pp. 55 - 73.2 Paul Gitlbrd, Ghanab New Christiani\): Pentecostalism in a Globalising African IE c ono m1, (London: Hurst & Co., 2004).E,. Kingsley Larbi, Pentecostalism: The Eddies o/'Ghanaian Christianity( Accra: Centre fbr Charismatic and Pentecostal Studies, 200 I ). aCeplras Omenyo, Pentecost Outside Pentecostalisnt: A Study of the development o/' Charisruatic renewal in the Mainline Chtrches in Ghana(Zoetermeer: Boekencentrum Publishing House, 2006); See also, Cephas Omenyo, 'From The Fringes to the Centre : Pentecostalisation of the Mainline Chr.rrches in Ghana' Exchange,34, / (2005), pp.38 - 60. s J. K. Asamoah - Gyadu, African Charismatics; Current Developments within Independent Indigenous Pentecostalism in Ghana(Leiden/Boston: Brill. 2005) Ghana Bulletin of Theolog, Vol. 2 43 Abanlfo O. Atiemo studied and documented various aspects of the movement, Its history, theology, impact, and so forth have been well discussed. However, the crucialphase of the evangelical fellowships, which formed the main link in the transition from the dominance of the old form orthodox/mainline christianity to the current dominance of pentecostal/charismatic christianity, has been virtually neglected. Most scholars only mention that phase in passing. For example, Larbi,6 omenyoT and Asamoah-Gyadus devote only small sections of a few paragraphs each to the evangelical fellowships. Yet the fellowships, more thin any other factor, have been directly responsible for the fast and widespread growth and acceptance of the Pentecostal icharismatic culture in Ghanaian christianiiy. rney afforded a smooth transition from 'westernthe predominance of the old forms of christianity to the general acceptance of the mainly pentecostal fonns by the Ghanaian Christian public. Up till about the late 1960s the main renewal movements known in Ghanaian christianity were the African Independent churches (AICs), the classical Pentecostal churches and the prayir Groups within the mainline churches. The prayer groups within the mainline churches had not gained any significant influence, and were found only in a few places. Most of them operated without official approval oftheir churches and often found themselves in conflict with the official church hierarchy.e The Classical Pentecostal and the African Independent churches themselves were, at that time, generally regarded as 'strange sects'that intruded on the serene and established christian culture of traditional westem denominations. whole families, and in some cases, ethnic groups had come to be identified with one or other denomination, I0 and any member ostrange who converted to anyof those sects' was regarded a renegade who disturbed family i'cl [,r* Larbi,_Penrecostalism: The Eddies of Ghanaian Christianity, p. gB ephas *, omen,vo. Pentecost ofiside pentecostuiism: A sntdy of the Diietopment of Charismatic -Renewal in the Mainline Churches in Ghana, p.95. s.Asamoah.-Gyadu (African charismatics, p.t0fffl pays greater attention to the subject than the other scholars. eAbamfo Atiemo, The Rise of the charismatic Movement in the Mainline churches in Ghana (Acxa: Asempa Publishers, 1993), pp. 46 - 47 . '" Abamtb Atiemo, christian Denominations and Ethnic Identity: An Assessment of the lmpact of the Missionary Movement on Aspects of Ghanaian social Life., Eddy A. J. G. Van der Borght et. al. (eds,) Faith and Ethnicity, vol t (zoetermeer: uitgeverij Meinema. 2002), pp.2l7 -229. 44 Th.e Evangelical Christian Fellowships solidarity and identity. These churches were also regarded as churches for people of low socio-economic status. Of these Churches, Larbi writes, Without despising the dedication, commitment, and achievement of the early leaders, it is not an Overstatement to indicate that their previous educational background did not prepare them for the elites of society....It is therefore no exaggeration to state that the impact the Church made upon the higher echelon of society was minimal.rl Many educated young people, who by birth, belonged to those churches, were not willing to identifu with them. The mainline churches had remained very nominal and had lost the confidence of the young peopie. In fact, leaders ofthose churches had begun to express concern about the drift of their members to the 'Apostolic' (Pentecostal) and the 'Spiritual' lAfrican I ndependent) churches. Then in the 1970s, through the influence of movements such as the Scripture Union (SU), the University Christian Fellowships or the Ghana Fellowship of Evangelical Students (GHAFES), and Campus Crusade for Christ, which had been operating mainly in second and third cycle Educational Institutions, non-denominational evangelical Christian Fellowships sprang up and started to spread in towns and cities Of the country.13 These fellowships sprang up spontaneously and spread very fast. They could be found in almost every city, town and neighbourhood. There were also lunchtime fellowships in many workplaces, including the government ministries. Apart from the town and neighbourhood fellowships, many'evangelistic' groups were also fonned. They included the Youth Ambassadors for Christ Association (YAFCA), Christ Reminders, the Ghana Evangelical Society (GES), Hour of Visitation Choir and Evangelistic Association (HOVCEA) and the Volta Evangelistic Association. The most influential of them was the Ghana Evangelical Society (GES). " E,. Kirrgsley Larbi, PentecostaLism: The Eddies oJ'Ghanaian Christianity, p. 179. I2 See Omenyo, Pentec:ost Ottside Pentecostalisnt, pp. 102. 128. '' Some of these movements, e.g. the Scripture Union and the University Christian Fellowship. had been in the country for a long time but their activities were confined to educational institutions. 