Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Reproductive Health https://doi.org/10.1186/s12978-023-01585-0 RESEARCH Open Access ‘Baby mamas’ in Urban Ghana: an exploratory qualitative study on the factors influencing serial fathering among men in Accra, Ghana Rosemond Akpene Hiadzi1*, Jemima Akweley Agyeman1 and Godwin Banafo Akrong2 Abstract Background Biological fathering, especially in patrilineal societies, was traditionally acceptable only in the context of marriage to the mother of the child. Many men were polygynous, often staying in one household with all their wives and children. However, this phenomenon has been on the decline in recent times, mainly due to Christianity, which encourages monogamy while frowning on polygyny. The Ghanaian family has for the past few years been undergo- ing changes due to migration, urbanization, and industrialization. With an increase in non-marital births and the dissolution of marital unions, multi-partner fertility is likely to increase. Contemporary Ghanaian perspectives on the circumstances that lead men to engage in paternal multi-partner fertility, otherwise referred to in this study as serial fathering, are scanty, hence this study examines the factors that lead to serial fathering among Ghanaian men. Methods The study employed the qualitative method, using in-depth interviews with twenty (20) serial fathers and a focus group discussion with seven (7) women. Results It was found that factors such as the attitude of women in relationships, the duolocal post-marital residential pattern, and the age at first birth are some of the reasons why some men father children with multiple partners. Conclusion The study concludes that both situational and personal factors account for the phenomenon of serial fathering amongst men in Prampram, Ghana, and these factors bring about distinctions in serial fathering as occur- ring either within or outside of marriage. Keywords Serial fathers, Family, Multiple partner fertility, Qualitative approach, Ghana Plain Language Summary In Ghana, men are increasingly having children with numerous women, whom they refer to as their "baby mamas." Contemporary Ghanaian viewpoints on the factors that motivate males to engage in this behavior are minimal. Consequently, this study examines the factors that predispose Ghanaian men to father children by multiple women. In-depth interviews with twenty (20) serial fathers and a focus group discussion with seven (7) women from Pram- pram, a suburb of Accra, Ghana, were utilized in this qualitative study. The results of the study show that men had children with different women due to the negative attitudes of women, which pushed them to frequently change *Correspondence: Rosemond Akpene Hiadzi rhiadzi@ug.edu.gh Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s) 2023. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecom- mons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 2 of 15 partners. The lack of a friendly relationship with in-laws, duolocal residence patterns, the non-observance of marriage rites, the young age of the first birth, and a continual need for companionship and sexual satisfaction were all factors that contributed to the practice. If these factors are addressed, it is anticipated that the prevalence of "baby mamas" in Ghanaian society will decrease significantly. This study also shows that family therapists and counselors should consider involving male clients’ spouses when counseling them about having many "baby mamas." Background data sources were not built to explore them. Petren A man who fathers children with more than one woman [9] also assessed the relationship between paternal consecutively is typically referred to as a "serial father." multiple partners (having children with two or more This frequently results in having several sexual partners, partners) and environmental chaos indicators among which is challenging for the majority of mothers who unmarried, non-resident fathers. Multiple paternal end up having children with such men since they end partners are related to environmental instability but up being referred to as "baby mamas." The phrase "baby not social support. Indicators include relationship inse- mama" is applied to mothers who are not married to curity, residential instability, job insecurity, and finan- the child’s father. Africa is not exempt from this; it has cial difficulties. evolved into a universal norm over time. Studying serial The study of multiple-partner relationships is, in fathering, which is also linked to having multiple part- accordance with Candia and Kisangala [10], a relatively ners, requires obtaining relationship data for all births, new area of study. Their study examined male multiple- which is not normally obtained when conducting fertility partner fertility in Uganda. According to their survey, studies [1, 2]. As a result, the study of serial fathering is 42% of males had multiple children. Age, being Muslim, a relatively new field of study in Africa because there is and being divorced or separated increased the risk of limited data [3]. multiple partner fertility, although being in the West, According to Yeboah et  al. [4] and Nyarko and Potter having a first sexual encounter after 19, and being mar- [5], serial fathering is on the rise regardless of whether or ried or cohabiting decreased it. There was a correlation not a man has lost his spouse. Throughout many parts of between the number of wives or partners and lifetime the world, divorce and having many children have been sex partners and the risk of having numerous partners. linked to having multiple fathers [6]. Serial fathering is Anecdotal evidence from Ghana suggests that men distinct from polygamy, which is the practice of marrying have children with multiple partners, (who they may many spouses simultaneously. Serial fathering can occur or may not be married to) in turns and one frequently without simultaneously marrying multiple partners, but hears men (particularly in urban and peri-urban areas) only after a divorce or separation. However, given the dif- refer to the existence of a "baby mother" or "baby ficulties that come with serial fathering, it has emerged as mama". Socioeconomic factors, such as the expecta- a crucial field of research for academics, as it is crucial to tion that men will provide their nuclear families with look at the factors that lead men to have several partners shelter, food, clothes, healthcare, education, etc., may and consequently become serial fathers. This is because contribute to this phenomenon [11]. One typical com- prior research has suggested that it is difficult for men munity where this practice can be found is, amongst who have children with numerous women to provide for the people of Prampram. Men were permitted to be the financial and social demands of all the families [7]. polygynous in traditional Ghanaian society, as well as Typically, children from past relationships suffer when in other African communities, and they often lived in more resources are allocated to the current relationship a single compound with all of their wives and children [8]. [12, 13]. Before marrying the second or subsequent Most research on serial fathering has been under- wife, the man often asks for the first wife’s consent and taken in Europe and the US, whereas few have been pays her a "pacification price"[14, 15]. Children also conducted in Sub-Saharan Africa, although this is a play an important role in such unions as they serve as developing phenomenon. According to Guzzo and social capital for their parents [16]. Dorius [2], multiple partnerships are being studied in But recently, monogamy has replaced polygamy as the US because they may affect parental, child, and the most socially and religiously acceptable option. family wellness. In addition, they emphasized that the However, men are still perceived as having children first step in studying a novel social phenomenon is to successively with various partners. Men opt to cohabi- characterize and assess its prevalence. In the case of tate or get married to one lady and have one or more multiple partnerships, this is challenging because most children with her. These men move on to new wives H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 3 of 15 when their marriages end. This occurrence is preva- there is a growing debate among feminist scholars about lent among urban and peri-urban residents. Whether how fathers often socialize their male children to aspire or not they were married, men might still father chil- to embody particular values and behaviors. Men in dren outside of their current families. However, there rural northwestern Ghana are likely to embody hybrid is a limited study on the factors that influence males to masculinities where traditionally hegemonic mascu- have multiple partners. Thus, the current study exam- line ideals—such as men being regarded as independ- ines the factors that influence serial fathering in Accra, ent breadwinners—and contemporary gender-conscious Ghana. This study is significant for two primary rea- norms—such as men as supportive presiding fathers— sons. It is most likely the first study in modern Ghana coexist. In subtle ways, however, the hybridization of to have addressed this significant gap in the sociology masculinity both challenges and reinforces patriarchal of the family literature in Ghana, and it is likely to be gender arrangements. By maintaining a keen interest in the only one. Second, concerning Dangme’s marriage their heteronormative breadwinning role as a model of and childbearing practices, the findings also offer a cul- masculinity, educated and gainfully employed men are tural viewpoint. critical of patriarchal norms that may be destructive to The remaining sections are as follows: The literature is feminist discourses, but their depictions of masculin- discussed in “Literature review” section, and the method- ity indirectly