No. XV of 1930-31. Gold Coast. CORRESPONDENCE RELATING TO A Scheme for Extending the . System of Village Dispensaries and Improving the Training of the African Nursing and Dispensing Staff. Ordered by His Excellency the A cti-ng Governor to be Printed. GOLD COAST: Pyinted by the Goveynment Printer at the Government Rrinting Office, Accra. To be purchased from the Gove rnment Pl'intil1g Office (PI~blicatiolls Branch), Accra, Gold Co~,st Colony, a1!d from the Crown Agents fOl' the Colonies, 4 , Millbank , London, S. W . I. 1930. Price-One Shilling . No. XV of 1930-31. . Gold Coast. CORRESPONDENCE RELATING TO A Scheme for Extending the System of Village Dispensaries and Improving the Training of t~e African Nursing and Dispensing 'Staff. Ordered by His Excellency the Acting Governor to be Printed. GOLD COAST: Printed by the Government Printer at the Government Printing Office, Accra. TOi be purchased from the Government Printing Office (Publications Branch), Accr.a. G'old Coast Colony, ' and from the Crown Agents for the Colonies, 4, Mil/bank, London, S. W. I . 1930. I. Despatch from the Govemor to the Secretary of State. GOVERNMENT HOUSE, ACCRA, 2nd June, I930. My LORD, I have the honour to refer to that part of the Report of the Committee, appointed by the Secretary of State in 1927, which dealt with a scheme for the creation and training of an auxiliary service of Medical Assistants, and to paragraph 16 of Sir Ransford Slater's despatch of the I7th "November, 1928, in which he informed Mr. Amery that he approved that scheme in principle and would submit his views after questions of details and costs had been settled. 2. The scheme first submitted by the Director of Medical and Sanitary Services (Dr. Inness) in 1928 followed closely the recommen- dations of the committee and was a costly one. The estimated capital expenditure on school buildings aLone, spread over three years, was £73,000. It ,*vas proposed to build the school for Medical Assistants at Korle Bu on such lines that it could be used eventually as a college for training Medical Practitioners, the idea being that if and when the I college scheme was proceeded with, the school buildings could be taken over by the col,lege and a new school for Medical Assistants built at Kumasi. Accommodation was provided for 90 students, 30 being taken in each of the first three years. The course was to be one of four years, and the total number of Medical Assistants aimed at was 2 SO. Recurrent costs, with the full complement of students, were estimated at £6 ,000 per annum, and it was calculated that the bill for salaries, when the full number of 250 Medical Assistants had been trained, would amount to ;,)6,500 per annum. To this had to be added £18,750 for the cost of necessary emp1,oyees, transport, travelling atld incidental charges, excluding drugs and dressings . . 3. These proposals were submitted to the Executive Council, and the Council advised that they were too costly. Conflicting views as to policy were also expressed with the result that the Governor asked Dr. Inness for his considered opinion as to whether such additional money as Government might be able to afford for medical needs in the next twenty years could most profitably be spent on 1. training, say, 120 Medical Assistants, or u. increasing the number of Medical Officers and permanent hospitals, or 1ll. increasi.ng the number of Medical Officers with travelling dispen- sanes. 4. Dr. Inness unhesitatingly advised the adoption of course (i), and was requesteato prepare a less costly scheme for consideration. At the same time, his attention was called to the Sierra Leone scheme which was submitted to the Secretay of State in Mr. Young's despatch No. 327 of 4 the 23rd June, 1929, a copy of which was supplied by the Governor of Sierra Leone for the information of this Government. 5. In November last, Dr. [mless submitted a simplified scheme. The course suggested was still to be one of four years and the curriculum similar to, but sl,ightly less full than, that proposed by the I927 committee. Accommodation was provided for a maximum of 40 pupils, and ten pupils would enter the school each year until 80 Assistants (the maximum number proposed) had passed out. At the end of the fourth year the first ten pupils would pass out and be posted as Medical Assistants to dispen- saries in various centres. Thus, in the fifth year there would be 40 pupils and ten Medical Assistants, and in the tenth year 40 pupils and 60 Assist- ants. Thereafter the number of pupils would decrease to a figure sufficient to maintain an establishment of 80 Medical Assistants. The capital cost of the modified scheme was estimated