45 Abamfo O. Atiemo Nature of the Fellowships These fellowships were non-denominational in nature and were careful not to align themselves with any denomination; though they had a clear bias towards churches they considered'spiritually alive'.la Theywereallnot the same. There were distinctions among them. They could be classified as follows: . Town and neighbourhood fellowships . Work place fellowships . Evangelisticassociations . Fellowships with international connections Town and Neighbourhood Fellowships These were found in most towns and neighbourhoods throughout Ghana. By 1980, only a few towns and villages in Ghana wer. without such fellowships, Many of these fellowships feil under the scripture Union (SU), which until the emergence of the town fellowships iestricted its activities to educational institutions. Aduborfour reports tirat the SU was initially reluctant to establish formal links with these fellowships.rs Among the reasons for this reluctance was the fear of losing the goodwill it had built between itself and the churches over the years. The leadership of the SU feared that church leaders might misinterpret the fellowshipi as attempts to 'poach their members to establish rival churches.,l6 However, the SU eventually saw an opportunity in the emergence of the town fellowships and appointed a full-time secretary to serve them. It was the first time such appointment had been made by the SU anywhere in Africa.r' Ia Such chttrches were mostly evangelical ones like the various Baptist communities. Pentecostal Churches like the Assernblies ofGod, Church ofPenteco;t. and the various Apostolic Chur"ches. They co nsidered the Mission-instituted churcires as otlicially sound in doctline but rnostly t'illed with 'church goers'rather than born-again believers. Members of such Churches needecl to be evangelised but when they wlre converted they did not need to leave their churches since ihose churches were already sound in doctrine and practice. The Afiican Independent churches were regardei by the f'ellowships as 'demonic' or 'f'alse' churches and people in them needei to be rescued. on conversion they were made to leave their churches andjoin ,genuine'churches. '' Samuel B. Adudorfour, Evangelical para Church Movemenrs in Ghanaian christianity: c. I 950 - Early I 990s, (phD Thesis, university of Edinburgh, July. 1994), p. 84. I6 Adrrborfour. Evangelical Para Church Movements, p. g4. 'SU Afi'ican Regional council Newsletter.4. 19g1. p.3. cited by Aduborfour.. Evangelical Para Church Moventents, p.86. 46 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships Work Place Fellowships Many work places became centres of vigorous Christian evangelistic and worship activity. Members of the fellowships went to work earlier than the official time of reporting so that they could spend some time together in prayer and reading of the Bible. Lunchtime on specific weekdays was a tirne for a more elaborate prayer and study meeting. Sometimes, top management personnel were involved in such meetings. At the Ministries area where most of the government ministries and departments were situated, fellowships in the various ministries occasionally converged at a central point for special programmes, such as to listen to a specially invited speaker or to pray for the experience of the Holy Spirit baptism. Professional or occupational fellowships such the Nurses Christian Fellowship and the Armed Forces Christian Fellowship were also establ ished. Evangelistic Associations Although all the various types of the fellowships were evangelistic in orientation, those designated as evangelistic associations emphasised evangelism and actively engaged in vigorous evangelistic activities, travelling across the length and breath of the nation. There were two kinds of evangelistic associations: those with an orientation to use many different methods, especially open-air tnass preaching, street and market-square preaching, and house -to-house preaching; and those who aimed at evangelising niainly through music and preaching. Examples of the former are the Ghana Evangelical Society (GES), National Evangelistic Association (NEA), Christ Reminders, and Holy Power Evangelistic Fellowship (HOPEF). Others were the Volta Evangelistic Association (VEA) and the Christ is the Same Ministry. Among the latter were the Hour of Visitation Choir and Evangelistic Association (HOVCEA), Joylul Way Singers, and Calvary Road. These fellowships did not form their branches with the converts they made through their evangelistic activities. They directed converts tojoin any ofthe churches regarded as'genuine'or 'Bible believirtg.'r8 Fellowships with International Connections Fellowships that originated from outside Ghana but were in close relationship with the evangelical fellowships also existed' Two most r8 See tbotnote l4 above. 47 Abamfo O. Atiemo prominent ones are the Youth for christ (yFC) and later, the Full-Gospel Business Men's Fellowship International (FGBMFI). Unity classifying the fellowships into types does not imply any marked distinctions between them with respect to beliefs and pralticer. ih.r" *u, a tremendous sense of Christian unity among them and members visited each other's fellowship without inhibition and there were great collaborations to organize evangelistic outreach programmes. Bible teachers and evangelists moved from one fellowship to-ano-ther to minister. Atternpts were made to unite them into ecumenical bodies. For example, a coordinating committee of christian Fellowships (cccF) was formed in the Greater Accra region, and a National union of christian youth (NUCY) was formed by Rev Abraham De-Love who was the pastor of the Philadelphia church in Accra and one of the most prominent leaders of the evangelical fellowships._ln the countryside, many of the fellowships that had affiliated to the su formed what they called, ,Area committees of the Scripture union.'Such bodies brought the feilowships together in a formal way to jointly organise evangelistic crusades, seminars,ltudy and prayer camps, and rallies. The Theology of the Fellowships The fellowships had no officiar set of articles of faith. Their attitude to logrna may be captured in the words of one of their most popurar hymns. Hymn numbered 291 of Golclen Bells; My faith has found a resting place Not in a lorm or creed I trust the ever-living one His wounds for me shall plead. Chorus I neecl no other argument I ncecl no other plea It is enotLgh that Jesus died And that he diedfor me. And also, in the words of the popular chorus, Only Jesus can save! 48 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships Only Jesus can save! Halleluiah! They emphasised scriptures and experience more than dogma. However, it is possible to outline their teachings and practices as follows: Centrality of the Scriptures The fellowships were virtual Biblicists. They focussed, almost entirely, on the Bible. Their meetings were marked by vigorous Bible study and ernphasised the importance of committing Bible verses to memory. They promoted what has come to be known in Christian circles as 'Quiet time' by which is meant the setting aside of a period of the day for prayer and rneditation on the Bible. Devotional materials produced by the Scripture Union(SU) and the International Bible Reading Association (IBRA) were, especially, recommended as guides to such meditation. The New Birth Fundamental to the theology of the fellowships was the doctrine of the 'new birth' attained by believing in, and confessing Jesus Christ as 'Lord and personal saviour'. They taught that there were two types of people in the Church: 'Church goers' and 'born-again' Christians. 