strengthen male hegemony in marriage ology employed for the study is presented in “Methods” relationships. Also, their results show that there is a lot section. “Results” section presents the study findings, and of ambiguity in how men define themselves as feminist “Discussion” section discusses them. In “Conclusion” sec- allies by supporting gender equality, but none of them tion, a conclusion is drawn. openly asks why women can’t also be breadwinners. According to Esson et  al. [21], research in geogra- Literature review phy and allied fields on gendered experiences in Africa Masculinities in Ghana has struggled to comprehend the nuances that com- A limited but expanding body of historical, ethnographic, prise the lifeworlds of young men. Their study examines and anthropological research in Ghana has attempted to the thoughts, actions, and experiences of male youth in comprehend gender in numerous domains of life before, Ghana through the lens of Guru’s popular song "Boys during, and after colonization. Prior to colonial control, are Tired," which is influenced by urban studies theo- the dominant school of thought contends, the Ghana- ries that demonstrate how music can be used to explore ian idea of gender was established as complementary social dynamics in Africa. Based on interviews and focus between men and women, although boundary mainte- groups with young people in Accra, the empirical find- nance remained prominent and pervasive [17, 18]. ings and analysis demonstrate how the phrase "boys are Miescher [19] examined the changing meaning of tired" and the attitudes it evokes constitute a subversive becoming a man in modern Africa through the life stories critique and protest against the precariousness of con- of eight senior men. In addition, the report concentrated temporary Ghanaian urbanism. "Boys are tired" encour- on the ideals and expectations that formed around prom- ages the problematic (re)calibration of gender relations inent men in their respective communities when Ghana on patriarchal terms. In two novel ways, these insights became an independent nation. How the men navigated advance discussions regarding the geographies of chil- complex social and economic transformations and dealt dren and youth and gender relations. First, the vernacu- with their increasing obligations and responsibilities as lar of "tiredness" generates novel theoretical perspectives leaders in their kinship groups, churches, and schools on a broader set of questions regarding youth agency and was also probed. Nevertheless, it must be acknowledged contemporary gender relations, specifically how young that Miescher not only explored masculinity and ide- people are implicated in the reproduction of patriarchy. als of male behavior but also provided a new perspective In doing so, their study identifies a troubling set of gender on African men in a century of transformation. In addi- relations occurring in Accra that are conceptualized as tion to community standards, the findings indicate that "retaliatory patriarchy," which consists of three constitu- missionaries and other colonial officials had a significant ent elements: entitlement, resentment, and ignorance. impact on notions of men and masculinity. The study’s Dery [22] further acknowledges that critical studies on findings also indicate that the transition to manhood and men and masculinities have gained considerable trac- a position of power, seniority, authority, and leadership tion in feminist scholarship over the past several decades. was not always welcomed or straightforward. However, the expanding focus of feminist scholarship Dery and Akurugu [20] acknowledged that there is has been on how individuals with male bodies construct, limited academic research on how fathers themselves negotiate, and express masculine identities. Despite this construct and represent masculinity in Ghana, although growing interest, there has been insufficient research into Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 4 of 15 how rural Ghanaian men construct and negotiate their discussed traditional and non—traditional parenthood, masculinities in intimate relationships. The findings show masculine roles, and becoming and being a father. In that dominant notions of masculinity offer a broad con- fathers’ parenthood experiences, male discourses influ- text for understanding the narratives, negotiations, and enced their relationships, occupations, and involve- experiences of intimate partner violence of the partici- ment with childcare. This study shows how uncertainty pants. The findings also suggest that father figures play influences the roles of contemporary fathers and how significant roles in shaping and enforcing the conform- they oscillate between traditional and contemporary ity of their sons to traditionally hegemonic masculine parenthood. ideals. These hegemonic ideals are so deeply ingrained Global South parenting emphasizes the customs and in the larger social fiber that questioning them is rarely experiences of motherhood [29]. A study examined how imaginable, thereby stifling alternative discourses. Even males are seen as fathers and how they affect young chil- more convincingly, this study suggests that fathers shape dren’s development in Botswana. The majority of fathers their sons into "men" who emulate their own actions. It is in Botswana feel their primary role is to manage the instructive that fathers experience pride when their sons family’s finances while raising children is the mother’s can live up to hegemonic masculine norms. The signifi- responsibility. Men don’t use support services because cance of these findings lies in their immediate revelation they lack parenting abilities. To promote father engage- of the range of implicit and explicit cultural messages, ment, a public research agenda is recommended. proverbs, and metaphors that fathers use to define "desir- able" and "undesirable" masculinity for their sons. In light Multiple partner fertility (MPF) of these findings, it is essential to emphasize that fathers’ Two types of multiple partner fertility (MPF) exist. The rigid enforcement of problematic gender identities can first one takes place outside of marriage. This is typical have negative effects on their sons, on women, and soci- among young fathers who are unmarried to their chil- ety as a whole. Importantly, when fathers strictly raise dren’s mothers. The other type of MPF is found in mar- their sons and then approve of their unbending behavior, riage. This type of MPF occurs when married males they make it harder for boys to find other ways to be men. father children with other women outside of their part- nerships [30, 31]. MPF is when an individual has bio- Fatherhood and fatherhood roles logical children with multiple partners [32]. Given the Modern fathers must supply, guide, help, and nurture. socioeconomic correlations of MPF and the repercus- These positions can strain men’s relationships with their sions of entering MPF for individuals and families, partners, their sense of purpose at work, and their self- understanding the prevalence of such homes is crucial. confidence as responsible adults. Due to the social nature Thomson et  al. [33] admit that multi-partner fertility of fatherhood, perceptions of parental engagement have accounts for over 20% of total fertility in the US. Coun- changed over time. The men’s ties to their own fathers, tries with high rates of first births outside of wedlock the nature of those interactions, and the father’s emo- also have high multi-partner fertility rates. Multi-partner tional availability all affect how they feel about father- fertility is more uniformly spread across older ages than hood [23]. Men emulate their fathers’ parenting styles single-partner fertility, which peaks in the early to mid- [24]. According to Meyer [25], fathers’ traditional roles 20  s. Although the possibility of multi-partner fertility have shifted from being moral teachers and mentors to has increased during the decades analyzed, the rates of being breadwinners, role models, and loving parents. multi-partner fertility have remained rather stable. Industrialization, economic instability and dislocation, labor market changes, and gender equality calls report- Factors relating to fatherhood with multiple mothers edly influenced these outcomes. In the past, fathers sup- Numerous studies indicate that several variables are asso- ported the family. Fathers now have a wider range of ciated with fathering in families with multiple women, a responsibilities, including involvement and child care, as phenomenon commonly referred to as "multiple partner a result of women having more access to the workforce. fertility" (MPF). These factors include: Depending on their socioeconomic situation, fathers negotiate these roles with their spouses [26, 27]. First‑birth‑age Lewington et  al. [28] confirmed that many men find Multiple partner fertility is correlated with the father’s fatherhood to be both rewarding and challenging. Their age at first birth. According to U.S. and U.K. studies [1, study investigates the effect of contradictory parental 30], men who start having children young are more likely responsibilities on men’s identities and how they negoti- to have children with different women. Young fathers may ate them. Conventional masculine conceptions of father- live with their children’s moms. Because cohabitation is hood were both upheld and rejected by fathers. Men less permanent than marriage, there’s a higher possibility H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 5 of 15 of remarriage and more children [34, 35]. Young individ- Fathers who report unintended pregnancies uals may not be able to work and support their families. Fathers who tell their spouses about unwanted pregnan- The inability to financially support children might lead to cies are more likely to have multiple relationships [49]. breakups and new partnerships. Black men between 