as follows :- £ School lecture rooms (at Korle Bu) 6, ISO Initial equipment 1,000 80 dispensaries and Medical Assistants' quarters (spread over eight years commencing from the fourth year) 57,000 In order to avoid the cost of non-essential buildings, no provision was made for hostels for the pupils, and it was proposed that they should live out and be paid at the rate of £48 per annum during their training. On passing out, it was proposed to pay the Medical Assistants the following salaries :- Medical Assistants £154- 10-£208 Senior Medical, Assistants £222-12-£282 Chief Medical Assistants £300-20-£400 The teaching staff required was one Medical Tutor and two Science Masters. Recurrent costs were estimated to rise from £2,590 in the first year to £29,700 in the twelfth and subsequent years. 6. The modified scheme, while less costly in every respect than the original proposals, was received at the time the Estimates for the current year were under consideration. A careful analysis of the financial position was made, and the Governor reLuctantly carne to the conclusion that it would not be prudent to provide funds for the scheme in those Estimates. At the same time Sir Ransford Slater remained of the firm opi~:on that an extension of the dispensary system was badly needed. In (he Gold Coast there are practically no dispensaries, except those attached to the 32 hospitals widely scattered through the Colony, Ashanti and the Northern Territories. Facilities for treatment are admittedly 111- adequate, and I append a minute in this connection by Mr. W. J. A. J ones (Secretary for Native Affairs):- " The fact that there are only 32 hospitals in th.~ Gol,d Coast and its dependencies, with a total area of 91,600 square miles, or in other words one hospital to approximately every 2,860 square mil.es, affords ample evidence of the necessity for providing more extensIve facilities for medical treatment, and I am convinced that every Political Officer with up-country experience will agree that this need can best be met by the establishment of dispensaries in the larger towns where there are no hospitals at present. • 5 " Owing to the expense which travelling and absence from their homes entail Africans who live in towns or villages situated some distance from district headquarters do not as .1 ruie consult the Medic;~1 Officers until native or patent medicines have failed to cure them of their particular diseases. The result frequentLy is that a patient is brough.t to a doctor only when there remains but little hope of his recovery. He dies in hospital, the faith of the inhabitants of his village in the superiority of the white man's medicine over their own is badly shaken, and aU suggestions from the Political Officers that other sufferers from illness should go into the district hospital for treatment are received with suspicion". This is a true account of the experience of all Political Officers who have interested themselves in the bodily well-being of the people urder their care. What 1 desire to emphasize is that if it can be avoided, we should not restrict the activities of the Medical Department and consequently the benefit of medical science to district headquarters and to the educated section of a district's population. To exemplify this argument let us take the case of the Keta district. There are several villages of con- siderable size both along the banks of the Vol ta and beyond the lagoon where Medical Officers are only known to the average inhabi- tant as unpleasant persons who appear on the scene, generally supported by the District Commissioner and Police, whenever there is an -outbreak of smallpox. To people such as these the value of proper and early treatment will remain unappreciated until we are able to introduce some such system as that advocated by Dr. Inness. The Awoame Fia has frequently, both in Legislative Council and in letters to Government, stressed the necessity for providing dispen- saries at Dsodje and elsewhere in his State. He certainly contem- plates, and with every reason, that, if his request is granted, the dispensaries will be visited at frequent and regular intervals by a Medical Officer, but I am convinced that the principal object which he has in view, as has every other Chief who makes a similar request, is to provide his people with some institution not too distant from their homes where they may obtain medicine for common ailments, dressings for their sores, and so on. " The dispensary buildings form the largest item of capital expenditure in the Director of Medical and Sanitary Services' scheme, and here I am sure we may count on the assistance of the Chiefs, most