'Church-goers' were not genuine Christians and needed to be re-evangelised. Many of the people that filled the pews of the traditional mainline Protestant and Roman Catholic churches were regarded as belonging to the former. The person who was not born-again but went to Church was a 'carnal Christian' and the religious services such a person engaged in did not please God. For without the 'new birth', all human efforts to be righteous 'are like filthy rags'(lsaiah 64:6). Jesus, the Only Saviour Their theology of God was the orthodox Trinitarian one. However, the focus was on Jesus because of their emphasis on'salvation'.'Only Jesus can save' was a recurring refrain in the preaching and admonitions of the fellowships. Jesus and the events surrounding his life and work was the reference point of their preaching. New Testament passages such as, 'l am the way, the truth and the life...'(John l4:6) and'There is no other name under heaven, whereby we may be saved'(Acts 4:12) were cited in support of the teaching. This saving power of God through Jesus Christ was set in the context of the love of God which was deemed as 49 Abamfo O. Atiemo unsurpassed by any kind of love known in human experience. This is illustrated in the words of the popular chorus, Your Jather may love you,' Your mother may love you. But none can die for you. The love ofJesus surpasses all. The Holy Spirit Their view about the Holy Spirit was, originally, very orthodox. with the exception of the GES and a few others who started as pentecostal movements from the very beginning, most of the,fellowships did not have an explicit Pentecostal ethos from the start.'' The Hoiy Spirit was considered the main agent of the 'new birth' and also the unfailing 'companion and Teacher' of the believer on earth. The pentecostal understanding of the Holy Spirit was embraced much later. But when it was embraced it quickly became the main view in their teaching and practice. Speaking in tongues and prophecies were the most popular manifestations that believers sought after. Frorn that point on, the Pentecostal understancling of the Holy Spirit became the standard for measuring the soundness of a denonrination,s doctrines and spirituality. From the point of view of many fellowships, the GES for example, most of the existing Churches had the right doctrines and practices but what was lacking was an adequate understanding of, and the correct attitude to the palpable manifestation of the Holy Spirit in the believer. They organised special prayer meetings for what they termed, 'Holy spirit baptism'. At such meetings people who were berieved to have received the 'baptism of the Holy spirit' manifested the gifts of speaking in tongues and prophecies. Healing and exorcisms (or what they call 'deliverance' in the contemporary charismatic Movement), though not Ie The Scripture union, {br example, initially, resisted the charismatic influence. Pentecostal influences in the t'ellowships came indirectly fiom sources outside Ghana such as the ministries of American evangelists such as T. L. osborn, Gordon Linclsay. Oral Roberts. Kenneth Hagin and Morris Cerullo. However, the most direct vehicles of its spread in the t'ellowships were f'ellowships such as the GE,s and rhe university christian t'ellowships at the Universiry of Ghana and the university of Science and Technology and the existing classical pentecostal churches. of these the most influential was the GES. (See Samuel B. Aduborfour. Evangelical para chtrch Movements in Ghanaian Christianity, pp.192,215 - 220). 50 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships unknown, were not promi- nent in the activities of most of the fellowships. They were so concerned about the spiritual status of the individual with respect to the 'new birth' that many, from the start, did not pay any significant attention to miracles, demon-possession and other themes that have now become central to the teaching of the Charismatic movement. These were to become predominant later. Salvation The salvific goals of the fellowships were more other-worldly than this- worldly. They therefore emphasised denial of self and the world as a means of pursuing salvation. They regarded life as temporary and therefore less important than 'eternal life' which was a central theme in their preaching. This was captured in the song, I have another world in view, in view; I have another world in view. My Saviour is gone to prepare me a place- I have another world in viev,. And also stanzafour of Golden.Beiis numbered 3I which was one of the most liked songs of the fellowships: Then let our songs abound; And every tear be dried. We are marching through Immanuel's ground To fairer worlds on high. Chorus. We are nrarching to Zion B eafifu| beautiful Zion We are ruarching upward to Zion The beautiful city of God. Every -Believer Ministry The fellowships were lay-movements. Their non*denominational status meant that they did not depend on ordained ministers to minister to them. Individual Christians were imbued with the sense of responsibility to do some service for God. The teaching was that every believer had been called to be a witness of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. The 'Great Commission'was said to have been given to every believer. So one-on-one sharing of the gospel, street preaching at dawn which they called 'dawn 51 Abam.fo O; Atiemo broadcast', mass open air crusades and visits to schools by vorunteers to preach the gospel became very common, Teams that brought together people who believed they had identified their coulrron spiritual gifts were formed in many of the fellowships. For example, there was the prayer team, which was variously referred to as, 'Power House', or 'Prayer Tower'. There were also personal or house to house evangelism teams, worship teams, choirs and hospital/prison visitation teams. The importance of private devotion as a means of growth They prornoted the culture of 'Quiet Time'. Believers were encouraged to set aside a few minutes (usually between fifteen and thirty rninutes) each day, especially in the morning, to pray and study the Bible. Devotional books prepared and distributed by the SU,20 and the IBRA2, and other The Importance of Prayer Prayer, like Bible study, was a central activity of the feilowships. prayer meetings were unusually long. corporate prayer took the form that iras come to be described as 'chorus prayer'. In this kind of prayer, everybody prays aloud at the same time. This kind of prayerwas until then associated with the AICs and the Pentecostal churches. prayer vigils or ,all-night, became a major feature of the fellowships, with the GES and some others making it a regular weekly affair. Other Teachings Apart from the above there were many other teachings of the fellowships That give insight into the major religious concerns of this periocl of Christian renewal in Ghana. For example, the 'redeeming love of God' expressed in the atoning death of Jesus christ the son of God was at the centre of their theology. Everything else revolved around this core- theme. Consequently, related themes such as holiness, forgiveness, healing and the 'new birth' came to be stressed. 