35 By revealing unexpected pregnancies, they hoped to and 44 living in poverty report having children with sev- avoid penalties in the future. Grindlay et al. [50] studied eral mothers [36]. Fathers having two or more children unexpected pregnancies in Accra, Ghana. Nearly half of from many relationships seem to be at a disadvantage. females said their most recent pregnancy was unplanned, Matlakala et al. [37] reported that in South Africa, young and most felt at risk for future unexpected pregnancies. men can become fathers as young as 17, but Swart et al. Women were more likely to have an unplanned preg- [38] concluded that in KwaZulu-Natal, young men can nancy if they had previously given birth, made their become fathers as young as 14. Unmarried young men’s sexual debut between ages 8–14 instead of 20–24, or had relationships are precarious. Children from a previous 3–4 sexual partners rather than 1–2. partnership reduce the likelihood of parents marrying, causing men to have more children outside of marriage Men’s income [39, 40]. Couples are less likely to marry or live together The financial status of a man indicates whether he would if the father (but not the mother) has previous children father children with multiple women. Numerous studies [41]. Having children with several partners can cause show that men with higher incomes are more likely to friction and estrangement in a couple’s relationship fol- marry and establish happy families [47, 51, 52]. Poor men lowing the birth of a new baby. have more children [53]. They reproduce with multiple partners to reaffirm their masculinity. Their relationships Race and educational attainment will be unstable, and they will likely have children outside Fathers’ race or ethnicity is also associated with multi- of marriage. ple-partner fertility. Multiple partner fertility is more prevalent among African fathers, who are often polygy- Marriage formation in Ghana nous and take satisfaction in the number of children they Many Ghanaians value marriage because it serves as the may have [42, 43]. Men with childless wives want fertile foundation for determining who will perform reproduc- women. According to Kane et  al. [44], in-kind support tive, economic, and noneconomic roles [54]. Addition- accounts for a quarter of total support. Children receive ally, Ghana’s pro-family and pro-marriage ideology has in-kind support of $60 per month on average. Multilevel repercussions for social relations, and among the various regression analyses show that younger children with ethnic and linguistic groups, single women and men are longer visiting hours, high school-educated fathers, and frequently viewed differently from those who are married no substance abuse difficulties receive more in-kind care. [55]. This is gradually encouraging the majority of Gha- However, children whose fathers lack stable jobs or are naians to develop the practice of getting married young of African heritage receive more support in kind. Later [56]. Amoateng [57] makes the additional claim that qualitative research indicated fathers’ incentives for in- marriage is almost universal in Ghana and that having kind contributions are relational, not monetary. children is expected of couples. The family serves as the Men with more education were less likely to father cornerstone of social structure, the main provider of old children with more than one woman and were better age security, and the primary caregiver for the young. informed about their reproductive choices [45]. They The Children’s Act of 1998 and Ghana’s Constitution understand health better, are more likely to be married, from 1992 both specify the legal age of marriage and and raise healthy children. They reduce child behavioral union formation as 18 years old and forbid these activi- issues [46, 47]. ties before this age [58]. Under Ghanaian law, the legal age to marry is the same for all, which respects both traditional and Islamic unions. The laws of Ghana are A woman’s natal count superior to any religious doctrine, although the country’s Some believe that the number of children a man has with constitution guarantees everyone the right to freedom a single woman indicates whether or not he will have of worship. Therefore, it is forbidden in Ghana to marry additional children. According to Nisén et al. [48], father- anyone under the age of 18, whether for religious or cus- hood decreases a man’s fertility, but this does not prevent tomary reasons. When both families of the woman and men from desiring larger families because they can build man are aware of the union, a man and a woman are gen- social capital. Men are more likely to have children with erally accepted as husband and wife in Ghana. Addition- other women if they are married and their wives exhibit ally, the formation of marriages in Ghana serves to give signs of infertility. Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 6 of 15 couples companionship, a way to support one another, had a general notion about serial fathering that they and a legal means of engaging in sexual activity and pro- wished to investigate, but there was no prior knowledge creation [59]. Members of each family are checked for in the Ghanaian setting to explore it. diseases that cannot be cured or spread, criminal records, violent behavior, respectability, occupation, and religious Sampling and procedure background. However, a potential spouse must also meet For the study, a sample size of 20 male serial fathers and some important requirements before being accepted. 7 female participants was purposefully selected from Prampram. It excluded men who fathered children with Methods a single woman and those who fathered children with Study location many women but shared a residence with them and their The study was undertaken in Prampram. It serves as the children. For the purposes of this study, the women with Ningo-Prampram District’s capital in the Greater Accra whom the men had children were referred to as "baby Area. It has a population of 204,673 individuals [60]. In mamas." The inclusion of women was undertaken to addition, Prampram has two major suburbs: Upper Town acquire a gendered viewpoint on the subject under study. and Lower Town, which are made up of the four (4) com- In-depth interviews were conducted with the communi- munities of Lower East, Lower West, Kley, and Olowey. ty’s serial fathers, and a focus group included the women. These communities are home to the four major clans, Due to the nature of their occupation, meetings were which include the "Larkpl3," who live in the Lower East arranged with the identified serial fathers who agreed to and West, as well as the Kley, Anewey, and Olowey. Dan- participate in the study, and interviews were conducted gme and Ga are widely spoken there. at their residences and places of work (see Table  1). All One significant reason for the choice of Prampram participants were provided with information regarding as the study area is that it is a peri-urban community. the study, the intended use of the collected data, and the In other words, it has characteristics of both urban and anticipated interview duration. rural settlements. According to Tach et  al. [61], multi- An in-depth interview guide was developed to gather ple-partner fertility, or serial fatherhood, is prevalent in data regarding the factors influencing serial fathering. peri-urban areas and more so among low-income fathers. The in-depth interview collected data on the socio-demo- Prampam is also a patrilineal society where a child born graphic characteristics of the respondents, while Section into the family belongs to the paternal agnatic kin. In Two examined the factors that influenced their decision addition, the residential pattern is duolocal. The woman to have children with different women. The participant prepares meals at her home and sends them to her hus- interviews were conducted in Dangme and Ga (Ghanaian band’s home in the evening, where she passes the night. dialects), which was convenient for both the researchers The man could also come and spend the night in the and the participants. Before the interviews commenced, woman’s home occasionally. The women basically raised all participants were provided with information about their children in a matrifocal setting. When boys reach the study, the intended use of the collected data, and an puberty, they are sent to join their fathers on the male estimate of the interview duration. A 45-min-to-1-h-long compounds, while girls remain with their mothers. interview was conducted. All participants were consulted beforehand on the audio recording of the interview. Par- Research design and setting ticipants were requested to complete an informed con- The study employed a qualitative exploratory research sent form upon agreement. Throughout the study, the methodology based on phenomenology and the inter- confidentiality of personal information was preserved. pretivist paradigm. This research design typically collects Accordingly, no personal identity was associated with participant data for analysis through in-depth interviews the interviewees. In addition, the names used to present [62, 63] and focus groups [64]. The purpose of phenom- the analysis are all pseudonyms and do not correspond to enology is to characterize the meaning of concepts or the true identities of the participants. Due to the fact that phenomena from the perspectives of multiple individuals the interviews were done in the local languages (Dangme who encounter them [65, 66]. This research phenomenon and Ga), they were back-translated and transcribed into was chosen because it allowed the researchers to examine English. in depth the factors that influence serial fathering among Whenever necessary, field notebooks and interview fathers in Prampram- Accra. The sociodemographic fea- tapes were used to fill the gaps discovered throughout the tures of the participants and the factors influencing