of whom would be prepared to pay either the whole or a considerable portion of the cost of a unit, i.e., dispensary and dispensers' quarters, which is calculated at £712 lOS. od. if built in concrete. In the poorer States the building would probably be made of swish and the cost reduced in this way as well as by the use of communal labour. '1 J " I am in entire agreement with His Excellency that the provision of dispensaries, 'iupervised and visited periodically by the Medical Officers, would prove a real boon to the people of the Gold Coast, and I strongly recommend that the Director of Medical and Sanitary Services' scheme for the training of Medical Assistants be adopted or, if the present financial situation renders this impossible, that additional dispensers be trained to take charge of the dispensaries which I confidently anticipate the native authorities themselves will provide if asked to do so by Government." Unquestionable, the addition of 80 dispensaries, served by trained assistants, who can render first aid and dispense medicines for the common forms of ailments, would be a real boon to the people of the Gold Coast. The Governor, therefore, felt that every effort should be made to provide these dispensaries and the necessary staff. . He instanced the fact that wherever he went on trek, he was asked by chiefs for the establish men t • 6 of dispensari s in their towns; and gave directions for the written opinion of Executive Council to be o\)taincu as to what ste.:ps could usefully be taken, in view of the chan ged financial position of the.: Colony, to deal with the problem. 7. I have obtained the views of Members of the Executive Council. The Colonial Secretary (Mr. Jackson), after reviewing the problem of how best to bring medical treatment within the reach of as large a number of the population as the present financial resources of Government permit, advises that the dispeJ1Sary scheme proposed by Dr. Inness should be proceeded with gradually, but he is of opinion (\i;lt there is no necessity to create and train 'a new grade of Medical Assistant. He considers that steps shou ld be take n to amplify the training given to dispensers so as to qualify them to take charge of village dispensaries, under the super- vision of visiting Medical ORicers, deal with ordinary dressings, ulcers and sores, render first-aid generally, and dispense stock medicines and other common remedies [or prevalent and well recognised ai lments. The Attorney-General (IVlr. Abrahams), the Treasurer (Mr. Kelly), the Secretary for Native Affairs (Mr. Jones) agree with the views of the Colonial Secretary. rile Director of l\Iedical and Sanitary Services (Dr. Inness) also agrees that, for the reasons enumerated by Mr. Jackson, the scheme should be confined in the first instance to the amplification of the training of dispensers so as to. fit them to take charge of village dispensaries. 8. The matter was discussed by Sir Ransford Slater with the Colonial Secretary and the Director of Medical and Sanitary Services in the first week of April; and the Governor directed that steps should be taken to initiate the system of training on the lines proposed by Mr. Jackson and agreed to by Dr. Inness. The latter, who has now submitted definite proposals to that effect, wri tes :- " Our present system turns out (\·\ '0 separate classes of worker; on the one hand nurses, \\ ho are quite untrained in dispensing, and on the other dispensers, \\ho arc only partially trained in nursing. 1 have no doubt whatever, and m)' opinion on the subject is fully shared by all the senior members of tbe staff, that a system of training which would, if it \\ere possible, combine that of a nurse with that of a dispenser would produce a type of man much better suited to local conditions and bound to be of greater assistance to a Medical Officer in his station, and to the general public. " The system I wish to introduce already exists in Sierra Leone and works there quite well. I would point out that it produces there the sort of man suitable for our projected scheme of Village Dis- pensaries, as well as one who can do the ordinary dispensing of a 110 pital or clinic. A Medical Tutor is included in the proposed scheme and he will be in a position to add an elementary training in midwifery, sanitation, etc., thus further enhancing the value of the final product of villagc dispensing \\ork." 9. The intention is to train tbe dispenser to become a first-aid administrant, an acti\·c health propagandist, and a general assistant to the Medical Officer, under whom he works. The training will be carried out in the Gold Coast Hospital and in the Dispensing S~bool in