20 The s. u. provided two books - The Daily Guirte tb, adurts and Daillt power for juniors. Both were in English. '' The IBRA provided Lightfor our path in borh English and the leading mother- t0ngues ol'the country. 52 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships A life of practical holiness and sanctification was taught as a necessary proof of the spiritual good standing of the believer, It was taught that the uncompromising holiness of God that led him to give up his own Son to suffering and death on the cross ought to evoke in the believer a sense of repentance and a desire for holy living, Such teachings generated a general sense of other-worldliness in Ghanaian Christians. For the fellowships, Conversion to Christianity meant a total break with the standards of the world. It was maintained that the changed inner lif'e of the believer ought to be reflected in outward behaviours. Fellowship members were therefore marked by modesty in dressing, their staying away from secular entertainment programmes, and turning away from anything that they considered this-worldly. But such expression of other-worldly piety was combined with a rather unusual sense of social responsibility and practical involvement in society with the aim of transforming it. This was expressed in several ways, including prayers, preaching, and forms of social action. For example, the GES had as its motto,oservice to God, Service to man'and saw its mission as 'rebuilding the broken walls of Ghana'. The intense prayer sessions held for the country sometimes produced prophecies about the political future of the country. For example, there were prophecies that were interpreted as predicting the various political upheavals that occurred in the country, in 1972, 1979 , and 1 98 I as well as events in other parts of Africa. 22 There was a strong belief that it was only the gospel of Jesus christ that could save Ghana fron-r the political, economic and social crisis of the period. The conviction that conversion to Christ and prayer held the only hope of salvation fbr the nation, partly inspired enthusiastic evangelistic activities, including mass open-air crusades dubbed with nationalistic descriptions, for example, 'Ghana for Christ Crusade.'Arnong the leading 22 Aduborfuor quotes t'rom a Memoranclum on Charismatic Christianitv in Ghana in u'hich the author'. a tbrmer stlrdent christian leader. shares his experiences of prophecies. In the document tl're author claims to have fbretold the overthrow of the civilian government ol Ghana's flrst republic as well as Iater developments. (See AclLrborfuor', Evangelical PcLra church Movements, p. 209. In a written response to enquiries I made. the Rev EnochAgbozo, fbunderand leader of the GE,S, ctaimed that there rvcre prophecies predicting the election victory of President Limann" the fall of the Apartheid regime in South Africa. and the fall of communist Russia. other proplrecies concerned the Rawlings'revolution of 1979, and he Liberian war. 53 Abamfo O. Atiemo Inspirational songs at such crusades was what came to be regarded as a national prayer for revival: the Ghanaian classical pentecostal hymn, If you believe and I believe and we together pray; The Holy Spirit will come down and Ghana shall be saved. And Ghana shall be saved! And Ghana shall be saved! The Holy Spirit will come down and Ghana shall be saved. The belief that the hope of national salvation lay in the hand of God seemed to have been shared by many. The Ghana Evangelical Society preached the message of surrendering the nation to the reign of God and discarding elements of traditional religious spirituality such as pouring of libation at state functions. The society used to organise, on its own initiative, an annual 'national week of repentance and prayer.' In June 1977 , through the influence of some religious leaders, an official ,National week of Repentance and Prayer' was organised by the government of General lgnatius K. Acheampong, The speaker at the ecumenical church service that crowned the activities of the week was the Rev. Abraham De- Love of the Philadelphia Mission and one of the frontline players in the evangelical movement. Though he was the pastor of a church, he preferred to describe himself as an'international evangerist'since ine title 'evangelist'was the most respected title in that era of christian renewal in Ghana. Established ecclesiastical titles such as, bishop, archbishop, minister or pastor were not fancied since a rnajor criticism against the established churches by the fellowships was that they had become more concerned about formalisms and worldly glory than the eternal salvation of people. Then also, there was the general belief thatthe Second coming of christ was imminent and the conviction that the conversion of many Ghanaians to christ would lead to God's blessing for the nation, raised the work of the evangelist above all others. The selection of the Rev. De-Love to preach at a state function was significant. It was the first time a preacher outside the mainline christian community had been featured at such function. previous governments had used, mainly, ministers of the mainline Protestant churches and the Roman Catholic church.23 But the use of De-Love, a prominent leader of the evangelical movement on that occasion, did not indicate the acceptance of " J, s' Pobee. Religion and Politics in Ghana: A case study of the Acheampong Era (Accra: Ghana Universities Press. 