serial translation process. In order to verify audio recordings fathering in Prampram were among the issues investi- and transcribe interviews, peer debriefing and member gated in this study. The exploratory research approach checks were also employed. Before fieldwork began, ethi- was equally relevant to the study because the researchers cal approval for the study was acquired from the Ethics H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 7 of 15 Table 1 Socio-demographic characteristics of respondents Serial Fathers Age Current marital status Occupation Number of Children Number of “Baby mamas” John 41 Cohabiting Mason 8 4 Adjei 18 Separated Fisherman 3 2 Gabby 63 Married Farmer 5 4 Daniel 65 Married Fisherman 15 5 Joshua 53 Cohabiting Driver 3 3 Mike 30 Married Farmer 5 4 Simon 35 Married Unemployed 5 4 Raman 19 Single Okada Rider 6 3 Kwame 64 Married Carpenter 4 2 James 32 Cohabiting Carpenter 2 2 Kofi 24 Single Barber 4 3 Baba 32 Cohabiting Carpenter 3 3 Kojo 30 Single Steel Bender 5 3 Sammy 31 Married Okada Rider 12 3 Wise 45 Married Driver 4 3 David 19 Single Okada Rider 2 2 Kwesi 45 Cohabiting Civil Servant 4 4 Paul 58 Separated Tailor 6 3 Ali 55 Married Civil Servant 5 2 Ayi 53 Cohabiting Civil Servant 5 3 Women Age Current marital status Occupation Number of Children Martha 40 Cohabiting Fish Monger 4 - Abena 35 Separated Hairdresser 3 - Rejoice 32 Married Trader 2 - Abigail 38 Separated Seamstress 4 - Mary 33 Married Baker 3 - Rose 30 Separated Trader 4 - Grace 28 Married Hairdresser 2 - Committee for Humanities (ECH) at the University of prior responses and identify any discrepancies that may Ghana, Legon, with approval number ECH 085/18–19. have developed during the interviews and informal con- Using purposive sampling, 26 respondents were versation sessions. approached, but 6 of them declined, citing "I am terri- fied." Oh, as for you guys, you are interviewing me so that Data analysis you can send me to the Family Tribunal" and "I hope you The obtained data were analyzed thematically using won’t give my response to the media." With this feed- NVIVO software version 12 to run the codes, catego- back, the researchers utilized a gatekeeper to sample the rization of themes, and subthemes that arose from the remaining responders. This made the respondents more interview transcripts of the participants. The thematic at ease, as the gatekeeper informed them that the study analysis was conducted using both inductive and theo- was conducted only for scholarly reasons. retical coding techniques. Inductive and theoretical cod- The focus group was also held with seven (7) women ing approaches were utilized in the analysis since they in Prampram. This was conducted to determine the gen- assisted the researchers in identifying, analyzing, and der dimensions of fatherhood. It allowed the women to presenting data patterns. openly express their opinions on the topic under inves- For inductive coding, the researchers began by read- tigation and gave a woman’s perspective on the issue. ing the interview transcripts and paying close attention Several of the concerns examined were similar to those to relevant data concerns, which led to the development raised during the interview sessions. The primary pur- of descriptive codes. This was immediately followed by pose of the focus group discussion was to confirm the the identification of cluster themes, whose meanings Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 8 of 15 were evaluated in the context of the study objectives and realized she could not take care of me, let alone the refined in light of the reviewed literature. Similarly, the children, so after having one child with her, I left the reliability of the findings was ensured by contacting eight relationship. (Kojo, a 30-year-old father of five chil- of the participants to confirm the reported results as part dren with three different women) of the participant validation method. b. Suspected infidelity: A few fathers who decided to Results enter into new relationships with other women did so Research participants because they suspected their legally married wife was In the study, there were a total of 20 male serial fathers licentious. They often heard rumors from their fam- and 7 female participants. As was discussed in “Meth- ily members that these women had been seen with ods” section, the inclusion of women was undertaken other men in the neighborhood. As one respondent to obtain a gendered perspective on the phenomenon intimated: that was being studied. Table 1 provides a further pres- entation of the findings derived from the data that was My wife was flirting. Anytime I came back from work, gathered. my sister told me that my friend was in our room watching TV. When I confront her, she denies it and calls me names. Factors leading to fathering with different women One day, I saw my wife in a very compromising position The findings of the study show that six major factors con- with a man. I decided to leave her and go for another tribute to the prevalence of serial fathering among men woman. I am now with a different woman who just deliv- in Prampram, and these factors are discussed in greater ered a baby boy. (Ayi, 53-year-old father of five children detail below. with three different women). iii. Involvement in social vices: Alcoholism is one of the The attitude of women in relationships vices that discourage some fathers from staying in This theme describes the various ways in which the a relationship with their baby mamas. Alcoholism women that the men in this study had fathered children was seen as acceptable for men but not for women, with showed attitudes that were not favorable to them especially married women. As such, although and thus caused them to move on to father children Simon loved to enjoy his bottle of alcohol, he with other women. These unfavorable attitudes have could not accept similar behavior from his spouse. been grouped into four sub-themes, namely: disrespect According to him: and non-performance of wifely duties; suspected infi- delity; involvement in social vices; and maltreatment of I went on to marry a fourth woman because my stepchildren. third spouse started drinking. I was surprised that a married woman could drink so much. I know that I a. Disrespect and non-performance of wifely duties: also drink, but I could not understand how a woman Some men got involved with other women and had could drink the way she did. The worst part was children with them because, according to them, that, sometimes, she gave some of the alcohol to our their first baby mamas were not submissive and did 5-year-old son to also drink. I mean, how could she not perform their "wifely" roles to their satisfaction. do that? (exclaims...) Teaching a child how to drink? According to Joshua: No, I will not accept that. (Simon, 35-year-old father of five children with four different women) She did not respect me. If I ask her to cook for me, she will refuse. She did not wash my clothes. She iv. Maltreatment of step-children: The results from kept our room untidy always. When I complain, she the study also show that for some other men, their insults me very well. I could not contain her behav- motivation to have children with multiple women ior, so I went for another woman and left the room stemmed from the maltreatment their current for her. (Joshua, 53-year-old father of three (3) with partners meted out to children they had with previ- three different women) ous partners. Although at the onset of the new rela- That woman was dirty and lazy. She will watch TV tionship, the women displayed love towards their all day. Sometimes, when she is cooking, she leaves stepchildren, they soon changed their attitude once the food on the fire and goes to sleep. When I try to they had children with the men and began to show talk to her nicely about doing housework, she will preferential treatment towards their own children ask me if I don’t have hands to also do the work. I H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 9 of 15 while maltreating their stepchildren. According to they nearly fought. I had no option but to let her go. James, The woman I am married to now was suggested to Things began to change when I me by my mother. (Sammy, 31-year-old father of 12 brought Sandra (my 9-year-old daughter from a children with three different women) previous marriage) to stay with us. I observed how For others, it was the spouse’s family that did not accept my second wife, Mamle, tried to prevent Sandra or acknowledge them as spouses for their daughters. from interacting with her daughter, Benedicta. San- Kwame was forced to divorce his wife since his in-laws dra was not allowed to touch any item bought by disapproved of their union from the beginning. Accord- Mamle. I was not happy with what was happen- ing to his assertions, ing in the house. I spoke about it to my wife, but it always ended up in a quarrel. The situation became I had two children in my first marriage, but that worse by the day. It has gotten to the point where she relationship eventually ended simply because my will not even allow Sandra into the house when I am in-laws never approved of my relationship with their not at home. I have decided to end my relationship daughter. They kept interfering in the marriage until with Mamle because I love my daughter Sandra very we went our separate ways. The children stayed with much and I cannot afford to see her being maltreated their mother after the divorce. My ex-wife remar- by Mamle. (James, 32-year-old father of two children ried, but I am able to visit her and the children with two different women) anytime I feel like it. I am also married to another woman now. (Kwame, 64-year-old father of four children with two women) Strained in‑law relationships This theme describes how, according to the findings, Whatever form these strained in-law relationships took some fathers were compelled to leave their first baby