Accra, but, to obtain the fullest benefit, it is essential that a su itable lecture room should be provided. All students will join the service as Nurses-in- training, the title of Dispenser-in -training (,It'{' item [6 of the Estimates) being abolished. They will sp nd alternate months in the hospital wards and in the Dispensing School. At the cnd of three ycars, they will be eligible to sit for the exam ination for nurses when, if successful, they will be appointed Second Divisiol1 N llrses on probation. They will the~ 7 continue their training in the wards and the dispensing school until th ey pass the Examination for Druggists. When this has been passed, they will be eligible for appointment as dispensers in charge of village dis- pensaries, or be required to serve in a Government hospital if the requirements of the service so demand. The course of training will last from three and a half to four years. The grades of Chief Nurse and First Division Nurse will be abolished in the case of men, and in their case posts above the grade of Second Division Nurses will be classified ::is Dispensers, First Division Dispensers and Chief Dispensers. The train- ing of female nurses will contil:1Ue as at present, and the grades of First Division Nurse and Chief Nurse will be retained for them. IO. Dr. Inness has been able to effect appreciable reductions in both capital cost and recurrent expenditure as compared with the costs of his modified scheme (see paragraph 5 supra). The cost of the dispensaries and quarters for the dispensers remains at the same figure (£57,000) but expenditure on these buildings will be spread over a period of eight years, commencing from the fourth year from the introduction of the scheme. I would observe, however, that there is every reason to anticipate that the Native Authorities will them- selves provide many of the required dispensaries and quarters (s ee Mr. Jones's minute quoted in paragraph 6 supra) so that the commitments of Government in regard to those buildings is not expected to be heavy. The only other capital expenditure will be £850, which is the estimated cost of a modest building to serve as a lecture room for 40 pupils. The following increases of establishment are involved: - (a) Eighty additional dispensers to staff the required number of village dispensaries. (b) A Medical Tutor. The increase of 80 dispensers will be effected gradually, and the only immediate increase contemplated is ten nurses-in-training to be added to the strength from the inception of the scheme. N urses-in-training will be paid at the rate of £48 per annum, and the salaries for qualified dispensers will remain the same as at present, viz . :- Dispensers £54-6-84; £r IO-8-158; £174-IO-224 . (See paragraph IO of, and enclosure 2 to, Governor's despatch No. 144 of the 19th February, 1930). First Division Diso- pensers £222-12-282. Chief Dispensers £300-12-396 . A field allowance of £36 per annum will be paid to dispensers when attached to village dispensaries. The Medical Tutor is required to organise and supervise the course of training, and to lecture in elementary chemistry, physiology' , anatomy and pharmacy. Dr. Inness recommends the appointment of a Medical Practitioner to the post with salary as for Medical Officers, West African Medi.cal Staff, and with Staff Pay of £150 per annum in lieu of private practice. Including the salaries of the Medical Tutor and the additional dis- pensers, the recurrent cost of the scheme will rise from £1,696 in the first yea,r to £5,774 in the fifth year, £r8,374 in the tenth year, and £24,372 in the fifteenth year, by which time it is anticipated that 80 full y qualified dispensers will be available for the village dispensaries. 8 11. It is propo cd to t()mmel1C~ th new !lcheme of trnining in July with Ihirl\·- thr'" tud nls, namely the ten additional nur es-in.training ref rred to in pnragraph 10 abo e, and twenty-three students who will be appointed to fill vacancies in the xisting estahlishment of nurses and dispel1!:lers. 12. The schcm' repres 'nts an earnest effort to extend the benefits of medical treatmcnt to as many of the inhabitants of the Gold Coast as the present financial situation permits. It involves a small initial expenditure and does not commit Government to any large increase of recurrent cxpenditur cven when it is fully ·developed. I trust, therefore, that Your Lordship will sec fit to approve thc proposals outlined in paragraphs <)-1 T of this dcspatch. In that event, T shall be glad if early teps may be taken for the appointment of a Medical Tutor. As soon as Your Lordship's approval is received, the construction of the lecture r00111 will