1992) p.S. 54 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships evangelical values by the General Acheampong's government. It appears he was the one with the strongest pretensions to intellectualism among the assorted cohorts of religious advisors that the general had gathered around himself. Most of these advisors belonged neither to the mainstream mission-instituted churches nor the classical Pentecostai traditions but to 'fringe groups'24 that did not also quite fit into the then fast proliferating African Independent Churches (AICs). Most of such pastors claimed to have been trained in Europe or the United States of America (USA) and adopted forms of spirituality that couid be placed between classical Pentecostalism and the AICs. They included Bishop Blackson of Bethany Church, who was rnade the Chairman of the Councii of the University of Science and Technology, Rev. S. T. Afutu, Rev'Yeboah-Koree of the F'Eden Mission. Some of these pastors were also the first to preach the American version of what has come to be calied the 'prosperily gospel', which is now associated with the Charismatic churches. In those days, the pietistic message of -the fellowships did not allow the admittance of such teaching as authentic.t' What De-Love had in collmon with these pastors was not evangelicalism but their suppoft for a regime that had serious deficits of credibility'o ancl Arnericanisms in language and fashion. The credibility of De-Love himself as a Christian leader was swept away together with the general with the fall of his regime. Nowhere was the belief that the transformation of the country could be effected best by mass conversion to Christ more strongly felt than on university campuses where two main routes to national salvation were being adveftised to the youth. Young intellectuals were generally divided between 'scientiflc socialism'and evangelical Christianity; though some of thern tried to combine the^two views and preferred to think about Jesus Christ as a revolutionary.-' [t appears the general disenchantment that followed the failed attempts to transform the society through violent revolutions in 1979 and 1981 left evangelical Christianity in its dominant 'o J. S. Pobee. Religion and PoLitics in Ghana. p.9. " When later. Bishop B. A. Idahosah of Nigeria visitecl Ghana and preached a message in the veirr of the prosperity gospel several sections of the evangelical movement rebuked hinr and disassociated themselves tiom that aspect ofhis teaching. r6 Sce Pobee. Religiott ancl Polirics in Gltarta. p.9. -' Ahamfo Atiemo. 'Singing with Understanding: The Story Gospel Music In Gl.rana'. StLLdies in llbrld Christianity Vol. 12, Part2, 2006, p. 153. 55 Abamfo O. Atiemo Charismatic version as the only real option open to most youngrspeople concerned about the socio-economic transformation of the country. Evangelical Christians were also involved in various social services. The best organised of social service activities was 'operation Help Nima' (o'H.N), which was started in the 1960s by evangelical students of the University of Ghana, Legon. The project was devoted to improving environmental conditions in the twin-slum suburb of Nima-Maamobi neai Accra, the capital city. This project included student volunteers devoting some time to clear heaps of refuse, providing technical services in thi building of places of convenience as well as education and advocacy through the publication and distribution of literature, documentary filmi, and discussions on radio, with tirne it became a national programme of the evangelical christian movelnent, with support from government and i nternational partners. The scripture Union Prayer warriors Ministry and 'Deliverance, The spread of evangelicalism to towns and neighbourhoods meant that the middle and lower level artisans and other people of low formal educational background became targets of the evangelistic efforts of the fellowships. This development presented challenges of its own. In the first place, ihe rather abstract and intellectual message of evangelical christianity had to be presented in the various mother-tongues in a way that would be understood by everybody, despite the level of their formal educational training. Initially, the SU was reluctant to take up the challenge. As a result, some former members of the su forrned the cooidinating committee of christian Fellowships (ccgF) in Accra to give direction to the town and neighbourhood fellowships. 2e But the most dramatic developments in this direction occurred in the inland regions of Ashanti and Brong Ahafo. A movement, dominated by mernbers of town and neighbourhood fellowships, dedicated to prayer as mQans of fighting against spiritual powers that are believed to be responsible for most of the suffering in the world emerged. This movement came to be known as the 'Prayer warriors Ministry' and was a movement within the SU. This movement was one of the movements responsible for the spread of the 'deliverance'ministry in Ghanaian christianiiy. Later on, 28 It is mostlv that generation that supplied the initial leadership and membership of the Charismatic Churches. 2e Acluborfbut Evangelical Para Church Movements, p. 85. 56 Th,e Evangelical Christian Fellowships Emmanuel Eni's book, Delivered from the Powers of Darbness3o which was a best seller in Anglophone West Africa, and seminars organised by Derek Prince,3l served to make deliverance more widely accepiable to the elite evangelical Christians in Ghana, who are currently mostly found in the Charismatic movement.32 Evangelists appeared whose speciality was 'deliverance,' They organised mass deliverance sessions at which they openly preached against the practice of witchcraft and the use of juju and invited their hearers who thought themselves witches or wizards to come forward for exorcism. They taught about how such things as ancestral curses, worship of idols, and involvement with the occult could affect people's fortunes in life, rnaterially and spiritually and urged people to seek 'deliverance' from thern. The foremost of such evangelists was Evangelist Akwasi Amoako.33 Such teachings accorded well with the temperament and world- view of the less educated, in particular, and Ghanaians in general. They squared with the general ten^dency to attribute events and occurrences in Iife to supernatural agency.'o 'Deliverance' is an irnpo-rtant feature of what paul Gifford identifies as 'Ghana's new Christianity."' The Fellowships and the Churches The fellowships discouraged the starting of new churches and insisted that their members remained with their original churches and serve as a 'leavening influence'. Their central concern was evangelism and renewal of the existing churches, especially, the mainline churches established through the activities of the 19th Century missionary movement. They considered these churches lifeless and in need of revival. Their n-rain r0 See Abamfo Atiemo. 'Deliverance in the Charismatic Churches in Ghana,'Trirtity Journal of Churc'h oncl Theologl,, Vol. IV, December/January, 1994-95, p. 44. rr Abamfb Atiemo, 'Deliverance in the Charisrnatic Churches in Ghana.'p.43. " When the 'deliverance' teaching began to spread many mainstream evangelicals opposed it. The SU. especially, resisted it and opposed the lbrmation of the praver Warriors Ministry which was dedicated almost entirely to 'deliverance.' r-tCephas Ornenyo & AbamfbAtiemo.'Claiming Religious Space: 1'he Case of Neo- Prophetism in Ghana.' Ghana bulletin of Theology. (New series. Vol,l. No. l. July. 2006). p.59. Adrrborfour. Evangelical Para Church Movements. p.362. '0.1. M. Assimeng. SaLvation, Soc:ial Crisis ancl the Httman Coidition (Accra: Ghana Universities Press. 