and wherever they originated, it was viewed as a reason mamas for new relationships due to the constant quar- to end the partnership and seek out other partners with rels and misunderstandings that ensued between their whom they might develop healthier in-law relationships. spouses and their family members. To them, such unhealthy relationships did not need to be perpetuated, The Duolocal pattern of residence and the best way to avoid them was to end such rela- This theme describes a cultural element existing among tionships since there was no end in sight to the strained the Ga that was seen by both the men and women in the relationships between their spouses and their family community as facilitating the incidence of serial father- members. For some, it was their spouses who did not like hood. In the interviews, twenty-five (25%) of the fathers their family members, as indicated in the quote below: who did not share the same residence with their spouses I never thought I would have children with more reported that they found it easy to get into other relation- than one woman. I grew up in a polygynous home. ships based on this residential arrangement. It is a com- I saw how my late father had a hard time manag- mon practice in Prampram for couples to live apart, as is ing his home. Hardly a day passes by without one characteristic of the Ga-Adangme. The following narra- fight or another. Anytime my stepmother fought my tives illustrate the theme: mother, I was always sad. I vowed to marry only In my heydays, I slept with different ladies anytime one wife. But things didn’t go as I planned. The first I wanted because I was staying in my father’s house woman I courted was a thorn in my flesh. She always while my wife was also staying in her father’s house. had issues with my mother. I tried my best to get her I had money and I could take the women out. I only to stop, but it was not working. I eventually had to had to pick a fight with my wife whenever I wanted break up with her because I was tired of the fact that to be with a different woman. She will get so offended she always quarreled with my mother. I did not like that she will refuse to bring my food and sleep in it at all. (Gabby, 63-year-old father of five children my house at night for even more than a week some- with four different women) times. Then bingo! I got the opportunity to explore As the following quote shows, for some individuals, it and have fun. Those were the good old days. That was the members of their own families who did not get made me have children with many women. (Daniel, along with their spouses. 65-year-old father of 15 children with five different women) My mother always had issues with the woman who We have a young men’s room in the family house. had children with me first. She just did not like her. Once I get a girl who agrees to my proposal, I just One day, when she came to visit me at my house, send her there. My girlfriend is not aware of it. Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 10 of 15 (Adjei, 18-year-old father of three children with two money for it. She became pregnant again. Hmm... different women) Her family was asking me to perform the rites or On days that my woman does not come to sleep in risk losing her. Unfortunately, I still could not per- my house for one reason or another, I just go to town form the rites, so eventually, her father asked her not and get myself another woman. It is not too difficult to see me again. It was difficult for me, but being a to get a woman to sleep with you. Unfortunately for man, I have also moved on. (Joshua, 53-year-old us, some come with pregnancies. (Wise, 45-year-old father of 3 children with 3 different women) father of four children with three different women) A discussant from the female focus group believed that This notion about the residential arrangement fueling the men in the community were just not committed to the practice of serial fatherhood was corroborated by the having a relationship with a woman that would lead to women in the community during the focus group discus- marriage simply because they preferred to have multiple sions as well. According to one discussant, sexual partners. According to her, My father married my mother, and they had three Men here don’t like marriage. They propose to you, of us. I did not know my father till I was about 10 and as soon as you agree, they start sleeping with years old when he visited us at my mother’s father’s you. When you become pregnant, they present two house. All along, my father had been living in his bottles of schnapps to your parents, and that is all. father’s family house. My mother told me that she Before you know it, they are sleeping with other used to spend the night at my father’s family house. women and having children all over the place. I call Being a fishmonger, on nights of bumper catch, she them "yεnk⊃ nkoaa " (translated as "let us keep had to stay all night to smoke the fish and so could going"). (Martha, 40-year-old, cohabiting) not spend the night with my father at his family house. Unfortunately for my mother, she had the This shows that it is somewhat simpler for males to shock of her life when she found out that my father seduce women without following the customary proce- had impregnated another woman. That was the end dure of formally seeking the woman’s hand in marriage of their marriage. Thinking of the incident now, I from her family and then performing marital rites. This believe this residential arrangement made it easy for phenomenon pushes men (who may already be fathers) my father to cheat on my mother. (Abigail, 38-year- to have children with various women at various times. old,Separated) First‑birth‑age and related factors The findings from the study also show that the early onset Non‑performance of marriage rites of childbearing facilitates multi-partner fertility among In this section, the study shows how men who have chil- men in Prampram. About 10% of the fathers in this study dren with women they are not married to or have not stated that they started giving birth at an early age and completed marriage rites within patrilineal descent sys- at a time when they were not prepared to handle the tems have weaker social identities. Such men are not responsibilities that came along with having children. recognized by their would-be in-laws as legitimate hus- The following narratives exemplify the theme: bands. Daughters are therefore requested by their family members, especially their fathers, to end their relation- My first child was born when I was 17 years old. My ship with such men until they perform the marriage rites. parents were farmers, and I would go to the farm The responses from some fathers indicated that their with them. Though I had wanted to be enrolled in unions were not approved by would-be in-laws because school, it did not happen for me. I had a number of of their non-performance of the required marriage rites. female friends. One day, I slept with one of them, Thus, anytime they had a problem or disagreement in and she became pregnant. My parents took respon- their relationships, the women were advised by their sibility for the pregnancy till she delivered. They relatives to quit. According to the study’s findings, one warned me not to sleep with her again. By age 26, I respondent responded by retracing how his relationship realized I had three children. Hmmm... now I have 5 with his first baby mama ended, stating: with 4 women. (Mike, 30-year-old father of five chil-dren with four different women) We had been seeing each other for about three years, While I was in secondary school, I impregnated one although I must admit I had not yet performed the of my classmates and had a son (Isaac) with her. necessary marriage rites for her. In the second year, My mother took him and cared for him while I sent she became pregnant. Initially, I was preparing her money occasionally for his upkeep. After my to perform the marriage rites, but I could not get polytechnic education, I got married by ordinance H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 11 of 15 to Maku. It was a big wedding which was the talk As previously alluded to, this demand and the failure of of the town. We stayed in one of my father’s houses. certain women to meet it led some of the fathers in our After 8 years of marriage, I went to have a child with study to end their relationships with their first, second, or another woman in my village. My wife found out third baby mamas and begin seeing other women. and filed for a divorce. (Ayi, 53-year-old father of five children with three different women) Discussion I had my first child when I was seventeen years This qualitative study examined the factors that drove old. I was then in JSS Two. I had to stop my studies men in Prampram, Ghana, to have children with numer- because my mother, who was then taking care of me, ous women, a phenomenon referred to as "multi-partner could not afford to take care of me, my girlfriend, fertility." For the study, "serial fathering" refers to the and our baby. When she delivered, my mother asked practice of fathering children born to multiple women. her to come and stay in our house so that things Serial fathering thus occurs both inside and outside of would be easy for her. But that was where all the marriage. It occurs in marriages when there is suspicion problems started... I saw that she wasn’t a wife mate- of adultery, poor spousal behavior, and/or in-law inter- rial and decided to call it quits (Joshua, 53-year-old vention, all of which are grounds for divorce in Ghana. father of three children with three different women). According to the thematic findings derived from Having a first child at a relatively young age (in this the study, it is evident that men had children with sev- case, during adolescence) creates a situation in which eral women due to women’s negative attitudes, which men are unable to financially