be begun, and the engagement of tbe ten additional nurses-in- training wi 11 be proceeded wi th. 13. A copy of this despatch is being sent to Sir Ransford Slater, who expressed his agreement generally with the scheme before his departure. q In conclusion, I desire to place on record the ability with which Dr. Inness has prepared the various schemes which have been considered, and the readiness 'which he has shown to amend those schemes to meet the changed financial circumstances of this Government. Those amendments have, I know, entailed much work on his part. I have, etc., G. C. DU BOULAY, Acting Govemor. THE RIGHT HONOURABLE LORD PASSFIELD, P.C., ETC., ETC., ETC. II. Despatch from the Secretary of State to the Govemor. No. 635. DOWNING STREET, JIst July, I9Jo. SIR, I. have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your despatch No. 389 of the 2nd of June, and to convey to you my approval of the proposals outlined in paragraphs 9 to I I for extending the system of \'illage dis- pensaries and improving the training of the native nursing and dispensing' staff. . 2. I agree that, having regard to the financial position of the Colony, it would not have been prudent to proceed with the scheme for the creation and training of an auxiliary service of native Medical Assistants; but I consider that the present proposals are sound and practicable, and I endorse your remarks concerning the care and industry which Dr. Inness has applied to the consideration and preparation of the various propo als whic', have been under examination. 9 3. As regards the appointment of a Medical Tutor, I shollid 11 <.: g lad if you would consider in the first instance, whether there is any officer on the existing establishment of the Medical Department whom you could recommend for the post. This would seem preferable to the appointment of a candidate from outside, as it would ensure that the officer would be one who has had some experience of local conditions. 4. If, however, there is no officer on the existing staff whom you would wish to recommend for the post, I shall endeavour to find a suitably qualified candidate, and I propose to inform the selected officer that he will be a member of the West African Medical Staff, assigned to this post; but that, if he finds the work of training the African subordinate staff uncongenial, or if the responsible Medical Authorities so decide, he will then be liable for service as a Medical Officer as may be thought desirable. I have , etc., PASSFIELD. THE OFFICER ADMINISTERING THE GOVERNMENT OF THE GOLD COAST. Ill. D espatch from tile Govemor to the Secretary of State. GOVERNMENT HOUSE, No. 634. ACCRA, I6tlz September, 19jo. l\fy LORD, I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of Your Lordship's despatch No. 635, dated the 3 1st July, I930, approving the proposals for extending the system of village dispensaries and improving the training of the African nursing and dispensing staff in the Gold Coast. 2. The Acting Director of Medical and Sanitary Services , a copy of whose memorandum is attached, reports that there is no officer suitable for the appointment of Medical Tutor on the existing establishment of the Medical Department. I shall therefore be glad if steps can be taken to select as ~oon as possible a suitably qualified candidate for the post, as proposed 111 paragTaph 4 of the despatch under acknowledgment. I have, etc., G. C . DU BOULAY, Acting Governor. THE RIGHT HONOURABLE \ LORD PASSFIELD, P.C., ETC., ETC., ETC. 10 Enclosure to No. 111. MEDICAL DEPARTMENT, P.O. Box 138, VICTORIABORG, ACCRA, 2nd September, 1930. RESPECTING APPOINTMENT OF MEDICAL TUTOR IN CONNECTION WITH EXTENSION OF VILLAGE DISPENSARIES AND THE IMPROVEMENT OF THE TRAINING OF THE NATIVE NURSING AND DISPENSING STAFF. SIR, I beg to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the nnd August, 1930, attaching a letter from the Secretary of Stat.:= dated 31st July, 1930, and have to inform you that there is no officer in the existing establish- ment of the Medical Department on the Gold Coast that I can recommend for the post of Medical Tutor. Two Medical Officers that I considered might have successfully filled the appointment have declined the offer- one while { greatly appreciating the offer frlt that he had no aptitude for an appointment of this nature'; the other regretted the work would not be congenial to him. 2. Under the circumstances I request that the Secretary of State be asked to select a suitable candidate under the terms proposed in paragraph 4 of his letter. G. HUNGERFORD, A cting Director, Medical and Sanitary Service. THE HONOURABLE THE COLONIAL SECRETARY, VrCTORIABORG, ACCRA.