1995), p.33. See also. Stephen E,llis & Gerrie ter Haar. Worlds of Power: Religious Thought and Political Practice in Africa (London: Hurst & Co. . 2004). pp.25.26. tt Giilbrcl. Ghana's New Christianity, pp.83 -102. 57 Abamfo O. Atiemo message was that the 'new birth'was a must for all who would be saved. A recurrent theme in their teaching and preaching was, .no church, no pastor, no rite, can save you. Only Jesus can savel. There was also a deep mistrust of the ministers of the mainline churches. The liberal theology most of them subscribed to, the formalisms of their liturgical traditions, and their general opposition to evangelical revivalist and Pentecostal ethos caused members of the fellowships to regard them as neither'born-again' nor'spirit-filled'.39 Members of the fellowships, for such reasons, also became suspicious of theological education in general and the major Protestant theological seminary the Trinity college in Legon, became a virtual 'no-go' area for them. The churches, in most cases, also viewed the fellowships with suspicion. In certain cases conflicts ensued between congregations and the fellowships. Initially, such conflicts occurred rnainly between the fellowships and the mission-instituted churches, which seemed uncomfortabre with the ,bom again' message, and later their charismatic ethos which seemed to question the effectiveness and the authenticity of their work and tradition. with tiure, friendship was lost also between the felrowships and the Pentecostals, especially some congregations of the church of pentecost. It is not very clear the issue that sparked off the conflict between them; especially, since those churches benefited most from the activities of the fellowships. The fellowships viewed the pentecostal churches, especially the church of Pentecost and the Assemblies of God as their natural allies. Therefore, they normally directed converts made in their evangelistic efforts to these churches. And in most cases, such converts were nominal members of the mission-instituted churches or belonged one of the AICs. Sonretimes, if they were sure the pastor of the particular mission-instituted protestant congregation was 'born-again,'they counselled the converts not to leave but stay and serve as agents ofrevival. It seems that the Pentecostal churches felt a sense of competition between them and the fellowships, especially as the latter turned more pentecostal in ethos and grew in influence over Christian young people. The 16 Abamfo Atiemo, The Rise of the Charismatic Moyement, p. 47. See also Abamfo Atiemo, Aliens at the Gate of Sodom and other Reflections (Accra: Presbel Printing Press. 1997). pp. 28-41. 58 Th.e Evangelical Christian Fellowships Pentecostals wanted to exploit the new situation of increased respect and wider acceptance of Pentecostal culture, which had begun to elrrerge, especially alrong the young and educated, by attracting their youth back and integrating therr properly into their churches. This desire led to the strengthening of existing youth and student groups and the formation of new ones, organised along the lines of the fellowships, in congregations and on school campuses, The Fellowships and Spread of Pentecostal /Charismatic Culture The importance of the fellowships in the Pentecostal/Charismatic renewal of Christianity in Ghana has not been given sufficient attention in the discussion of the subject. Yet, it was the fellowships, which more than any other factor, helped remove the image of 'Pentecostalism' as an expression of Christian spirituality, belonging mostly to people of low socio- economic status.'' Most of the leaders of the f'ellowships, especially the type referred to in this work as 'evangelistic associations,' and rnajority of the members were well educated: university graduates, graduates of teacher training colleges or, at least, products of second cycle institutions. Initially, they used mostly English as the rnediunr of expression at their meetings. Messages were translated into the local languages when necessary. Students on holidays and those who had completed their studies found the fellowships their natural places of worship. With this development, Pentecostalism increased in stature as a genuine and respectable expression of Christianify, and educated youltg Pentecostals, who previously had felt not very confident to identify with their own denominations and of whom the denominations were suspicious, became bolder and began to iclentify with the tradition.38 This was natural since the feilowships normally regarded the pentecostal churches as their natural allies.3e The Pentecostal and some Baptist r7 Accorrling to Larbi, the Churcl'r of Pentecost. for example. was rrp to i970. 'basically. a grassroot movement,...The movement as a whole was basically etl'ective in reaching onegroupofpeople-theilliteratesegmentsofsociety.'(E.K.Larbi, Pentecostalism; The tt Eddies of Ghanaian Christianity, p.197). T'he Ght,ro Evangelical Society Story; brLitcting a Nation for God ancl Christ( Accra: Churtu Evangelical Sociery. 1998). p.39. " Although the t'ellowships accepted the rnainline churches as churches rvith soLrnd doctrinal heritage. the general view was that such chlrches had too manv nominal members who r.r,ere actually. not 'born-again'. They categorised church people into 'church- goers' and'Christians'. 59 Abamfo O. Atiemo churches were regarded as churches that were'alive'. During this period, youth and students move- ments in the existing Pentecostal churches were established or strengthened and their influence extended to campuses of educa- tional institutions.aO The Bible study and prayer grorp, in the mainline churches also benefited greatly frorn this respectability gained by the Pentecostal/charisrnatic culture.u I Through the influence of the Ghana Evangelical Society (cES) and others, rurost of the fellowships came to emphasise the importance of the 'Holy Spirit baptism', stressing on speaking in tongltes and prophecy. The weekly Friday 'all-night' prayer meetings organised by the GES, for. example, were patronised by people from all over the country, and from different fellowship and denominational backgrounds. They also came to emphasise the doctrine of charismatic gifts and ministries, and encouraged christians to identify and develop them through prayer. opportunities were created by the fonnation of