support their first baby prompted them to regularly change partners. Hence the mama and child, resulting in the breakup of the rela- study proved that men’s intolerance of attitudes such as tionship. Because these men were young, they were not disrespect and non-performance of wifely responsibili- mentally ready to make a long-term commitment to their ties, suspected infidelity, maltreatment of stepchildren, first baby mamas. In addition, the findings from the study and alcoholism resulted in the dissolution of their rela- show that several men fathered children with multiple tionships with women who exhibited these attitudes. women at an early age due to peer pressure. As stated by This is because the patriarchal character of Ghanaian a respondent: society places males in a position of control within their marriages, hence granting them certain societal privi- I was exposed to sexual activities early. We were leges that women do not have. In Ghana, marriage con- a group of friends who dared each other about the fers uxorem privileges to the man, such that the married number of ladies we could sleep with. At the time, woman is obligated to do domestic duties like cooking, we had no idea it would result in pregnancies. The cleaning, etc., and to sexually satisfy her husband, and the reality dawned on us when the ladies started get- avoidance of such acts leads to intolerance on the path of ting pregnant for us. It was not easy for us. (Raman, most men. This adds to the study’s findings, which show 19-year-old father of six children with three different that men in Prampram who had children with multiple women) partners considered respect from their partners and the performance of traditional roles of Ghanaian women as caregivers to be critical for the sustenance of their rela- The constant need for companionship and sexual tionship with them and continued childbearing with gratification This theme describes how internal factors such as the the woman. The absence of these, therefore, led them need for companionship and satisfaction of the sex to move on and have children with other women. The drive interact together to make men in the current study results were in line with the study by Van Hedel et  al. always desire to have women by their side, even though [35]. they may have had a previous negative marriage experi- Some fathers, according to the study, also felt the need ence. Such motivations are seen to be innate and related to move on to new relationships because they were con- to personal desires and characteristics. As indicated by a cerned that the vices that their current spouses were respondent: involved in would be picked up by their children. To prevent that from happening, therefore, they chose to Being a man and at my age, I cannot stay alone opt-out of those relationships. Also, although some without a woman. Beyond the satisfaction of my fathers had children with their current spouses, they still sensual urges, I need a woman to provide me with regarded the children from their previous marriages as domestic services; wash my clothes; cook for me to very important to them and would not allow them to be eat; keep my house tidy; etc. (Mike, 30-year-old maltreated by their current spouses. If current spouses father of five with four different women) did not show affection and love to their stepchildren, the Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 12 of 15 men did not hesitate to end such relationships and move in multi-partner fertility and become serial fathers even on to others if necessary. when they are on the wrong side of their marital part- Women in Ghana are typically expected to be more ners. The findings further state that fathers who did not faithful to their spouses than men. As Johnson and Young share the same residence with their spouses reported that [43] argue, a woman suspected of infidelity runs the risk they found it easy to get into other relationships based on of losing her marriage, but the same law does not apply this residential arrangement. Hence, it was identified that to men. A woman’s involvement in alcoholism is like- this is a common practice in Prampram for couples to wise culturally taboo, and such women are avoided by live apart, as is characteristic of the Ga-Adangme. men since they are regarded as a disgrace, and they are The results of the study also identified that the non- also scared of such behaviors negatively affecting the observance of marriage rites can also cause people to lose children they have with such women. This result was their spouses. This is because, in Ghana, marriages are consistent with Matebese et  al. [67] study. The findings not considered valid unless all marriage rights required further acknowledged that fathers who are close to their for legal recognition have been accomplished [74]. The children are sensitive to the quality of care they receive various ethnic groups have certain conditions that a and, as a result, will guarantee that their children receive man must meet for the union to be considered genuine. the utmost affection and care from their caregivers. In Hence, when a man does not fully fulfill the marriage cer- the absence of this, such fathers may take severe actions, emony, the bride’s or wife’s family may request custody such as abandoning their relationship with a woman who of their daughter until the man completes the marriage refuses to love and care for their children since they are payments. This is in accordance with the study con- not the woman’s biological children. This result is con- ducted by [75–77]. The study further acknowledges that sistent with the findings of the studies that were con- when women enter into consensual unions with men ducted by [22, 53]. who have not begun or completed the customary mar- The study also argues that strained in-law relation- riage rites required to be recognized as a married couple ships also prompt men to regularly change partners. This in contemporary Ghanaian society, micro-level factors is because, in Ghana, marriages are between families; it such as the need for survival, the need for a safe haven is not only the man and woman who unite for this pur- and the influence of a love charm are the driving forces. pose [68]. Families have a crucial role in the preparation It does not, however, imply that such relationships are for and maintenance of marriage [69]. Hence, to prevent socially acceptable. Thus, social structural factors such the dissolution of marriages, families not only approve as family influence prohibit such couplings, resulting in of prospective partners but also mediate marital issues. serial fathering. The findings from the study show that Therefore, if in-laws disapprove of the union, it becomes in Prampram, it is customarily expected of a man to first difficult, if not impossible, for the couple to maintain give notice (si womi) to the family of the lady they intend their relationship, even if they are ready to do so. Thus, to marry by providing two bottles of champagne plus strained in-law relationships have contributed to the dis- one hundred Ghana cedis (Gh₵ 100). This is followed by solution of marriages in Ghana and other Sub-Saharan knocking (Agbo simi), which requires the man to present African nations, a circumstance that pushes men to form to the family of the woman two (2) bottles of champagne, new relationships and father children without women. one (1) crate of malt, and one (1) bottle of Akpeteshi plus This is also in line with the study from [70]. five hundred cedis (Gh₵ 500). The man is then required Among the Gas in Ghana, the duolocal residential sys- to carry on with the request (sibimi) and acceptance tem is followed, in which the man and his wife continue (kplemi), for which they must provide two (2) bottles of to live in separate family residences after marriage [7]. champagne plus two hundred Ghana cedis (Gh₵ 200.00) At her husband’s request, the woman only visits the man respectively. According to the men who participated with meals she has prepared for him, cleans the house, in the study in Prampram, this was difficult for them to washes his clothes, and spends the night with him. Due achieve due to their low wages, which made them unwill- to the flexibility afforded to both men and women to have ing to marry the woman with whom they had children. several sexual partners, this living arrangement leads to This is consistent with numerous studies cited in the pre- a significantly greater frequency of promiscuity among sent study, which show that a man’s financial standing the population. According to studies conducted among determines whether he would father children with mul- Ga, this residence style also contributes to the preva- tiple women and that men with higher salaries are more lence of teen pregnancy among Ga [71–73]. As a result, likely to marry and establish happy families [47, 51, 52]. the people’s duolocal residence pattern—a practice Poor men have more children [53]. They procreate with unique to the Gas of Ghana—as reported by this study several partners to confirm their masculinity, resulting in provides a favorable environment for men to participate unstable relationships. H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 13 of 15 First-birth age and other related factors have also been run, social services such as health education in primary identified as factors that contribute to men having mul- and junior secondary schools increased access to family tiple partners. The findings from the study show that the counselling services, and increased access to reproduc- early onset of childbearing facilitates multi-partner fertil- tive health services in Prampram should also be made ity among men in Prampram. This is because the study available. Future policies and interventions aimed at shows that about 10% of the fathers in this study stated reducing the prevalence of serial fathering among men that they started giving birth at an early age and at a time in Ghana should include sexual education in peri-urban when they were not prepared to handle the responsibili- communities. ties that came along with having children. These findings concur with the studies from [1, 30, 45, 53]. These results all support the findings of the current study, which show Conclusion that the practice of serial fathering is influenced by first This study employed qualitative approaches to examine birth age in addition to other factors, such as low edu- the factors that lead men to father children with mul- cational attainment and low income as a result of the tiple women. Because of the unfavorable attitudes of early start of fathering. These factors all contribute to the women in relationships, the duolocal pattern of residence environment in which men father children with multiple strained in-law relationships, the failure to perform mar- women. riage rites, the first-birth age, and the constant desire for Finally, the persistent need for companionship and companionship and sexual gratification, it was discov- sexual fulfillment was also identified as the reason why ered that men ended up having different baby mamas. On men have multiple partners. According to the find- the surface, it could seem that these men made a mainly ings of the study, although men may have had unpleas- deliberate and planned decision to practice multi-partner ant experiences with marriage in the past, they still want fertility. However, a close look at these choices in light of women by their side for the company and the fulfillment the outlined factors shows that certain circumstances in of their sex drives. Additionally, this was a result of per- which the men found themselves influenced their actions. sonal preferences. In Ghana, men usually look to women Although the men admitted that they had hoped to have for assistance when it comes to providing domestic ser- long-lasting relationships with their spouses, the afore- vices, making them reliant on women for such services. mentioned issues had hindered them from doing so. This As a result, when their wives are unable to provide these explains why they initially began having children with services, they turn to other women, whom they occasion- them. We acknowledge the role that individual attributes ally impregnate and end up using to father their children. play in the tendency toward serial fathering and come According to the findings of the study, men’s continual to the conclusion that both situational and personal fac- need for companionship and sexual gratification sig- tors contribute to its occurrence. The limitation and nificantly influence their likelihood of having multiple avoidance of serial fathering will depend on an individ- children. This is in line with the findings of the study by ual’s capacity to avoid and/or control such factors. While [79–81]. social and cultural norms may not always push men into serial fathering, paternal multi-partner fertility or serial Practical implications fathering appears to be a way out of difficult situations for The study has implications for family heads in Ghana them. As a result, serial fathering occurs both inside and as well as for family counsellors and therapists. When outside of marriage. It happens in marriages when there providing men with counselling services on having sev- is suspicion of adultery, poor spousal behavior, and/or eral baby mothers, family counsellors and therapists in-law intervention, all of which are grounds for divorce should consider incorporating the partners of their in Ghana. It happened among the unmarried because of male clients. Additionally, the counsellors should lead early childbearing, a lack of marriage rites, and a persis- both spouses through pre-planned sessions for atti- tent demand for sexual fulfillment, which occasionally tude improvement. Furthermore, the family counsel- led to unintended pregnancies. lors and therapists should make every effort to inform Acknowledgements men of the need to form the habit of performing obliga- We thank all the respondents from Prampram-Ghana for their valuable tory marriage rites for their partners. The family heads feedback. in Ghana ought to counsel the spouses of these men Author contributions to develop the practice of getting along well with their RAH, JAA, and GBA conceived and designed the study, participated in the in-laws. The men’s families should also counsel them data collection, performed analysis and interpretation of data, drafted the paper, and revised the manuscript. RAH and GBA revised drafts of the paper to exercise more patience in their relationships, espe- prepared and revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final cially when young children are involved. In the long manuscript. Hiadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 14 of 15 Funding 10. Candia DA, Kisangala E. Determinants of multiple partner fertility There is no funding from any source. among males in Uganda: a cross-sectional study. BMC Public Health. 2021;21(1):1–8. Availability of data and materials 11. Adu-Gyamfi A. A house for the nuclear family: The case of Ghana. The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available Housing and Society. 2018;45(3):157–85. from the author (Jemima Akweley Agyeman-jemima_ocansey@yahoo.co.uk) 12. Tsai MC, Dzorgbo DB. Familial reciprocity and subjective well-being in on reasonable request as this is part of an MPhil work. Ghana. J Marriage Fam. 2012;74(1):215–28. 13. Addo I. Perceptions and acceptability of multihabitation as an urban low income housing strategy in Greater Accra Metropolitan Area. Declarations Ghana Urban Forum. 2013;24(4):543–71. 14. Wulifan JK, Mazalale J, Kambala C, Angko W, Asante J, Kpinpuo S, Kalolo Ethics approval and consent to participate A. Prevalence and determinants of unmet need for family planning We obtained ethical approval for the study from the Ethics Committee for among married women in Ghana-a multinomial logistic regression Humanities (ECH) at the University of Ghana, Legon, with approval number analysis of the GDHS, 2014. Contracept Reproduct Med. 2019;4(1):1–4. ECH 085/18–19. The objectives and benefits of the study were explained to 15. Osafo J, Oppong Asante K, Ampomah CA, Osei-Tutu A. Factors contrib- the study subjects. Informed written consent was obtained from each partici- uting to divorce in Ghana: an exploratory analysis of evidence from pant. For the illiterate participants, the researcher read the information sheet, court suits. J Divorce Remarriage. 2021;62(4):312–26. checked if they understood, and asked them to fingerprint when they agreed 16. Bawa S. Paradoxes of (dis) empowerment in the postcolony: to participate, and this was approved by the ethical committee. The right of women, culture and social capital in Ghana. Third World Quart. the participants to withdraw from the study whenever they wanted to do so 2016;37(1):119–35. was respected. The anonymity and confidentiality of the respondents were 17. Dery I. Ghanaian men and the performance of masculinity: negotiating ensured. All methods were carried out in accordance with relevant guidelines gender-based violence in postcolonial Ghana. 2018. and regulations. 18. Dery I, Bawa S. Agency, social status and performing marriage in post- colonial societies. J Asian Afr Stud. 2019;54(7):980–94. Consent for publication 19. Miescher SF, Miescher S. Making men in Ghana. Ghana: Indiana Univer- Not-applicable. sity Press; 2005. 20. Dery I, Akurugu CA. “‘Real Men’Support Their Wives”: Reconstruct- Competing interests ing Masculinity Among Men in Rural Northwestern Ghana. Hypatia. The authors declared that they have no competing interests. 2021;36(1):172–90. 21. Esson J, Amankwaa EF, Mensah P. Boys are tired! Youth, urban struggles, Author details and retaliatory patriarchy. Transactions. 2021;46(1):193–207. 1 Department of Sociology, University of Ghana, Accra, Ghana. 2 School of Man- 22. Dery I. “Give Her a Slap or Two … She Might Change”: Negotiating Mas- agement and Economics, University of Electronic Science and Technology culinities Through Intimate Partner Violence Among Rural Ghanaian of China, Chengdu 611731, China. Men. J Interpers Violence. 2021;36(19–20):9670–90. 23. Jessee V, Adamsons K. Father involvement and father–child rela- Received: 29 September 2022 Accepted: 19 February 2023 tionship quality: An intergenerational perspective. Parenting. 2018;18(1):28–44. 24. Mitchell JL, Lashewicz B. Generative fathering: a framework for enriching understandings of fathers raising children who have disability diagnoses. J Fam Stud. 2019;25(2):184–98. 25. Meyer J. Restructuring the Christian Fatherhood Model: A practical theo- References logical investigation into the ‘male problematic’of father absence. Theol 1. Guzzo KB. New partners, more kids: multiple-partner fertility in the Stud. 2018;74(1):1–1. United States. Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 2014;654(1):66–86. 26. Demontigny F, Gervais C, Larivière-Bastien D, St-Arneault K. The role of 2. Guzzo KB, Dorius C. Challenges in measuring and studying multi- fathers during breastfeeding. Midwifery. 2018;58:6–12. partnered fertility in American survey data. Popul Res Policy Rev. 27. Lam T, Yeoh BS. Migrant mothers, left-behind fathers: the negotiation of 2016;35(4):553–79. gender subjectivities in Indonesia and the Philippines. Gend Place Cult. 3. Fabiano GA, Caserta A. Future directions in father inclusion, engage- 2018;25(1):104–17. ment, retention, and positive outcomes in child and adolescent 28. Lewington L, Lee J, Sebar B. “I’m not just a babysitter”: Masculinity research. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 2018;47(5):847–62. and men’s experiences of first-time fatherhood. Men Masculinities. 