various ministries to enable those who had identified their gifts and ministries to use thenr to serve. In that sense the fellowships became virlual Bible schools that trained the youth for church-life and the spread ofthe gospel. This approach of the fellowships produced an army of young, enthusiastic, and gifted christians. some of these people became itinerant teachers and evangelists. They were well educated. They earned the descriptive title, 'free-lance evangelist'. Since the emphasis at this point was on evangelism, other titles such as'pastor','bishop,,,reverend, and the rest were not attractive. They were actually derided, in sorre cases. It was, ou [t appears. at a point. some classical Pentecostal churches began to resent the inf'luence o1' the f'ellowships on their young people and designed slrategies. such as fbrming students ancl youth movemellts to counter it. Some of these .or.,r.,.,t, *... the Pentecost Students arrd Associates (PENSA), which later became pentecost youth Evangelistic Movement (PENTYEM) and rhe Apostolic students Association (APosA). There were occasional reports of conflicts between the f'ellowships and Pentecostal churches in several parts of the counh-v. Reports tiom f'ormer members of the f'ellowships in the central Region. tbr example, indicate that mernbers of the church of Pentecost u,ho belonged to the t'ellowships were at a point given the option to choose betu,een the fellolvship and the church. But this was difficult for most of such mernbers since they actually joined the Church afler they had become convertecl through the work of the I'ellou,ships. ar sr-rch groups experiencecl steady growth beginning rrom trre early 1970s and born- again members of their congregations fbund comfortable company rvith them. (See Atiemo. The Rise of the Charisntatic Movement.p.29), 60 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships mainly, these people that became the founders and leaders of the contemporary Charisrnatic churches.a2 The independent charismatic churches were the direct offspring of the fellowships. Due to their non-denominational nature, rnany of the members of the fellowships were not seriously committed to their own church denominations. The denominations themselves were suspicious of thern and were not ready to give them space.a' Many of the young people with fellowship background, who felt called to be full-time church workers, were not easily accepted into the ordained ministry of the mainline churches, so such members of the fellowships became the natural source of the initial leadership and membership of the then emerging ,charis- matic ministries.'44 Several of such people eventually found their ways into the ordained ministries of the existing mainline or mission-instituted churches.as This development has been significant for the unprecedented sense of unity among the various Christian traditions in contemporary Ghana. The a2 Among sLrch people who have become inuuential leaders of the charismatic churches are. Rev. Tackie-Yarboi of victory Bible church, pastor Ben coleman of All People for Jesus Mission. Bishop Agyin-Asare of word Miracle church lnternational. Revs. Steve and Stanley Mensah of charismatic Evangelistic Ministry, and Rev. Ransfbrd obeng of the Calvary charismatic centre in Kumasi. These either belonged to the GES or, at least. occasionally visited its weekly 'All-night prayer, meetings. others are Pastor Mensah- otabil, of lnternational central Gospel church, who belonged to the Kanda Fetlowship and Archbishop Duncan williams of Action- Faith Ministries. who announced the launching of his ministry at the GES all-night on the Friday preceding rlre Sunday of the event. " Omenyo & Atiemo. 'Claiming Retigious Space,. p.67. '" Initially. the churches that are now ref-erred to as the Indepenclent charismatic Ministriei prel'elrecl to be called.'Ministries'. "'Among contemporary leaders of the mission-instituted churches that belonged to the evangelical fellowships are, the Most Rev Dr. Robert Aboagye-Mensah, presiding Bishop of the Methodist church p- Ghana. Rt. Rev.yaw Frimpong - Manso. Moderator o1'the Presbyterian church of Ghana. Rt. Rev Akrofi, Accra Bishop of the Anglican church, and Rev Steve Asante of the Ghana Baptist Convention. others are Rev. Herbert opong. clerk of the General Assembly of the presbyterian church of Ghana, Rt.RevFred Nnuro.BishopoftheKofbriduaDioceseoftheMethodistchurch, Rev. Godfied Banrfb, Director of E,vangelism and Missions of the presbyteririn church of Ghana. and Rev. Dr. Emmanuel Asante. former president of the Trinity Theological Seminary, Legon. There are countless others in the ordained miniitries of these Churches. 61 Abamfo O. Atiento presence of former'brothers and sisters in Christ'in the various confessional traditions, bound together not only by history but by common evangelical convictions and commitment to Charismatic/Pentecostal spiritualify, has served to further boost Christian unity in Ghana. The previous mutual suspicions, which in some cases bred mutual contempt because, denominations regarded each other as either 'non-spiritual' or given to 'ridiculous or false expressions'of spirituality have faded away. Another contribution of the fellowships was the strengthening of the existing prayer groups or charismatic movement in the mainline churches. Some of their members, as well as people with sympathies toward them, who had gained some influence in church and society lobbied church Ieaders and influenced decisions that contributed to the gradual acceplance of the evaflgelical messdge of the fellowships, and the eventual sympathetic appreciation of Pentecostai/chaiismatic culture with in those churches. Rev. Peter Barker, an English minister of the presbyterian church of Ghana, Mr william ofori-Atta, a prominent statesman and a presbyterian lay-person, affid Rear Admiral P. F. Quaye, a respected naval officer and a member of the Evangelical Presbyterian chdrch are a few of such people. Mr ofori-Atta became the chairman of the Ghana Evangerisrn Cornmittee (GEC), which was tasked by the Christian Council of Ghana ro promote ''evangelism thi'ough its member churches. Mr Enoch Agbozo, a former s6nior civil servant and founder and leader of the GES, was the secretary. A laity-based evangelistic programme designed and run by this committee, the 'New Lif'e for All'(NLFA) became an effective vehicle for renewal and church growth. Although the GEC did not deliberately promote charismatic spirituality, its message of 'new life' was so similar to the 'born-again' message of the fellowships that its programmes became the natural favourite of rnembers of the feltowships which belonged to the n-rainline churches. Eventually, sr"rch n.rernbers also came to be counted arnong the main agents for the spread of Pentecostal culture within the nrainline churches. uo The evangelical fellowships, with their non-denominational orientation and their message of the new birth, which required faith in Jesus christ alone and not the membership of any church, helped slow down the drift of the * Atiemo, |-he Rise of the Charisntatic Moyement, p. 30. See also, Omenyo. P e ntec ost outs ide P entecos tal is ru. p.277. 