4. Yeboah I, Okyere J, Dey NEY, Mensah RO, Agbadi P, Essiaw MN. Multiple 2021;24(4):571–89. sexual partnership among adolescent boys and young men in Ghana: 29. Trivedi S, Bose K. Fatherhood and roles of father in children’s upbringing analysis of the 2003–2014 Ghana Demographic and Health Survey. in Botswana: fathers’ perspectives. J Fam Stud. 2020;26(4):550–63. Tropical Medicine and Health. 2022;50(1):1–10. 30. Fomby P, Osborne C. Family instability, multipartner fertility, and behavior 5. Nyarko SH, Potter L. Levels and socioeconomic correlates of nonmarital in middle childhood. J Marriage Fam. 2017;79(1):75–93. fertility in Ghana. PLoS ONE. 2021;16(2):e0247189. 31. Amorim M, Tach LM. Multiple-partner fertility and cohort change in the 6. Lemmons BP, Bamishigbin ON, Cryer-Coupet QR, Lewis EM, Dorsey MS, prevalence of half-siblings. Demography. 2019;56(6):2033–61. Johnson S. Exploring the determinants of discipline and monitoring 32. Monte LM. Multiple-partner fertility in the United States: A demographic among non-resident African American fathers. Child Youth Serv Rev. portrait. Demography. 2019;56(1):103–27. 2021;125:106004. 33. Thomson E, Gray E, Carlson MJ. Multi-partner fertility in Europe and 7. Arthur-Holmes F, Busia KA. Household dynamics and the bargaining the United States. InAnalyzing contemporary fertility. 173–198. Cham: power of women in artisanal and small-scale mining in sub-Saharan Springer; 2020. Africa: A Ghanaian case study. Resour Policy. 2020;69: 101884. 34. Mata J, Richter D, Schneider T, Hertwig R. How cohabitation, marriage, 8. Brown NR, Schweickart O, Sinclair RC, Moore SE. Multiple partners, mul- separation, and divorce influence BMI: A prospective panel study. Health tiple strategies, multiple causes: Understanding why men and women Psychol. 2018;37(10):948. provide discrepant sex partner reports. In: Cognitive Development 35. Van Hedel K, Martikainen P, Moustgaard H, Myrskylä M. Cohabitation and from a Strategy Perspective 2017. p. 43–60. Routledge. mental health: Is psychotropic medication use more common in cohabi- 9. Petren RE. Paternal multiple partner fertility and environmen- tation than marriage? SSM-population health. 2018;4:244–53. tal chaos among unmarried nonresident fathers. J Soc Serv Res. 36. Assini-Meytin LC, Green KM. Long-term consequences of adolescent 2017;43(1):100–14. parenthood among African-American urban youth: A propensity score matching approach. J Adolesc Health. 2015;56(5):529–35. H iadzi et al. Reproductive Health (2023) 20:37 Page 15 of 15 37. Matlakala FK, Makhubele JC, Mashilo MW. Challenges of teenage fathers 63. Rutakumwa R, Mugisha JO, Bernays S, Kabunga E, Tumwekwase G, towards fatherhood in Vaalbank, Mpumalanga province. Gender Behav. Mbonye M, Seeley J. Conducting in-depth interviews with and without 2018;16(3):12013–20. voice recorders: a comparative analysis. Qual Res. 2020;20(5):565–81. 38. Swartz S, Bhana A, Richter L, Versfeld A. Promoting young fathers’ positive 64. Rutledge PB, Hogg JL. In‐Depth Interviews. The International Encyclope- involvement in their children’s lives. 2013. dia of Media Psychology. 2020:1–7. 39. Raley RK, Sweeney MM. Divorce, repartnering, and stepfamilies: A decade 65. Gill P, Baillie J. Interviews and focus groups in qualitative research: an in review. J Marriage Fam. 2020;82(1):81–99. update for the digital age. Br Dent J. 2018;225(7):668–72. 40. Smock PJ, Schwartz CR. The demography of families: A review of patterns 66. Talebian N, Uraz TU. The Post-Phenomenology of Place: Moving Forward and change. J Marriage Fam. 2020;82(1):9–34. from Phenomenological to Post-Structural Readings of Place. Open 41. McClain L, Brown SL. The roles of fathers’ involvement and coparenting House International. 2018. in relationship quality among cohabiting and married parents. Sex Roles. 67. Larkin M, Shaw R, Flowers P. Multiperspectival designs and processes in 2017;76(5):334–45. interpretative phenomenological analysis research. Qual Res Psychol. 42. Fagan J, Levine EC, Kaufman R, Hammar C. Low-income, nonresident 2019;16(2):182–98. fathers’ coparenting with multiple mothers and relatives: Effects on 68. Matebese S, Macleod CI, Tsetse N. The shame of drinking alcohol fathering. J Fam Psychol. 2016;30(6):665. while pregnant: The production of avoidance and ill-health. Affilia. 43. Johnson MS, Young AA. Diversity and meaning in the study of Black 2021;36(4):629–46. fatherhood: toward a new paradigm. Du Bois Rev. 2016;13(1):5–23. 69. Forkuor JB, de Paul KV, Ganee EM, Ndemole IK. Bride price and the state 44. Kane JB, Nelson TJ, Edin K. How much in-kind support do low-income of marriage in North-West Ghana. Int’l J Soc Sci Stud. 2018;6:34. nonresident fathers provide? A mixed-method analysis. J Marriage Fam. 70. Monk JK, Ogolsky BG. Contextual relational uncertainty model: Under- 2015;77(3):591–611. standing ambiguity in a changing sociopolitical context of marriage. J 45. Dariotis JK, Johnson MW. Sexual discounting among high-risk youth ages Fam Theory Rev. 2019;11(2):243–61. 18–24: implications for sexual and substance use risk behaviors. Exp Clin 71. Atobrah D, Awedoba AK. Men play, women break the town: gender and Psychopharmacol. 2015;23(1):49. intergenerational asymmetry in sexual and reproductive Worldview 46. Berrington A, Pattaro S. Educational differences in fertility desires, inten- among the GA of Ghana. Sex Cult. 2017;21(3):860–81. tions and behaviour: A life course perspective. Adv Life Course Res. 72. Tetteh PM, Markwei U. Situating the notion of “gbɛkɛfɔŋs” in the discourse 2014;21:10–27. of child sexual abuse among the Ga in Accra. Ghana Journal of child 47. Van Holland De Graaf J, Hoogenboom M, De Roos S, Bucx F. Socio-demo- sexual abuse. 2018;27(5):510–22. graphic correlates of fathers’ and mothers’ parenting behaviors. J Child 73. Tekpor SD. They call me a ‘bad girl’–Experiences of young mothers in Fam Stud. 2018; 27(7):2315–27. urban Ghana (Master’s thesis, NTNU).2019. 48. Nisén J, Martikainen P, Myrskylä M, Silventoinen K. Education, other 74. Dodoo ND, Atiglo DY, Biney AA, Alhassan N, Peterson MB, Dodoo FN. socioeconomic characteristics across the life course, and fertility among Does financial autonomy imply reproductive and sexual autonomy? Finnish men. Eur J Popul. 2018;34(3):337–66. Evidence from urban poor women in Accra. Ghana African Studies. 49. Stykes JB, Guzzo KB. Unintended Childbearing and Marital Instabil- 2019;78(4):477–95. ity: An Emphasis on Couples’ Intentions. J Divorce Remarriage. 75. Nuworsu A, Diabah G, Amuzu EK. “Look me, hwε ha, ofainε kwεmɔ biε 2020;61(7):504–24. aha mi fioo!!”: Codeswitching at inter-ethnic traditional marriage ceremo- 50. Grindlay K, Dako-Gyeke P, Ngo TD, Eva G, Gobah L, Reiger ST, Chan- nies in southern Ghana. Multilingua. 2019;38(3):283–311. drasekaran S, Blanchard K. Contraceptive use and unintended pregnancy 76. Bawa JA. Bride price in Ghana: An assessment of its social representa- among young women and men in Accra, Ghana. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(8): tions in selected Communities in Northern Ghana. UDS Int J Develop. e0201663. 2019;2(2):74–85. 51. Karney BR. Socioeconomic status and intimate relationships. Annu Rev 77. Ahortor G. Marriage, Sexuality and Moral Responsibility among the Tongu Psychol. 2021;72:391. Mafi People of Ghana. Legon J Human. 2016;27(1):71–94. 52. Mikolajczak M, Raes ME, Avalosse H, Roskam I. Exhausted parents: 78. Gbadagba G, Acquah EK, Empeh-Etseh H. Examining the significance of Sociodemographic, child-related, parent-related, parenting and visual artifacts in Anlo traditional marriage system in the Volta region of family-functioning correlates of parental burnout. J Child Fam Stud. Ghana. Res J Advan Humanities. 2020;1(4):54–69. 2018;27(2):602–14. 79. Obeng-Hinneh R. Negotiating entry into marriage: Strategies of Ghanaian 53. Gaddis I, Kilic T, Lechene V, Wolf A. Inside the Household: Poor children, women in ‘marriage-like’partnerships. Ghana Soc Sci J. 2019;16(1):54–71. women and men. New York: International Bank for Reconstruction and 80. Fiaveh DY, Okyerefo MP, Fayorsey CK. Women’s experiences of sexual Development; 2018. pleasure in Ghana. Sex Cult. 2015;19(4):697–714. 54. Bosiakoh TA, Agyei-Mensah S, Anarfi JK, Sarkodie AO, Sauvain-Dugerdi 81. Conley TD, Piemonte JL, Gusakova S, Rubin JD. Sexual satisfaction among C. The capabilities approach and agency for shaping family formation individuals in monogamous and consensually non-monogamous rela- trajectories in Ghana. Afr Popul Stud. 2018;32(3):89. tionships. J Soc Pers Relat. 2018;35(4):509–31. 55. Takyi BK, Lamptey E. Faith and marital violence in Sub-Saharan Africa: 82. Akpadago J. Causes of Marital satisfaction and the criteria of choosing exploring the links between religious affiliation and intimate partner vio- partners for marriage as Perceived by the People of Navrongo in The lence among women in Ghana. J Interpers Violence. 2020;35(1–2):25–52. Upper East Region of Ghana. Int J Innov Educ Res. 2020;8(9):310–20. 56. Hanrahan KB. ‘Mɔn’(to marry/to cook): negotiating becoming a wife and woman in the kitchens of a northern Ghanaian Konkomba community. Gend Place Cult. 2015;22(9):1323–39. Publisher’s Note 57. Amoateng AY. Socio-cultural correlates of changes in the timing of mar- Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub- riage in Ghana: 1988–2014. Gender Behaviour. 2017;15(2):8931–43. lished maps and institutional affiliations. 58. Amoako Johnson F, Abu M, Utazi CE. Geospatial correlates of early mar- riage and union formation in Ghana. PLoS ONE. 2019;14(10): e0223296. 59. Opoku JK, Manu E, Appiah DM. Same-Sex Marriage in Ghana: Scripture, Health Law and Bioethics.2021. 60. Ghana Statistical Service. Ghana 2021 Population and Housing Cencus. In Population of Regions and Districts (Vol. 3A). 2021. 61. https:// stats ghana.g ov. gh/ gssma in/fi leU pload/ press relea se/2 021 PHC General Report Vol 3A_Population of Regions and Districts_181121.pdf. 62. Tach L, Edin K, Harvey H, Bryan B. The family-go-round: Family complexity and father involvement from a father’s perspective. Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 2014;654(1):169–84.