62 The Evangelical Christian Fellov,ships membership of the mainline churches to the Pentecostal churches. Their stand that it was more prudent to stay in your own church and help revive it than to leave for another one created a sense of mission in many young tuiembers of the rnainline churches who decided to stay and work towards renewal. Ascendancy of Charismatic Spirituality The iate 1980s saw the beginning of the gradual fading away of the evangelical fellowships, the reinvigoration and spread of the charismatic movement within the niainline churches, and the eutergence and growth ol the neo-Pentecostal or Charisnratic ministries. These developments plovided the context for the crystallisation of elements drtrwn from clifT'erent eras of renewal ancl traditions in the historical evolution of Ghanaian Christian faith-expressions in the Pentecostal/Charismatic form. They also led to the fading away of the doctrinal, litmgical and other distinctions that previously characterised Christian denominationalisrn in C hana." ' The development represented the culmination of a long series of waves and strands of renewal in the history of Christianity in Ghana. The evangelical fellowships constituted the watershed in the process'toward the charisruatisation of Ghanaian Christianify. The fellowships' acceptance and promotion of the Pentecostal /Charisrnatic ethos led to the effective 'de-denominqtionalisation' of what Pentecostals call 'the Holy Spirit baptism.' A major characteristic of the evangelical fellowships was their insistence on a personal relationship of every believer with Jesus Christ rather than the membership of any denomination as a necessary condition fbr salvation; and the Holy Spirit baptism whiclr was said to be a distinct second experience subsequent to conversion was said to be available to every believer, ilrespective of one's denominational background. The ethos of the evangelical fellowships had four significant results, which had special implications for the Charismatic movelnent in particular and Ghanaian Christianity in general. First, most of the youllg people who belonged to those fellowships did not have arry serious cornmitment to their own denominations and were more ready to accept other viewpoints on the prirnary basis that those viewpoints were biblical, than to hold on to t7 Kwame Bediako, Christianitl, in Africa: the RenewaL of Non-We,ttern Religion (Edinburgh: E,dinbulgh University Press. 1995), p.66. 63 Abam.fo O. Atiemo the traditional creeds of their denominations, which were mostly couched in phrases that were difficult to relate to their contemporary situation, and which they also viewed with suspicion. Secondly, many young Christians became equipped in preaching, witnessing and counselling. They grew enthusiastic and were searching for opportunities to use their spiritual gifts. This created a widespread culture of voluntarism among the youth with respect to evangelism and other forms of Church work. Young people, at their own financial expense, embarked on evangelistic activities without expecting any imrnediate material or financial reward. They did not even seek to be recognised by the official church. The converts made through such evangelistic efforts were directed to join any mainline Protestant church or one of the classical Pentecostal churches. Thirdly, the relish for charismatic gifts in the fellowships marked the beginning of the wide acceptance of the Pentecostal ethos by young educated christians, thus leading to the speedy removal of the prejudices generally held against that type of christian faith-expression. Fourthly, though due to the links between the SU and the GHAFES, many sections of the evangelical fellowships were regarded as movements for the highly educated, the neighbourhood and workplace fellowships served as the channels through which evangelical christianity was made accessible to rural communities and lower and middle level artisans and workers such as 'auto-mechanics, dressmakers, petty-traders, taxi-drivers, untrained school teachers, office messengers, and factory workers.,48 This was the case especially in Ashanti and Brong Ahafo. Many of such people were not of any high level educational background, yet, the combined influence of evangelicalism and Pentecostalism generated sufficient enthusiasm in some of them and they became involved in the founding and -growth of theneo-prophetic movement,ae which they currently domin-ate.s0 Conclusion The fellowships were the melting pot in which the differences between the various traditions were removed. Certain factors, all linked to the f'ellowships, made this possible. In the first place, worship forms of the oo Aduborfbur. Para Church Movements, p. 83. a'Omenyo & Atiemo. 'Claiming Retigioui Space'. p.58. soPaul Giftbrd, Ghanab New Christiinie,, p.89. 64 The Evangelical Christian Fellowships fellowships, which later became mainly charismatic, but included aspects associated with the mainline Protestant churches, such as their hymns, came to be seen as neutral and gradually came to be accepted as normal in the various churches. Most of the elements of contemporary Ghanaian Charismatic liturgy and other practices, such as 'praises and worship', 'testimonies', 'healing and deliverance' were nurtured and made widely acceptable through the fellowships. Even though some of these and practices such as everybody praying aloud at the same time at public worship, the use of drums, rhythmic clapping of hands and dancing at worship already existed in the prayer groups, they were deemed as practices mainly associated with the Pentecostal and African Independent churches. Such practices came to be accepted in almost all churches, including the Roman Catholic Church. The practice of creating 'teams' for various ministries, which is now so popular in Ghanaian churches, is also a legacy of the fellowships. Teams for special ministries such as 'praise and worship,, ,prayer,, :personal evangelism,'and others became popular with the spread of the fellowships. These have been inherited by the charismatic movement and have gradually spread within the various denominations as special lay-ministries. 65